Do you agree with Ketanji Jackson that do you need to be a biologist to be able to define what a woman is?

Question

If you do, that means you also think that trans people who are not biologists are also 100% unable to tell if they are men or women, and if they need to "transition" because they are born in the wrong body. That is, if being a biologist is necessary to tell what a woman is.

bornnoutisdee · Accepted Answer

I think you can take a DNA test to find out whether you are male or female to check chromosomes

Some trans people say stuff like “Anybody who identifies as a woman is a woman.”

I disagree with this. If I say I identify as a cat that doesn’t make me a cat.

A woman is an adult human being. A person who is assigned female at birth by doctors is biologically a woman. A person who is born with female genitalia is a female.

You cannot change biological sex. A trans woman biological sex is male who was most likely born with a penis. Even after bottom surgery they still wouldn’t have things like ovaries, a cervix and a uterus. I’m not 100 percent sure but I think I saw another user write they can’t self lubricate the same way as a person born with a female genitalia.

Also there has been more than 50 successful uterus transplant between two people who were born with female bodies.

As of 2023 there has been zero successful uterus transplant between male and female bodies.

purplepoppy · Accepted Answer

I'm not a botanist but if I go to the shop for carrots I don't return with bananas.

slatyb · Accepted Answer

There's no point in arguing over the definition of "man" and "woman". What difference does it make? If someone tells me their name is Bumblesnoot and their pronouns are fry and fur, that doesn't affect me in any way. I don't care which door they choose when they have to pee.

Snakeyes7 · Accepted Answer

No. Women have many biological features that aren't their vagina that are unique to men that literally anyone can recognize.

Anonymous · Answer

Does it surprise you thatJoe Biden's pick for a supreme court justice can't define that? Doesn't surprise me at all.

Do you agree with Ketanji Jackson that do you need to be a biologist to be able to define what a woman is?

Most Helpful Opinions

What Girls & Guys Said

Do you need to be a Biologist to be able to define what a 'woman' is?

Do you agree with Ketanji Jackson that do you need to be a biologist to be able to define what a woman is?

Most Helpful Opinions

What Girls & Guys Said

Do you need to be a Biologist to be able to define what a 'woman' is?

We're glad to see you liked this post.