Did Irina's life matter? Does a White Woman's lives matter?

[Anonymous]

As Black lives matter activists seek to explain this away or even justify this raising a defence fund for the perpetrator I believe this question needs to be asked as more and more white women are targeted.

Her life Mattered. White Women's lives matter

No her life didn't matter. White women's lives matter.

Updates

8 mo

https://www.facebook.com/share/r/17gRupFxAm/

[Anonymous]

the problem is that white feminists would call you racist for standing up for her

becoming the next Daniel Penny or Charlie Kirk just doesn't seem worth it anymore with the cancel culture if it means you get imprisoned or assassinated for it

[Asker]

I remember the 10 hours in new york sexual harassment video which showed how bad sexual harassment is was at first praised by the left and feminists but quickly forgotten about like it never existed after they realised that the woman in question was white and all the men harassing her were black.

[Asker]

https://youtu.be/plmgBIZGSJ4?si=Pi_-yJ6Xchk6B_Hm

[Opinion Owner]

the Pakistani grooming gang cover-up in England is much worse and recently a 12 yr old girl in Scotland got arrested for carrying weapons to defend herself from a migrant that ended up sexually assaulting her sister

[strateguy632]

Not according to blm. We can't say people life matter.

[avery58]

Yes, just as much as the lives of the many Native American women who are assaulted, murdered, or disappear every year and which topic no one knows anything about because it's not discussed.

[Asker]

Its a wonder native American communities are ominously silent about domestic abuse and murdered women on their reservations that they are completely in charge of.

[avery58]

They're not silent about. There have been many protests which the media and overall population doesn't care about.

[avery58]

www.harborhousefl.com/.../

www.latimes.com/.../combat-crisis-violence-indigenous-women-girls

[avery58]

Also, not all of the attacks happen in the reservations

[Asker]

If reservations are governed by native Americans and native American laws and the perpetrators are native Americans and they have their own media what can the mainstream media do except report it and what can thf overall population really do?

[avery58]

Did you read the articles? The first one said that 63% of the perpetrators were non native and other reports have said a similar thing.

What about the cases of missing Native American women? It stops being just the reservation's business when someone goes missing, federal law enforcement would have to look into it.

Like I said, not all of these attacks happen on reservations

[Asker]

The majority (87%) of homicides involving Indigenous women and girls reported by police between 2009 and 2021 were cleared by police, in that an accused person was identified in relation to the case. This proportion was slightly lower than in homicides of non-Indigenous women and girls (90%).
Most Indigenous women and girls were killed by someone that they knew (81%), including an intimate partner (35%), acquaintance (24%), or family member (22%). In most cases, the person accused of their homicide was also Indigenous (86%).
Police were less likely to lay or recommend a charge of first-degree murder—the most serious type of homicide charge—when the victim was Indigenous (27%) compared to when she was not (54%). Instead, charges of second-degree murder (60%) and manslaughter (13%) were more common. Manslaughter charges were also more common when the accused person was Indigenous.
When incidents of homicide of Indigenous women and girls moved to court, manslaughter charges were twice as common when the victims were Indigenous women and girls (41% of homicide charges) than when they were not (20%).
Manslaughter charges were the most likely to result in a finding of guilt, in homicides of Indigenous (66%) and non-Indigenous (72%) women and girls. Overall, 45% of homicides of Indigenous women and girls (including manslaughter and other homicide charges) resulted in a guilty finding. Acquittals were rare in homicides of Indigenous women and girls (1.6%), as they were when the victims were non-Indigenous (0.4%).

[Asker]

At the case level, guilty findings in cases of homicides of Indigenous women and girls were most common in cases where the accused was a spouse (82%) or a stranger (79%). Overall, stranger homicides were less common among Indigenous victims (8%, versus 12% of non-Indigenous women and girls who were killed).
Custody was by far the most common type of sentence passed in cases linked to homicides of both Indigenous and non-Indigenous women and girls. The average length of sentenced custody was three years shorter for those found guilty in a case involving the homicide of an Indigenous woman or girl, compared to when the victim was non-Indigenous.

[avery58]

You can't be serious lol. I was just trying to share links and quotes from articles, and it won't let me. Funny how that works

[avery58]

Do you have links to those statistics? Because this is what I found.

publichealth. columbia. edu/news/colonial-roots-violence-against-native-american-women#:~:text=Between%2086%2D96%20percent%20of, starting%20with%20Columbus's%201492%20expedition.

https://www.nbcnews.com/news/amp/ncna1272670

www.domesticshelters.org/.../domestic-violence-rampant-among-native-americans

[avery58]

The first link:
www.publichealth.columbia.edu/.../colonial-roots-violence-against-native-american-women starting%20with%20Columbus's%201492%20expedition.

[avery58]

Had to break it down like that to post the links cause G@G doesn't want us to share links about this topic for some reason 🙃

Quote from the first link:

"Between 86-96 percent of the sexual abuse of Native women is committed by non-Indigenous perpetrators who are rarely brought to justice."

Quotes from the second link:

For nearly half a century, tribal nations have lacked the authority to prosecute people who are not members of a tribe — even though, according to the Department of Justice, those non-Native Americans are responsible for most of the violent crimes in Indian Country."

"Now, on the heels of a Supreme Court decision in Cooley’s case that affirmed tribes’ law enforcement authority, and with the reauthorization of the Violence Against Women Act currently before Congress, there is growing momentum to fix the legal loophole that non-Native American criminals have exploited for decades."

Quote from the third link:

While 35 percent of women (and 33 percent of men) experienced violence at the hands of a Native American perpetrator, a whopping 97 percent of women (and 90 percent of men) experienced violence committed by non-Native individuals."

[avery58]

Seems apparent that some of the violence is coming from tribal member, while much of it is coming from non-tribal members. These numbers are exactly the reason that it should be discussed more and looked into, to find out what is really going on and how to prevent it or help the women.

Saying that violence against Native American women should be looked into as well shouldn't need a debate

[Asker]

Not the case. Its being ignored and covered up by reservation tribal councils. Eventually it will blow up in their faces as the truth is revealed.

[Anonymous]

tbh, all money raised for that murderous black criminal should be investigated and then turned over to the family of this woman, or at least to some charity organization. Seems like money laundering to me. But it's bat shit crazy to support a murder just because of tribalism and feeling like you have to support the man who has the same skin color.

[Asker]

Iran shows the BLM supports his actions

[KostasKouvalis]

Yeah, more then George Floyds, Treyvon Martin's or Jordan Neeley's. Even though I think she was a moron for getting into a subway car full of nlggrs in the middle of the night and sitting in front of one with her BACK turned. But yeah, the double standard and hypocrisy is sickening and I genuinely believe there is something inherently psychologically wrong with black people and their White supporters.

[SoccerPlayer99]

Not on the cultural left. If you're white, you're out.

[jshm2]

No, the question doesn't need to be asked, you troll.

[RedInnocent69]

Of course. All lives matter. It just sounds silly when you say it