
Russia has warned Ukraine. Russia is very cautious about Nato. There is a group (NATO) that threatens the country (Russia). Russia thought about taking measures for this.

Russia has warned Ukraine. Russia is very cautious about Nato. There is a group (NATO) that threatens the country (Russia). Russia thought about taking measures for this.
I think it's an apsolute embarrassing hot mess for Russia. In the current state just about any other country with a half decent military could easily squish Russia at this point.
Russia is using military assets from the cold war and wwII and hasn't faced a centralized military in 60 years. 🤣 And it shows. Russia use to be the 2nd most powerful military and it's losing to the 22nd most powerful military. 😐
Ukraine is being led in terms of US support by mostly soldiers from the US are mostly either veteran status or haven't been in combat for 5-10 YEARS. And they are holding back Russians 🤣🤣 at this point a full on war with any major real military power vs Russia would be like a 300 lbs kicker in American football punting an egg at this rate. If Russia's elite tanks are having both the MG and tank turrets jam live in combat... I don't wanna know how fcked their nukes are 🤡. At the current rate I wouldn't be surprised if Russia's nukes are cold war era and the booster engines on the missiles are in a similar state to Chernobyl 🤯
Not to mention most of Russia's air Force are using dummy bombs. That are unguided low AND MORE IMPORTANTLY "SLOW" flying air strikes. For a military power that is suppose to be rival to the US it's pretty moronic to send your most expensive pilots and planes directly into the range of Qaams and javilins 😐.
Not to mention having not one but like 3 generals die in combat 1-2 go missing back at home and now a like 6th general has been instated 🧐
As if that's not embarrassing enough just about every war pre Ukraine and between the lines of like the cold war was fighting soldier based rebellions that had almost zero response to an apc or tank. So it's like no wonder Russia was way over confident. 😐
It doesn't help that Russian military relies mostly on training that relies heavily on fear and hazing. Most Russian soldiers dont usually make it past 1-2 years. Meaning there is an enormous gap between privates and the actual leadership. 😱 Yes generally speaking to reach the rank of like srg. Or Lt. We're talking like 3-4+ years experience. Meaning most of Russia's military is lead by a skeleton crew. Leaving the masses with no clue what's going on.
Lol soon the US is gonna suffer the same fate in their military ranks after they went woke
Ukraine will learn just like Iraq, Libya, Afghanistan and everyone else the USA "helped" that the USA isn't quite the friend they believe it to be.
yes this will be costly for them
NATO a defensive alliance cannot threaten to attack, certain members could go at it alone but there is no way to turn the defensive alliance into a offensive alliance.
It was never a threat to Russia, they just used it at a excuse, much as how they use rape as a weapon of war in Ukraine, raping women and children.
It is far time Ukraine starts hitting targets in Russia itself with terrorist attacks to get payback for the rape of its women and children. Set off a few dirty bombs in Moscow and other high population center and kill them all.
For every one person raped or killed in Ukraine kill a million Russians... and I hope Russian's end up living in fear for when the next terrorist attack could happen. It is far time they feel what they created, rather than let their neighbor live peacefully.
Russia can never win, even if they do, they'll be those suicide terrorist squads forever now... until they leave occupied territories.
Russia has also shown it see's treaties as something it doesn't need to follow, Budapest Memorandum is worthless. The rest of the world would be stupid to ever believe any treat that Russia signs. Ukraine should get nukes again to defend itself, as Russia has shown to be the aggressor.
I bet money you're very okay with this.
www.dailymail.co.uk/.../...killing-her-family.html
Should Afghans kill a million of us Americans for each Afghan woman or child a US soldier raped or help someone else rape?
www.nytimes.com/.../...n-allies-abuse-of-boys.html
Just to remind you that only a few individuals of the US military personnel who committed sexual crimes in Iraq and Afghanistan faced justice.
@CALIGVLA
Useless article if I'm not a subscriber, I can't see it but the US doesn't use rape or abuse as a weapon of war, like Russia is. The US at least admits it happens and has laws against it and public trials for those that have evidence. It tries to arrest and prosecute those that they can.
Russia orders their soldiers to do it... to motivate them. Hey go attack this village, there is some 14 year old girls, go rape them and conquer it.
Your also doing a false equivalency because Ukrainians did not do a 9-11 attack on Russia. They did not attack Russia first.
The US would not have invaded Afghanistan had they not attacked the US first on 9-11.
At this point I know your a Russian troll trying to defend your own raping of Ukrainian girls to make your conscience feel better... no one can support what Russia is doing without doing it themselves... so fuck off rapist. I'm don't talk to rapists assholes like you.
@bingbongbangbung
Spreading false information
The United States went to Afghanistan in 2001 to wage a necessary war of self-defense. On September 11, 2001, al-Qaeda terrorists attacked our country. They were able to plan and execute such a horrific attack because their Taliban hosts had given them safe haven in Afghanistan
@bingbongbangbung www.defense.gov/.../
I'm reading your speeches. I would say that Russia and the United States are very great powers. And they direct everything the way they want. The United States of America is an invader, a colonial state that is involved in every business. ABD Irak'a neden girdi. ? Nükleer silah iƧin mi? Nükleer silah bulamayınca ne düÅündüler? Bunlar sadece bir kaƧ ƶrnek. Büyük devletler büyük sorunlar demek. Rusya'da istediÄini almak iƧin ne gerekiyorsa yapacaktır. (illagal yada legal)
Ukraine's mistake was that it hugged Europe when it was next to a state like Russia. Europe is a spoiled child.
Ukraine's mistake was giving up the nukes after the collapse of the soviet union, should of kept them and eventually built the mechanisms to launch them. Then Russia would not invade them for fear of getting nuked. If they tried, fine by me if Ukraine nuked them.
Their current mistake is only attack targets in their own country, they should be hitting every Russian city as much as they can, with hit and run tactics, and terrorist attacks until they withdraw and give back the stolen territory.
Escalate it with no limits, dirty bombs in downtown Moscow, biological and chemical weapons attacks in the cities. Killing the civilians and schools/hospitals. Since Russia can attack hospitals and schools without consequences in Ukraine, they should be returning the favor.
Chemical and biological warfare is good by me too against Russia as they are using them in Ukraine.
I think the US and Europe should withdraw from the useless UN and give nukes/chemical and biological weapons to Ukraine to use against Russia.
They can nuke back, I'm fine with that... lets destroy the world, a world that allows rape to be used as a war tactic, doesn't deserve to exist... all those rape victims would be better off dead anyways. The rest of the world that is okay with this happening doesn't deserve to live either.
As a rape victim who is going to die from the damage done by my attacker, I don't give a shit... I wish he had killed me. Leaving me alive is far worse than killing their victims and I only have a couple years tops left anyways.
The USA has somewhat influence on almost any war and I'm tired of them playing world police. Having said that, people should stop killing each other, Putin deserves prison for life and Ukraine shouldn't join the NATO as they once agreed on with Russia. Boom.
absolutely
Russia also agreed to respect their sovereignty. That went well.
Opinion
61Opinion
It was set in motion back in the Bush years and continued into the Obama years. This conflict should be look at as more of a conflict between Russia, Ukraine and the US with NATO bringing up the rear. Because our government very much pushed for Ukraine to become interdependent and also provided various forms of military aid when both Bush and Obama where in office. Also the rest of NATO in a lot of ways fallowed our government into it
So this conflict has been brewing for a long time. It just so happened to finally boil over now. At this point we now have a proxy war between Russia and the US with Ukraine. Also the idea of the conflict having any kind of diplomatic is pretty much gone at this point. Our government is using Ukraine as a attack dog and people with in our government are more then likely going to keep giving Ukraine military and push them to keep fighting tell they can't. More then likely this conflict isn't going to be over any time soon and as time rolls on this moving from a proxy war to a full blown war between us and Russia becomes more likely.
Of course if it does turn into a full on war many people demanding that we help Ukraine will refuse to enlist and fight it. Because the vast majority of you arm chair generals are to pathetic and weak to put your money where your mouth is.
If you believe corporate media sources and politicians from any side are telling you the truth about this conflict, think again. There are some hints about which side is winning. Is the ruble rubble like Uncle Joe promised it would be? No. Is the Russian economy ruined? No, they are making much more money on exports since the sanctions than before the sanctions. They are making enough money to continue to fund the war indefinitely. Is inflation in the West skyrocketing? Yes. Energy and food costs are crushing all but the elite in Europe and will be severe in parts of the US this winter. We might see people in Europe go cold and deal with blackouts this winter. Industries in Europe have been shutting down, which is the only way they can reduce the cost of energy. What is certain is that the cost of energy in Europe is structurally higher even if they can find enough supply, and Europe will deindustrialize. Have US bond auctions had trouble due to lack of buyers? Well, yes, because the US has confiscated the dollar reserves of two countries now (Afghanistan, sending that population into starvation, and Russia), so non-Western entities are hesitant to buy US bonds due to the risk of having them stolen if they piss off Washington. What will this do? It will push up the yield on US treasuries, thus forcing the economy to allocate more capital into servicing public and private debt and presenting a headwind for economic growth. Has the US succeeded in isolating Russia from the support of its allies? No. China and Russia are tighter than ever and have an industrial capacity much greater than that of the Westās.
As for the battle itself, I have been following this war carefully and it is clear that Ukraineās losses are catastrophic, probably 7-10x that of Russiaās in terms of manpower. Russia allows wave after wave of Ukrainians to run headlong into its superior artillery firepower, at times retreating to preserve its own forces. Russia is reinforcing and has held their ground during the past couple weeks. With an increasing concentration of forces in Kherson, I expect this winter Russia will go on the offensive. Unless NATO intervenes more directly than it has so far (donāt kid yourself, there are already NATO boots on the ground as mercenaries and in Ukrainian uniform), Ukraine cannot win this war. But NATO has problems due to critical shortages of certain weapons and ammo due to donations to Ukraine, long lead-times for manufacturing its technologically sophisticated weaponry, and much less industrial capacity than the West used to have.
Donāt believe me? Time will tell. At the end of the day what matters is the real war, not the information war.
This is the most insane rant Iāve seen in a while.
I'm not gonna lie Putin had drafted from his prior service which tells everyone he's being slaughtered right now & the fact he keeps talking about nukes says where he's really at in the war. Russia has never been tough since the great soviet union and there only advantage on the eastern front was the Winter.
In Afghanistan they got whooped by the Muhajideen & the US supplied them.
They had a hard time in that Chechnya or whatever it's spelled country twice.
When they invaded Georgia, they also had issues and were getting slaughtered. Russians have never been tough they even had issues when they came to support Assad, had no idea how to handle all the terroist and foreign fighters to help protect Assad to remain in power. Russia was even scared to fight us in the Korean war & Vietnam. We abolished all Russian influences in South America during the cold War. The CIA destroyed them and destabilized any country working with them.
Although I agree Europe has special needs for investing all their trust in Russia after all NATO was built as an Anti Russian force incase of aggression. I think it's very safe to say Russia isn't tough at all.
@Fuentes Russia is indeed weaker militarily than the US, but that does not mean they are not ātoughā and is not as important as which power is being successful and which is failing and declining. Russia was much weaker during the Georgia conflict than it is now, but it won, hands down. It also learned from the conflict and updated its military technology. South Ossetia and Abkhazia successfully broke away from Georgia and the Georgian military was defeated. There wasnāt a thing the US could do about it except to stir up trouble elsewhere. Russia won in Syria. Assad is still in power, the US-backed Al-Qaeda militants were confined to an enclave, and the only question remaining is how the issues between Turkey and Assad will be settled. With Ukraine, the question isnāt one of toughness, it is one of effectiveness. Is the ruble being crushed? No. Is Europe being deindustrialized and disarmed? Yes. Is Ukraine ever going to recover its claimed territories? I doubt it, but we shall see.
As for Russiaās supposed aggression, I encourage you to read the Rand report on options regarding Ukraine and Russia. It stated that Russia was not seeking a conflict with NATO, but gave recommendations for NATO to force Russia into the conflict with the goal of destabilizing it and allowing the West to carve up and plunder its resources. It also warned how pursuing these actions could backfire. The US pursued all of the recommendations and the risks the report mentioned have all been realized or are in the process of being realized.
In Putinās speeches, you will find that when he brings up nuclear weapons he always does so in response to Western rhetoric about possible use of nuclear weapons. And NATO has revised its military standards to allow use of nuclear weapons in response to conventional warfare, regardless of whether or not the conflict is existential to the West. So I would suggest that you should not rely on Western media or government misquotes and lies of omission.
@RealMarek actually no most European countries like France have said if Putin throws a nuke they would not reepond in Nuclear war I don't really think it's a response if the countries that have nuke on the west have denounced using them if Putin decides to use one.
Putin makes those threats due to the US and NATO supplying Ukraine for the war which I don't agree with what so ever that we have spent more money to find this war already beating the whole war funding in Vietnam in the first 9 months just craY amounts being thrown towards it while we have inflation is disgusting to me. But that doesn't mean Russia isn't making threats I have seen it translated off their networks & their people making jokes of nuking the whole world if they have too tonwin the war. Like I said Putin said it out of the horses mouth and his war cheif did too. They decided to draft there own people who were prior service for war. That tells you they're not being slaughtered? I mean we both know places like Iraq and Afghanistan turned to rubble and was blown to shits even By there own people, yet they never stopped fighting. Also the war in Syria is still happening today, Assad would have always remained in lower their was no way of ousting him. Their way to many fireign fights fighting for way to many different causes the country is just a shit show I believe that war started because he denied the middle east pipe line from being built.
We took Baghdad in 3 days, it's been 9 months and Russia got pushed back to the border countries. When they had Belarus supporting them to use their country to take Kyiv, all I see is failed battles and failed oops. They took moat of their country back in Ukraine the only ones contested are the ones he's trying to annex but now Ukraine had launched a mass offensive. Their is full. on videos of combat and firefights in bordering regions and they're going hard. If Russia was so called winning he would have been had these countries in weeks.
You said they learned from Georgia. That's not true he came into Ukraine even more sloppily and had horrible logistics and could not even push trough as I said before. Russia should have been able to take Kyiv already. It was predicted that Russia should have had it in months but now it's been 9 months and the only thing he has done is showed the world how weak they're by drafting up their poor service cause the Gen z Era ain't getting it done lol
I said Europe is stupid and makes no sense why they even put all faith in Russia after being Anti Russia and of course Russia still remains in tact it would take years to bankrupt them maybe even a centuries they're the third biggest super power.
@Fuentes I agree with some aspects of what you say, especially about the contradiction between European reliance on Russia while simultaneously pursuing anti-Russian foreign policy. I think that is more an expression of multiple factions within Europe as opposed to outright irrationality, but I digress. Also, there is the massive spending on Ukraine and the destruction of Western economies for the effort. Makes one wonder why Western elites are so committed to this project. Might it have something to do with Ukraine having been a giant grift for politicians and their kids? When during recent memory have our elites not lied to us? Hmm...
As for comparing Iraq to Ukraine, there is absolutely no valid comparison. Iraq was not nearly as militarily powerful as the Ukrainian military at the start of this conflict and even currently. There are many reasons Russia did not pursue American-style āshock and aweā tactics. First, the Americans killed 15,000 Iraqi civilians during the opening weeks of the Iraq war and leveled its civilian infrastructure. It destroyed half of Serbiaās industrial capacity and killed thousands of Serbian civilians. It is one thing to do that when controlling the worldās most powerful propaganda machine. Itās another matter entirely when opposed to it. Also, the Russians would rather not mass slaughter civilians in Ukraine, many of whom are Russian ethnically or sympathize with Russia. The US had no such qualms about Iraqi or Serb civilians.
Again, unless you have read Putinās speeches directly from the Kremlinās website, you have been lied to when hearing the Western media and govāt translations or reporting of what he said. NATO officials are the only ones who have been threatening the use of nuclear weapons during this conflict. Some like Liz Truss have done so openly. The Russian statements have always been in the context of responding to those threats and have never mentioned tactical nukes for battlefield purposes.
oh you are delusional lmao.
I would recommend watching Alex Stubbs on youtube. A geopol academic, former Finnish Foreign Minister, former Finnish Prime Minister. He discusses the causes.
The Kissinger real politics school of thought says Ukraine should accept being a subordinate satellite of Russia- mostly for the benefit of other countries and peoples. But why should any country accept that is Stubbs reasonable point.
It was not Nato who was grinding towards Moscow, but those satellite states of the USSR wanting to be part of Europe who were leading the charge away from Russia. Look at Ukraine, at one point the third largest nuclear power. They gave up their entire stock of ICBMs in return for security guarantees from Russia, US, UK, France. More fool them.
What NATO threatens is RESISTANCE to Russian military invasion. It has article 5 which says an attack on one is an attack on all. It has no article that says if any member chooses to invade Russia it is an invasion by all. If Estonia is invaded by Russia then, yes, all NATO comes to their aide. But if Estonia decided to take back historic borders, it would be on it's own.
Plus, till the first invasion of Ukraine, Russia had a path to be slowly included into NATO or at least close embedded collaboration with it.
The NATO provocation theory is just a nonsense. I won't go through more otherwise it will be boringly long.
In reality it is Putin's dreams of empire and being a latterday Peter the Great that is what this war is about. Even as they were invading the Russian Duma was discussing who should be next.
by the way Xi Jenping has the same dreams of empire.
That's a lot of claims you're making without evidence from credible sources
@bingbongbangbung Well I would suggest that a Finish Foreign Minister and Prime Minister has a credible view as he has been inside the tent whereas most other people haven't been.
The Budapest and Minsk agreements are public documents if you google you will find.
The NATO rules are also publically available. These last two are not so much credible but definitive. The NATO Founding Act defining cooperation with Russia is similarly in the same category of definitive.
Timothy Snyder (Yale Professor) has done a good history of Ukraine if you are interested it is well worth the time to watch on Youtube. In terms of Putin's dreams of empire I take that mostly from Alexander Stubbs who was Prime Minister of Finland 2014-2015 and was involved with peace negotiations of the first Russo Ukraine War. He was Foreign Minister from 2008. He has also been in EU key positions since 2004. I have used Tim Snyder for background.
I would regard Stubbs and Snyder as credible.
Ukrainians were mislead into thinking that NATO and EU is right for them.
I think I did do it even more vigorously then Russians if it was my country whom I ruled.
Though I do feel sorry for the Ukrainians. But Ukrainian president in 2013-14 was undemocratically made to leave his presidency. Why no one is talking about it is just appalling? Russia gave them a good financial package in exchange for not joining NATO and the EU.
I am just a no body in this scenario because I don't live anywhere near the two countries but I know there are people inside Ukraine who still liked the USSR and they did feel threatened. Many videos of people in Ukraine being treated badly for sympathies with Russians.
Why are we suffering because of there own quarrel? In Asia we are facing the inflation with electricity rates going as high as Europe. Surely, it is a fact I live in third world country but we are also suffering from the effect. Our per Capita incomes are 10 times less if not lesser than European countries but we are still working. I don't think the war ends soon. And I did give to Ukrainians to help them out but I think our American loving lapdogs of people ousted the sitting government for going to Russia and finally getting ousted in the process. I don't like Americans like most people but I like Ukrainians. They are very honourable, at least the ones I have met or traded. So, even now I am conflicted about the conflict. This war will have many losers.
Giving up nuclear weapons was a mistake but even with nuclear weapons my country leadership still waggles it's tail in front of US.
Russia just sent their army into ukraine killing a couple thousand people.
Urkaine responded, but was and is depending on foreign help, as its just a small country.
NATO is just an excuse as there never was any expansion of NATO in the last decades.
Now after Russia waged war, there are a couple of new Countries applying for joining Nato, and Nato Members are increasing their Military budget.
So basically Russia just commited ten thousand murders of Ukrainian citizen as well as on russian citizens, and made Nato as strong as ever.
NATO poses a danger to Russia
Ukraine is getting slaughtered. They are losing 10 Ukrainians to every 1 Russian. They lost air superiority months ago and have no planes left. They have been out of soviet era tanks for a month now. Javelins have dried up and now they are only being supplied with Carl Gustafs which are not really useful for tanks, they are more geared toward APCs and technicals. Ukraine is also out of 155mm HE artillery round and will not be supplied any for at least a year. Seems they were supplied with 155mm anti-tank mine rounds instead in appeasement. Meanwhile Russia is drilling their infrastructure with drone strikes turning off the electricity for winter. That a bad place to be for Ukraine against an artillery heavy/tank heavy army like Russia that just called up 300,000 reservists.
Is it right for Ukraine to join nato?
Nope, not at all. The puppet regime that controls Ukraine is dirty as hell. There is no way they would be admited to NATA even if previous treaties hadn't been made. The fuckery that happen under the Obama/Biden regime in Ukraine is shameful. Most Americans don't back the deep state's play for a proxy war there nor do we back Soros, Victoria Nuland, or of the other criminals involved in the situation. Quite frankly a lot of people are pissed off about the entire situation and the money being stolen from American tax payers. None the less, a fight is happening... Russia is winning. So at least the deep state will lose their little criminal playground.
That said the media in America is working overtime to brainwash the people of America that Ukraine is winning, even when it's blatantly obvious they are not. All the major military think tanks that advise policy are admitting Ukraine is losing, the pentagon is shining shit in their press conferences, but itās really obvious they know Ukraine is losing, yet the Democrat politicians and media ignore all the advice of experts and signs of failure by Ukraine and resort to pushing propaganda on the American public. Itās annoying.
It's a stupid play too because only 18% of "polled" Americans think we should be doing more to help Ukraine and the majority of Americans don't even trust the media enough to take polls to begin with... So support for Ukraine is a very small fringe group within America. They are out in the cold on their own with no backing of the American public or military.
https://media.patriots.win/post/jLDP1DAy.jpeg
So can we say that Ukraine deserves the current situation
Well I see a difference between the people of a country and a puppet government aligned with a group of Nazi soldiers that stole their elections. They arenāt on the same side, thus why that puppet government was committing genocide on the people of eastern Ukraine and the people of Eastern Ukraine didnāt resist the Russian forces that decided to enter their territory to fight the Nazis. Itās like how the Democrats rigged the 2020 election and no one likes the puppet regime surround Joe Biden and constantly mocks him in America or how Trudeauās people rigged the elections in Canada and a lot of people are pissed off at his regime, or how they rigged the election against Bolsonaro in Brazil the other night and people are rioting in the streets. There is a conspiracy by the WEF/UN/China against the people of the world. The people of the nations donāt deserve what they are being handed, it is a small cabal of criminals that have a reckoning coming their way. They need to be held to account.
I think the invasion by Russia is 100% evil, I 100% hope they are defeated and that every soldier that crosses the border is killed. I want Ukraine to have all of their territory and all of their citizens to be safe and in health.
I like Russia, I like their culture and many of their people. I hate Putin.
My biggest wish is for Putin to die or be overthrown and for Russia to bring all of their troops back and to end the invasion immediately. As long as Russia continues their invasion of a peaceful neighbor and want them to be defeated.
It is an immoral attack... just like the invasions by Germany (against Poland, France, Russia... etc.), Russia (against Poland) and Japan (against China and the Pacific island countries) in WWII
I respect Russia's own choices. It doesn't matter if it's Putin or anyone else. But in Russia he wants to preserve his own territorial integrity
When he/they are in Ukraine's territory killing Ukrainian women and children. I hope they all die.
I think it can be a dangerous situation especially if the NATO and the EU let the Ukraine join their forces. Especially the last could lead into a world war. I think the situation is hopeless in a way that there will be no peace unless one party gives up fighting.
That´s so because both of sides have no interest in an ending the fight.
Yes, perhaps a new world war is desired.
Highly dangerous and not beneficial to anyone. Its the equivalent of sending an Amazon package to every household on the globe... which is a fan pre-equipped with sewage to trash their house.
should be discussions by leaders to end it immediately.
Yes, no one wants war
I see no effort under Biden admin towards ending this, very dangerous. Putin has said he'd rather get along with the west. It will take different thinking to solve this, but as it is, looks like humanity is going to pay for our... poor decision making and emotional problems.
All Ukraine has to do is not join NATO
I see it as another Conflict.
The USA has given away over $70 Billion in "aid". Yet we are not in this Conflict.
We have issues at home that $70 Billion would go a long way to fix.
i personally feel Hunter Biden and The Big Guy owe the Ukraine a lot of money AND are being black mailed into giving our money away.
I think we should just Butt Out of it and let Russia and Ukraine do their own thing. The Ukraine was involved in a lot of criminal activities.
We need a Wall at home, veterans taken care of, and Democratic Mayors, Governors, and Nancy Pelosi all want more pay raises.. Defund the Police, give yourself a raise.
We need to butt out of the Ukraine Russia conflict.
"Russia has warned Ukraine. Russia is very cautious about Nato. There is a group (NATO) that threatens the country (Russia). Russia thought about taking measures for this."
Bullshit ^. NATO has never posed a threat to Russia. The only issue Russia has with NATO is that it is in place to protect peaceful nations from unlawful aggression by evil men like Putin. The purpose of NATO is to prevent the very sort of thing Russia has done in Ukraine.
If Ukraine had listened to Russia, none of this would have happened..
Also
The Brussels Treaty, a joint defense treaty signed by Belgium, the United Kingdom, France, the Netherlands and Luxembourg on March 17, 1948, against the Soviet threat at the beginning of the Cold War, is considered the forerunner of the establishment of NATO.
If Ukraine had listened to Russia about what?
About NATO
Ukraine is not a member of NATO.
Yes i know but Ukraine want member of NATO
Ukraine is a peace loving sovereign nation that has the right to defend itself, and to join NATO if it wants to. The only reason Ukraine had any reason to join NATO was to protect itself from invasion by Russia, which was obviously a justifiable concern.
The only reason Russia did not want Ukraine to join NATO is because it would have made it much more dangerous to invade Ukraine if it was a NATO member.
In other words, Russia warned Ukraine not to join NATO because it wanted to invade Ukraine without NATO involvement.
Is this getting through to your brain? There is literally no valid excuse for what Putin has done. He is a piece of human garbage.
Ukraine isn't peace loving when they have a high concentration of neo Nazis within their government
@bingbongbangbung Source? I challenge you to provide any credible evidence that these so called "high concentration of neo Nazis in the Ukraine government" have done ANYTHING was violent, aggressive, illegal or otherwise Nazi-like in any way whatsoever. Go on now, I'll wait.
I was amused at how poorly Russia's military did. Many people criticized US forces in Iraq that they could not quickly squash guerilla forces, but we did incredibly well (including during the invasion) militarily. Russia tried a ton of fancy stuff, including deploying their fancy weapons they had been bragging about, and completely failed to either launch a successful initial operation, or to sustain one. They look incredibly weak after this, and it will cost them their military readiness for at least a decade.
It's not up to Russia to decide if Ukraine wants to join nato or not, that's Ukraines choice. Not to mention, Russia promised Ukraine in their treaty to never invade Ukraine if they gave up their nukes, which they did. See how much worth their word was on that, so I hope Ukraine join Nato, obviously can't trust Russia. Break any promise or treaty to get whatever they want. There is no threat to Russia if every country in Europe joined Nato. The problem for them, is that they can't invade countries anymore on a whim for control or whatever excuse/reason.
RUSSIA HAD INVADE AN IDEPENDENT AND SUVERANT NATION.
ONE WHO DECIDED BY FREE ELECTION AND WILL OF NATION THEY WANT TO JOIN European Union!!! UKRAIN NEVER HAD INTENTION TO JOIN NATO BEFORE CRIMEA INVASION IN 2014.
USA HAD NOTHING TO DO WHIT THIS WAR, THIS ONE ARE DIRTY PROBLEMS UNSOLVED FROM 1945.
USA GIVE ECONOMIC SUPORT WHITCH COME BACK TO USA BY BUYING AMUNITIONS AND TEHNOLOGY FOR THIS WAR.
UKRAIN IS NOT THE ONLY NATION THAT IS TREATEN BY RUSSIA
RUSSIA HAD ALWASE BEEN LIKE THIS. READ HISTORY.
SLAVA UKRAINE!!! KILL THE INVADATOR, KILL THEM ALL!!!

Is it right for Ukraine to join nato?
ABSOLUTLY AS AN INDEPENDENT AND SUZERAN NATION.
NATO IS A >DEFENCIVE< ORGANIZATION
ANYBODY WHO FULFILE THE CONDITION CAN JOIN.
PROFESIONAL ARMY
TRANSPARENT INVESTITION IN ARMY
HIGH QUALITY EQUIPMENT (BUY OR PRODUCE) ACORDING TO NATO STANDARDS
2% GDP INVESTITION IN ARMY
Russia is winning. West is covering up losses Ukraine is mounting. Their cities have been destroyed. They lost a lot of men that can't be replaced with their offences. Russia is waiting for winter to attack again. This time double the tanks and 500,000 men. I predict they hit them straight on and break through then encircle and break Ukraine troops in to pockets.
I hope that Ukraine will stop joining NATO
Terrible. I've said it before and I'll say it again: if someone in Putin's inner circle could just end his life, I don't think anyone would be complaining
Interesting :)
The whole NATO lie has been fully debunked a thousand times over.
Russia was never worried about NATO. Putin thinks Ukraine and all of the former Warsaw Pact nations are his.
Europe has turned it's back on Russia for the time being. It'll be interesting to see if it continues to do so after the current administration ends.
I suspect difficult times ahead for Russia if it can't broker a deal with Europe. And a few other countries better play nicely otherwise they'll face secondary sanctions.
I hope that Ukraine manages to free itself. Seems like Europe needs a free Ukraine and doesn't necessarily need Russia although their resources would be handy.
It'll be interesting to see if Ukraine joins NATO in the future.
Anyone who thinks this is about NATO is an utter cretin.
What is the real problem then?
The problem is that Putin wants to take back Ukraine, Georgia, Poland and other ex USSR nations. The real big problem is that the west are a bunch of pussies and Putin knows it. There's a damn good reason why Putin didn't do any major invasions from 2016 till 2020, and why both times *a certain someone* was American president or vice president he was committed to invading sovereign nations. But fuck it, let's just keep calling the only American president in recent times who had a backbone and who said he'd nuke Russia if they did anything, a 'Russian asset'.
I think Russia just really doesn't want a nato country right on its border. I think they'd rather bully and manipulate Ukraine into being a source of resources for them. They elected a Jewish guy as a leader and that probably sent a message that they're doing whatever they want.
It's sad that one crazy man can create such a horrible situation!
Is it right for Ukraine to join nato
Why Not! Nato has never been known to be War Mongers, it's simply a group of countries which have joined an allegiance among them to help protect each other from Aggression from aggressive places like Russia the bully!
i understand thank you
You are welcome
Sure let's pretend Afghanistan, Syria, Iraq, Libya, Korea, Vietnam, etc., never had Western powers invading and destroying them
@bingbongbangbung None of them were invaded by the western powers, the western powers just when asked went in to help the faction looking for freedom fight their war. Not once ever did the western powers ever attempt to take property as is going on presently with your buddy in Russia and Ukraine. If you don't like the freedom that you have living in Canada I'm quite sure they would let you freely move to Russia, Syria, Iraq, or any of those other countries.
Unnecessary and cruel, that's going to leave the world in devastation and misery!! 🥺💔
Absolutely :S
Could've been avoided. When rich/powerful argue and wage war it's citizens who have to suffer. I'm against it. Now everyone has to suffer except the rich and powerful. They are still at the back sipping an expensive wine while all this is happening.
The war is secretly controlled by Hilary Clinton's lizard people who are being blackmailed by aliens who found Hunter Biden's laptop from a Jewish Space laser.
Serves US only
europeans are easily lied to and their whole freedom propaganda is a big joke
From the U. S. perspective, I am seriously concerned about all the money we are sending over, the parade of high-power liberal demons who visited, the Hunter Biden connection, and the reputation Ukraine has for corruption and money laundering.
My understanding:
Russia is poor and under-developed. Russia sees no way to catch up other than conquering others. Russia sees an easy target and attacks. Ukraine gets support to not be conquered. Russia is fucked, but can't back off now, otherwise they are poor, underdeveloped and easily beaten.
I want this war to be over. It only affects the innocent. Putin doesn't have a scratch on him just his soldiers and all the innocent Ukrainians that got injured or lost their lives. Putin only gives orders but doesn't get dirty. Just like Charles Manson got others to do his dirty work. I don't know how this is justified just cos this is the government?
Russia want Ukraine because of better weather and farmland. Ukraine got independent at 1992. 30% of Ukraine speaks Russian and they consider themselves as Russian. Itās just expansion of Russian territory. Russia is too cold that they have to come down.
maybe it could be
It is a war of aggression begun by Putin. He is therefor a war criminal. How often are war criminals held to account? See Cheney, Dick.
Is it right for Ukraine to join nato?
I think that Ukraine is a sovereign nation that has the right to pursue whatever future it chooses to. The reality is I don't see NATO accepting Ukraine under the current circumstances.
Maybe the question should be phrased, "should we allow Putin to dictate the policy of sovereign nations by threatening use of nuclear weapons" He is also holding fake elections trying to illegally annex sections of Ukraine, which I would hope would be recognized by exactly no one.
The answer MUST be no. How you get to that "no" is another matter diplomatically, but ultimately Ukraine is a sovereign nation, should be allowed to pursue NATO membership, and accept it if approved by NATO.
If a group like NATO is strengthening next to my country, I would like a war.
I'll bet Ukraine does not like what Russia is doing right now. In fact I'm reasonably sure that by attacking Ukraine Russia has hardened Ukrainian resolve to join NATO at the earliest possibility as a protection. Putin miscalculated in thinking his army would quickly overrun them. He is now in a position he never anticipated and so is issuing threats as he has little alternative.
Always remember first. Putin is the aggressor. This actually began in 2014 by the way.
NATO is an organization established against the Soviet threat during the cold war. Whatever the decision of Ukraine, Russia has given the necessary answer to the whole world. i think you should empathize
Russia, under Putin's leadership CHOSE to initiate a war of aggression against a sovereign nation beginning in 2014. If it does not like what is occurring right now perhaps it should have sought a different remedy than WAR. It is attempting to ILLEGALLY annex portions of that nation as well.
It is apparent by the mass departures that many Russian citizens also do NOT agree with this path that Putin has chosen. The Russian people have my empathy. Vladimir Putin does not.
People who know nothing about Ukraine and Russia, as well as Putin and his EX KGB days, should not be talking.
Look up what putin wants to do, then talk
Putin and his mafia members stole so much money from the people, that they can't fund their military anymore on their conquest.
Meh. War sucks hairy ass to say the very least. The people suffering the most are Ukrainians and the Russians secondly after them.
Millions of civilians are unable to return home. Many still in the country are forced to live without access to food, water, health care, and other essential supplies. This is not an isolated crisisāblockades of Ukrainian grain exports have worsened hunger in some of the world's most vulnerable regions
I think that Putin made avery bad tactical error. He's losing the war and the fact that he invaded took any diplomatic solution off of the table. Now he keeps compounding the error with additional ones.
It all America and the Nato
https://www.youtube.com/embed/hQ58Yv6kP44Watch this from 2007.
I think Russia has shown itself to be weak militarily and no longer a major world power.
No, my friend, Russia is a strong country. He's just not showing his full strength right now
C'mon now they can't even subdue a 3rd rate country like Ukraine. If France had invaded Ukraine it would have ended 2 months ago.
Ukraine is not alone. Europe and the USA are behind it..
Iraq was armed by Russia yet the US military wiped the iraqi military off the map in a month and Iraq isn't in their backyard.
I donāt understand why itās still going on. Ukrainians are whooping Putins ass like just leave them alone. He should have never invaded to begin with, he is a greedy monster.
Stupid and unnecessary, so many innocent people are paying the price
āLook at my big muscles, I am awesome.ā Itās childish bully mentality.
Russia watedt to add Ukraine to their landmass for far longer than most people realize. The NATO thing is just a justification for something that they were already wanting to do
Why in this thread, there are some people trying to pull U. S. in a circumstances while they never mention how the other countries have impacted the wars?
i dont know bro
I mostly mock them here, I already know the answer why they are trying to do that. You can ignore this bro.
it's not a war between ukraine and russia. it's a war between USA and Russia.
Ukraine will make a mistake by joining NATO
it's not like ukraine has a choice there. ukraine is just the playball on the line between the global superpowers right now.
It is up to Ukraine to decide. It should not join NATO.
is it up to Ukraine? really? think about it. i think it's not. because their government is not really a democratic one. their government was intalled ina coup by USA.
Round up all the Russian men shoot them, round up the women and children to be raped. Just do what they did to german women and children but for Ukraine.
Ukarine has enough fire power to defend off Russia in the war Russia does not have a chance of winning the war in ukarine ukarine will win this war agained Russia
Putin is a war criminal.
The fact that he wants to protect his country's borders does not make him a war criminal
it can be over any time now.
There will be no clear winner.
I hope they can negotiate a cease fire. BOTH countries and the USA are at fault for the war.
I feel that I have my own problems in the US so I donāt care about another counties war. Especially counties that doesnāt even care about MY problems
Why is Russia entering into your crane as a hostile government?
russia just wants to protect its territorial integrity
Wanting to protect its territory. They screwed the pooch in the Soviet era. Nobody picked on Russia. After the Soviet block fell. The only one that feels like it's being picked on is Mr Putin. He's the only one that's screwing his own country. Ukrainian people did not want anything to do with rejoining forces. The people wanted to be free away from tyranny. NATO did not want to go up into Ukraine. Until Mr. Putin start flexing his muscle. It is sad that people can't live in peace and harmony. There's been always one individual creating fear and disharmony in the world.
Itās not something the USA should get involved with.
It has shown the incompetence of the Russian military strategists.
Russia has every right to do what itās doing, Period.
no further comments.
The Russians are evil and the people claiming that Ukraine is run by Nazi's are Half wits
no way
it is not good for any of us on this planit
Putin is evil. Thereās no reason to murder innocent Ukrainian civilians.
If USA stop arming Taiwan and Ukraine, then world will be at peace
perhaps bro
They should stop fighting.
but Ukraine is still behaving towards Russia
I love when Russians think we donāt know whatās going onā¦
Russia is a dirt poor country filled with corruption.
Maybe e the west should have kept to itself but no. They just had to fuck around
You can also add your opinion below!
Most Helpful Opinions