- u
it depends on some specific circumstances... but it could be a possibility, yes
because you could very well be defending yourself from a very serious threat, but at some point you could be using excessive force... law states that your response has to match the level of the threat, and never to go overboard... and I think this is the instance, in which different people could have different opinions as to what would actually mean (also depends on the law of different states)
in this... if someone punches you first... it would be EXTREMELY unlikely, that you can just gouge out someone's eye with one punch back, something else must have happened as well, or something else could have been used
Most Helpful Opinions
All depends on the specific circumstances or situation you are in. You have the right to defend self defense, so if you are under attach you can fight back. Now it a matter of if a court of law or persecutor would consider you use of force, even in self defense, to be excessive. So if someone pushes you and you accidently gorge out an eye... that could be considered excessive even it was an accident you could have to prove it.
Additionally criminal charges aside... you could have a civil suit brought against you for damages.
In France you would cause there's no self defense laws (they're so shitty than if someone agrees you with a knife and you kill him with a gun you're the one who's considered as being the aggressor).
So yea in this situation you would be in deep shit.
As a rule of thumb self defence should be in proportion to the level of danger you're in. So if a frail little old lady gouges out the eyes of a 7ft stocky attacker it's OK.
What Girls & Guys Said
Opinion
18Opinion
I'm afraid of going to jail lol. Just see how I look in someofmy playful selfies:
I'm going to be immediately raped by everybody. I'm straight too. I wouldn't risk gouging somebody's eyes out. It's not worth getting plowed by prisoners. Being honest lolIt depends on the threat level and how well you can justify it.
If the attacker is smaller or close to your size and unarmed, then you probably will. If they’re a lot bigger than you then it can be easily justified.
There are plenty of cases of people being knocked out with a punch, hitting their heads on concrete and dying, even when the attacker didn’t intend to kill them.Technically yes. In reality probably not. You did not respond with deadly force. Law enforcement and the courts look at the LEVEL of force used AS WELL AS the result of the force. His eyes getting gouged out is unfortunate, but he attacked first and you defended with hands instead of a weapon and just happened to hit his eyes with your fingers. That is hand-to-hand so you still used the same level of force as the aggressor. Had you stabbed him that would be different.
Depends on the local law. Excessive use of force in self defense usually exists but there can be some major difference in how they are implemented. For example I am not sure its that comprehensive in USA where people appear to routinely shoot others to death when they only ever appeared to pose a non-lethal threat.
Depends on context.
If you're in a stand your ground situation, then it's unlikely you will get charged. but if it's an altercation in a public place then it's your criminal record vs theirs.Yes. But not guaranteed. Self defense could play a role in it, but there is still a chance you go to jail
If you can prove that it was in self defense; you shouldn't go to jail. But rather they should for assaulting you.
Really depends on the law where the crime was committed.
The outcome depends upon the law in the jurisdiction in which the event occurs.
Hmmm…that is a hard one. I think it really depends on how good your lawyer is. 🤔
Yes.. Self defence means you can use minimum force to restrain or prevent harm from the assailant..
Gauging out an eye is excessive force.It probably depends on the detail of what they were doing and if you had a reasonable fear that they would kill you or seriously injure you. If it was a punch, it’s going to be hard to argue that in court.
No, that' self defense and they got what they deserved.
There's no telling. People are wrongfully convicted.
Depends on the state. In my red state you’d be applauded
It will be difficult to convince prosecution that you didn't damage their both eyes unintentionally. Self-defense ends when the assaulter isn't dangerous anymore for the person who defends themselves
You seriously should be booked on a felony and locked up in Jail, have a mental evaluation and be barred from owning a weapon.
Fights are not like you see on TV. It usually results in jail or a lawsuit.
In true self defence and haven't gone to grab something and come back then no because you're defending yourself
In Germany you would be the villain, their laws would punish you by saying it was "overly violent defense".
Learn more
We're glad to see you liked this post.
You can also add your opinion below!