I am almost 25 years old, single and hating it. I wish I could say its because I set my standards to high, but its not. I love very homely down to earth girls. I don't like the blondes showing skin and leg and cleavage. When I'm out with my friends, yea sure I notice it, and would love to take a girl lookin all slutty and hot back to my place, but I would never date a girl who dresses that way. So to answer your question, yes, I prefer modest women over slutty looking girls. Because a modest girl can only be one of two things. She is either shy and I find that adorable, or two, she has respect for herself and feels she doesn't need to dress like a skank, and I adore that as well. A woman with standards and self respect is a girl you can marry, and that's what I am looking for :)
I don't hate them. I prefer that gal that I'm with to be modest, but I don't mind it when other women are not. If you're dressed aggressively then that means you're looking for attention. And that's fine for all the single women out there. I don't mind looking at them, but that doesn't I want to be with one of those women.
"modest" can look good, but at the same time it can look bad too. Same with showing off too much. You don't have to look slutty when showing off some skin, and you don't need to cover up all the time either. Sometimes I find I have the most fun when the girl is showing off some skin, and not so much that I don't have to imagine what she looks like under her clothes.
There is a big difference between modesty and looking like a prude or someone's 85 year old grandmother, I always dress modestly but I still get heaps of attention and no guys ever seem to complain for example I would wear skinny jeans, over the knee boots with a low heel, a more baggy cardigan (buttoned up like a sweater) with a scaf that covers any cleavage/ chest.