There is always something a bit wrong with a trans compared with a girl by birth but photo's don't necessarily show what you'd see in the flesh. eg an adam's apple and jaw line. Girls by birth have a totally different shape jaw to guys who have a more robust jaw. Neither pic shows either definitively but B jawline seems to be more square though I can't see A's.
B's shoulders seem to be out of proportion with the hips but the pose disguises it. The abdomen muscles seem to be developed but to have more a masculine shape of musculature.
Because both pictures are deliberately emphasizing the feminine aspects it is a toss up with pics like this. I would not be fooled in the flesh because I would be seeing a lot more and adherent non girl by birth aspects would stand out to me.
Having said that a lot of guys don't notice. A bar I go to had a trans waitress for a while. She bounced up to me but immediately knew I knew and let a girl by birth waitress serve me. A lot of the male patrons were obviously taken by her and didn't notice the bulge in her tight short skirt.
90-95% of the time, yes. I can easily tell a real woman from a tranny. My Transceiver is on point. The bottom girl is 100% real; those hips don't lie. The top one looks like a real girl too, to be honest. They might be trans due to that obvious lip surgery. But if they are trans, then they pass better than 99% of them, to be honest.
I think both are real women. But if one is definitely, 100% fake, it's the top one. The bottom one is not only not trans, but I can tell she's pretty short, too. Like 5'3" to 5'5". Men are rarely that petite.
u Doesn't matter to me, they are both female in my eyes. I think anyone saying they can always tell is a liar.
One is female the other is a mtf transgender. It’s a new gender
Still both women to me and I'd comfortably date either of them as a lesbian.
Or let me say this they are both women by gender but not by sex. And that’s cool you’d be willing to date them.
You'd be right. One is not biologically female. They are both still women by gender.
I dont really have sex anyway so its no big deal. If a transgirl hasn't had her surgery we just find a way to work around it.
@Intothevoid666
No, one is a man pretending to be a woman, and the other is a woman. Assuming this isn't some idiotic trick question.
Aww thanks! It's good to know you took a break from your religious preaching and fascination with comics and card games rip offs to learn so much about me too!
@Wade12345 I don’t see why gender has to be determined by sex tho?
@Intothevoid666
You wouldn't. Your generation has been brainwashed by Nancy Pelosi and other demoniacs to not believe Good and Evil and Right and Wrong exist.
Dude... you have sex dreams about comic book characters. Maybe don't preach about depravity to others.
You missing out on the part where its a comic book character? She isn't real. I may have sex with women but at least mine are real and not in a dream.
I dont need to hear about your sex dreams there, kiddo. Your God said lust was a sin and here you are flaunting it, not even with a person but with some drawing in a book.
Listen, if you want to dream about making out with Rogue or Jean Grey or even my personal favorite, Psylocke, then by all means go ahead. I didn't come into your sex post criticizing you about your choices so I'd appreciate the same courtesy.
You wouldn't understand this, because you make it a habit of disobeying God, but Kissing Rogue in a Dream is a sign of Forbidden Love. It's God talking to me in a parable telling me someone I like is off-limits. That's all.
You being a lesbian are in continual disobedience to God, so I wouldn't expect you to understand even if He did speak to you.
@Wade12345 Most people consider me very right wing. Gender and sex is objectively not the same thing. I don’t agree with a lot of what the trans community does and I don’t even know if I think sex reassignment surgery should be a thing but gender and sex are not the same thing.
@Intothevoid666 Try reading an older dictionary or encyclopedia then.
Like I said, your generation has been brainwashed by Demoniacs.
One year, there was a Wheel of Fortune puzzle where the phrase was "X and Y chromosomes" and the answer was "what do they determine?" and the woman said, "Gender" and she won the prize.
This notion of Sex and Gender being something different only started in the past decade, before then the terms were used interchangeably.
Outdated books and wheel of fortune to make your argument. It's a stretch at best
@Wade12345 gender is the social role u play in society sex is your biological status. How is that the same thing? They are two distinct concepts no?
@Intothevoid666 Not according to any biology text.
@Wade12345
gen·der
/ˈjendər/
Learn to pronounce
noun
1.
either of the two sexes (male and female), especially when considered with reference to social and cultural differences rather than biological ones. The term is also used more broadly to denote a range of identities that do not correspond to established ideas of male and female.
@Intothevoid666 Perverted dictionary definitions do not count. I've already explained that to you that you are brainwashed by demoniacs.
A is trans :)
Opinion
40Opinion
u I think A is the trans and B is the Indy driver.
I suspect that if you could post pictures of them nude, the difference would be more obvious.
I think the first one is trans because her face looks a bit more masculine to me, if that makes sense?
Also, this is just a screenshot, but in real life, you can pretty easily tell if someone's a trans or not, if you know the basics of how the male and female bodies look and function.
Like it's easier to tell if a man's a trans man or an actual man just by hearing them talk. A trans man will still most likely have a softer voice. As for trans women, again, the voice and the way they talk is a clear sign. Trans women will sometimes sound more like an effeminate gay guy than an actual woman. If you want an even clearer sign, just look between the legs lol. A bulge is pretty damn impossible to hide, y'know.
To make an Analogy, You can't tell the difference between high end proxy trading cards but you can tell the difference between most because most are not high end and very obvious proxies.
So yes in most cases one can. But there is times when you wouldn't until you get down there.
Most of the time you can tell easily, on rare occasions you can only tell when they are naked or speak. Fake boobs and fake vag are obvious, and men have a different number of ribs than women so thin people give it away, and typically the larynx is enlarged in men. Most trans "women" look like guys in drag. if only one of those pics is trans, my guess is B.
The Adam’s Apple is cartilage and can be scrapped away. As a last resort, look at the index and ring finger. On about 95% of men, the ring finger is longer and on about 95% of women, the ring finger is longer. In my case, it depends on which hand you check.
I can tell if not by facial features because some guys have really delicate features then by scent body odor
men and women don’t smell the same smell their hair a man won’t smell as pleasant as a woman even if he is wearing perfume or attempting to smell feminine
the female body gives off a natural scent that’s pleasing to males so when in doubt give her a sniff
This is fantastic, please do more of these, and don't stop.
I picked A is Trans but really it doesn't matter? They both look fully female. I hate that certain features (that even a biological female can have) are considered more masculine 😅
Hence why they are called trans female and not "female," kiddo.
They do not have the biology, or menstrual cycles of a female.
That's what makes it scary, you really can't these days without them providing the "Oh, by the way" disclaimer.
Why is it scary?
@Subarugirl in other words the change in appearance during transition has gotten so good that unless you were in front of them or they told you, you would be none the wiser.
I still don't see why that is scary...
@Subarugirl I personally don't see a reason to continue a conversation over a simple word.
What I will say is if you look at the dating world today in terms of straight individuals who prefer individuals who were born women, they would rather want to have a heads up note if they are in fact a transitioned individual.
Well I would assume that you would get to know someone before you start dating them... unless you look at every attractive female presenting person as a potential sexual partner, then I could understand why you would be uncomfortable... but it's not like trans women are tricking transphobic men into bed...
@Subarugirl LOL! They are all the time!! 😂 Do you live in Kansas or something?
@Subarugirl and I did, which is how I have met my girlfriend of almost two years now.
Now I also brought up my point because when I was single, I had experiences with meeting up with transitioned people that didn't tell me that off the bat or told me after we had known each other for a while.
And I get why they may hold it back, but it is also unfair to the individual they are dating to not be upfront because now the relationship technically started on a low via omission.
So to say that trans individuals are tricking people into bed frequently? No, probably not, and I am cool with people if they are upfront with that fact. However to say it hasn't happened isn't true either.
@Jamie05rhs Actually I live in Portland, Oregon... one of the most queer cities in the nation. I find it hard to believe that any trans person would want to engage in any kind of sexual activity with a transphobic person... I'm sure there is an extremely small minority that has happened to, but I would be willing to bet the chances of you being raped are higher...
@Subarugirl Ohh. That explains a lot.
And ok; I will accept your answer. It could be that things are different in Portland.
I don’t have a need to make this identification from a photo. I can tell after interacting. That’s enough.
Is not a fair poll since we can't see the body of the first one like the one shown in the second pic.
First one is trans? Yeah, no shit, that's why you didn't show the hips.
Need a better picture of the first one.
I can't see its hips.
Really does not matter tbh.
it’s not like a human treats anyone differently….
I would say the trans is A and biological female is B….. but you should have had a pic of their full bodies
I want to say the bottom girl is real, but I know it's probably going to be a trick question.
Yes!! Thank God I was right!
Second one because of the shoulders. The high wide shoulders compared to her body size is usually the best giveaway. Her wrists and hands are another giveaway. She's still a beautiful woman don't get me wrong.
My shoulders and hands look just like that...
@Subarugirl I'm so sorry... I didn't mean to offend but those are usually traits I've noticed more on trans women.
I am not offended... Im just saying that looking at a persons hands or shoulders aren't an accurate indicator of biological sex
@Subarugirl of course but this question wants us to try anyway.
It isn't the idea of whether or not she looks like a natural woman that's the problem.
@DaveJord that, and the fact that I'm not into men, no matter how much they look like a woman. I'm also not into women who look like men, pieces of plastic that look like women (sex dolls or robots), or pieces of plastic that are designed to look or feel like female parts.
I'm into women.
Usually but, these days, it's becoming harder to tell.
Call me, Fonzi! I said Aaaay.
Hmm... just intuitively, I'm going with the bottom one.
Tbh when it really comes down to it. Anyone and everyone can be deceived. Take Michael Obama for instance. I mean Michelle.
Maybe you can't tell just from the face. But the face is really not what most people care about.
There are some who are difficult to tell but my view would still change if they tell me they're transgenders and it would turn me off.
What about cross dressers
who are male, but they dress like girls because thats how they feel they should have been in, they just still identify as a man, and straight
Is a trans female a bloke with no ding-dong and two X chromosomes? Both look pretty much the same.
The down one is trans. You can see it by looking at the hands.
They both look like biological women but I KNOW the bottom girl is 100% real. Maybe the top is trans, if she is, she passes more than most trans women.
Most of the time yes. Though those that don't disclose it should be ready to suffer the consequences.
Lol a was the obvious choice. And some dickless worthless piece of shit down voted me without comment. How cute.
Second one is trans. She's had a lot of work done but yeah.
First one is girl
second one is a man whos pretending to be a woman
oh my god i'm done with this world🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮
At one point I could. Now is extremely difficult to tell.
My best guess the 1st picture is a man posing as a woman.
Wish you had shown the top one with full body. I think the top one is a trans gender female.
Shit probably both are Trans but I picked A
It doesn't really matter does it?
If you’re a guy then yes it does matter to be able to tell.
I mean sure, if you are looking at every attractive female presenting person as a potent sexual partner….. but I mean even in that case its not like trans people want to be in a sexual relationship with transphobic bigot...
Excuse me little lady but I am not a transphobic bigot. I was just curious if people could tell the difference if you were in a bar or such.
I never said that you were...…….
This girl can spot a transphobic bigot from an avatar. She doesn’t even need a photo. It must be reassuring to know that you can judge, and then discard, people so easily.
@Paul_in_Indy actually people who act bigoted and/or transphobic are bigoted and/or transphobic. I haven't called anyone here a transphobic bigot... yet. How ever if you pay attention and take the time read what was written you will see that I stated that trans people don't want to be in a sexual relation ship with someone who fits that description. Im glad I was able to clarify that for you.
I appreciate your eagerness to educate. I did not, actually, need clarification about your eagerness to judge and condemn people. I had picked that up, already. People can hear both what you say and what you mean.
@Subarugirl lol it does matter if it becomes more than a friendship etc and sex is involved… because a person should find out BEFORE if there’s any surprises such as a yk what or an illness (std) etc
It’s not bigoted to only want to date actual, biological women. If a dude wants to be surgically altered to appear female, that’s his business.
@MikeInHawaii of course not…. But generally you get to know someone before you start getting sexual and romantically involved…. What do you want? For them to wear gold stars? Or be on a register? … seriously though how many women have you started dating just to find out she was trans later on?
@JohnK123 more than you think I would be willing to bet... but that's besides the point. Not being able to tell the biological sex of someone you find attractive makes you uncomfortable and it really shouldn't be an issue. People are living their lives and your are obsessing with what genitalia they were born with... that shouldn't even be an issue unless you look at every female presenting person as something to put your penis in... which you shouldn't. The issue here isn't how people chose to live their lives, the issue here is how you view women.
Please stop feeding the trolls, don't make any sudden movements, and back away from them slowly.
@JohnK133. I didn't know they offer troll rides!
Do care, its not about looks.
I have no clue anymore these days
The hands are always a tell
Not really.
Believe it or not, man hands is a real thing.
For instance, this woman, Jik, a Thai masseuse, has large strong hands and that throws off many people thinking she is a ladyboy since Thailand is so famous for its ladyboys. But Jik is 100% born-with-a-vagina woman.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=llWw9fAxj7g&t=3317s
I am betting A is trans.
After five beers I would not care anyway
They are basically the same person
No It's tuff you have to have a feel for the dick
First one for sure. Don't you see the difference
Bottom is the biological one
I voted the wrong option, I should have voted A, not B. I didn't read your description
I hate this shit.
A is trans
You can't.
No. Who's who?
BOTH are HOT!
Top one is
Sometimes
You can also add your opinion below!
Girl's Behavior 
Guy's Behavior 
Flirting 
Dating 
Relationships 
Fashion & Beauty 
Health & Fitness 
Marriage & Weddings 
Shopping & Gifts 
Technology & Internet 
Break Up & Divorce 
Education & Career 
Entertainment & Arts 
Family & Friends 
Food & Beverage 
Hobbies & Leisure 
Other 
Religion & Spirituality 
Society & Politics 
Sports 
Travel 
Trending & News 
Most Helpful Opinions