Why do girls seemingly dislike guys that treat them right?

I'm gentle with the girls I date, not weak but gentle. Like I'm dominant but not in a bossing a girl around way, more like a coddling her kind of way. I've been told I'm too nice. So it's nothing to do with being dom or sub but entirely to do with me not treating them poorly. I really don't get it
Why do girls seemingly dislike guys that treat them right?
Post Opinion