Do you think all Americans should be deported. Most of your country was Mexico's. Give us back our land?

Question

Vevv123 · Accepted Answer

You are right, there were areas of the USA that were once Mexico. The U. S. ended up taking over due to a series of injustices, including military aggression and the exploitation of vulnerable situations in Mexico. It’s good to know the history of America and how they obtained land through actions that often disregarded the rights of the people living there. I think it’s important for many Americans to recognize that the land carries the stories of those who were affected by these injustices. However, Mexico doing the same back would also create a cycle of conflict and injustices.

Anonymous · Accepted Answer

No, many of the people that migrated to the US in the beginning, where people who weren't wanted in their own countries, if it be because they were criminals, or simply just poor.

We don't want that back. They spend a lot of money getting rid of them, we don't need to spend money to get them back, just see how the future generations after those migrants became? I don't like how the poor we're treated in the past but looking at the US now I'm glad they went.

contentious · Accepted Answer

Mexico invaded the USA, then America declared war on Mexico and occupied Mexico all the way to Mexico City. Mexico surrender and negotiated peace. As part of the terms of the Treaty of Guadalupe Hidalgo America paid Mexico millions of dollars for that territory. Now you want to violate a peace agreement and steal our money after invading our country? Shit, you're lucky we allowed Mexico to continue to exist. We could have just annexed all your land and kicked your ass into south America. It would be even easier to do that today. Thank your lucky stars we had mercy on you.

OlderAndWiser · Accepted Answer

Your theory is that the land should be returned to the earliest people WHO YOU KNOW were in possession of the land?

Before the Europeans arrived, Mexico was inhabited by Maya, Aztec, Mixtec, Zapotec, and Nahua natives. Should all non-indigenous Mexicans also be deported?

Fireguy17 · Answer

Deported to where?
We were born here, and no disrespect but your people lost it fair and square.
Our forefathers kicked a lot of butt to make this a great country, so come on in if you aren't already here, legally, and enjoy. There is plenty of room.
There is plenty of room.

Joshydavid25 · Answer

There was no land rights or country back then.. It was whoever claimed the land and could defend it, it was theirs.. Just like all the Native Americans who "stole" land and the Aztecs and the Mayans who was hated by neighboring tribes..

andreasderjuengere · Answer

You mean the Maya and Aztec? :D

(I wrote this before I saw I read @OlderAndWiser 's point.)

My own additional point is: ''deportation'' is pointless in itself.

No one should be made responsible for where their parents were born.

Today we build our tomorrow. Let us all do this with dignity and with respect.

Anonymous · Answer

Most of the American country was Native American, not Mexican.

They should return the country to Sioux, Apache, Hopi, Navajo, Comanches, Seminoles, Iroquois, Shoshone, and many others.

On the other hand, Mexico was originally Toltec, Mayan, Mixtec, Aztec, Zapotec and Olmec... they should also return the land to the original owners.

MysteriousDarkness · Answer

The original indigenous Mexicans include diverse groups like the Olmecs, Mayans, Aztecs, Toltecs, and Zapotecs. The Olmecs are considered one of the oldest major civilizations in Mexico, while the Mayans, Aztecs, and Toltecs also left significant cultural and historical marks. The Zapotecs were another powerful group who dominated the Oaxaca Valley.

With that said then shouldn't the non indigenous Mexicans be deport from Mexico?

NoDecision · Answer

I think Native Americans were here long before any of them.

Miristheiss · Answer

Mexico? The land of human trafficing and drug cartels? What a shitty country. Do better.

ohsheeT · Answer

Well of course I do. And then before you get it your deported because Indians owned it before you. So that was simple. Next question please

Anonymous · Answer

there are people in this world who follow the proper procedures to enter countries and don't risk their visa status. It was just years ago where everyone could have gotten their paperwork done if they were here illegally without consequences

Likestorizz · Answer

Oof at this point in my life I think I'll leave that decision to the government. I'm scared of them

alice55 · Answer

They shouldn't cause we don't want them in Europe we have enough immigrant like that no need to get more xD

Gaylordslav · Answer

why would a shithole need to expand? You can't even govern the lands you all ready have. In fact we should take all of Mehico and bottle cap the path to South America and bring prosperity, peace and liberation to the people of Mehico

glennos89 · Answer

I think we would have to move out of our area's. If you studied the past you will know things where completely different in the past.

Anonymous · Answer

i'd go the other way and buy/merge everthing at least down to Panama canal or further. That makes a small border to defend. "The United States of America".

Summeroflove · Answer

No. Illegals yes. Not all who are citizens or here legally

Gwendoline · Answer

Shouldn't Mexicans be deported back to Spain?

OneViewpoint · Answer

Well at least Texas, New Mexico, Arizona, and California.

chrissykerdock · Answer

1/2 of america was here before 1790 plus illegal only

Dargil · Answer

And before that, several strains of Native Indians. Where are you from, again?

Sal_Monella · Answer

I think all people who do not speak adequate English should be deported or given 3 years to pass an oral test. Almost every land on earth has been conquered by someone else.

Agape93 · Answer

Sure, and you can still get deported since tall aren't natives to the land either

AviatorTom · Answer

You can have California... if you're sure you want it. 🙄

Anonymous · Answer

That issue was settled by treaty in the 1800s so there are no legal grounds to deport American citizens. Illegal immigrants now are violating our laws by invading our sovereign nation.

SweetDripp · Answer

Buy it back or take it back. That's the way it works.

Renegade_Sailor · Answer

We won a war. Then out of the goodness of our heart let you have Mexico back, then paid Mexico for what we kept.  Not giving anything back.

NatalieKeller95 · Answer

we'll gladly give you back California, we'll even give you a discount on it as well,

Shiprex · Answer

Native Americans should be seeking the deportation of the undesirables

Staximus · Answer

Get your facts straight, most of the country did not belong to Mexico. You lost the war.

Anonymous · Answer

I guess you do not know anything about history. We had a Mexican American War in 1840s. America won. Then America paid Mexico $10 million dollars for it when we did not have to pay a penny. What do you think now?

Jackblue · Answer

We paid you compensation for it and you accepted it, and then used that cash to crush the rebel Mayans in the Yucatan.

WhiteBoyChill · Answer

Lol. Fckin hilarious. It isn’t like the US fought Mexico over land fair and square and won. Also, why the need to include the photo?

Filthy_Immigrant · Answer

it was the Native American's before yours. so stop being a hypocrite

OddBeMe · Answer

Go back to Aztecs and all the other Indian names along the east coast we name after rivers or mountains

Twalli · Answer

Actually it wasn't. It was Native American, then Spain, then France, then most of Amerca was bought by Thomas Jefferson.

Anonymous · Answer

We did not immigrate, we conquered aaaaaaaaaaaah

Bugchugo · Answer

You're on Aztec land, better give that back and start up those human sacrifices again.

Likes2drive · Answer

Well since I was born here where would I go?

jahaims · Answer

And how did you get that land before it was taken...

Anonymous · Answer

If anything Mexico should give us thier remaining land. Look at what a mess they've made of it all.

beefcakebradybatson · Answer

Sure. Give it back to the Indigenous folk !!!

Godihateyou · Answer

Texan here. Dependant of someone that died at the Alamo. Come and take it.

Anonymous · Answer

Okay then leave and give the land back to the Native Americans dipshit

slatyb · Answer

Deported where? Most were born here.

exitseven · Answer

No, America is for Americans.

ChicoFromThe305 · Answer

Begging for your land back is wild ngl

JordansGate · Answer

Weird take, but not my business

Jennz6 · Answer

Are you from Mexico 🇲🇽?

Ariesman81 · Answer

Come and get it

MrZameer · Answer

Why is this picture with this question ⁉️

shortster · Answer

In the words of Texans, come and take it. 💣

FunkyMonkee · Answer

No! What for?

Anonymous · Answer

Shut up.

SmokinAces2000 · Answer

To where?

blackeagle007 · Answer

Ok. Cool

Bklynbadboy12 · Answer

Come take it!

Panthero80 · Answer

Si. pero no.

Anonymous · Answer

Troll

Anonymous · Answer

Lmao ur a real L

Do you think all Americans should be deported. Most of your country was Mexico's. Give us back our land?

Most Helpful Opinions

What Girls & Guys Said

Do you think all Americans should be deported. Most of your country was Mexico's. Give us back our land?

Most Helpful Opinions

What Girls & Guys Said

We're glad to see you liked this post.