How much does a guy’s athletic body matter to you (when all else is equal)?

Please don’t talk about personality, confidence, humor, blah blah. This is a situation where all else is equal but if had two guys side by side: one has a chiseled physique and the other has a pot belly, how much of a difference would it make?

+3 points. Can turn a 6 to a 9
+2 points. Can turn a 6 to a 8
+1 point. Can turn a 7 to a 8
None issue
Negative point (s). His nice body makes me insecure about my own
Select gender and age to cast your vote:
How much does a guy’s athletic body matter to you (when all else is equal)?
Post Opinion