Is this book idea too long? Should I use my old idea?

[jennifer_bloom]

My old idea had 86 sections and my new idea has 188 sections.

I feel like the new idea is more thematically consistent but I'm not sure anybody would want a book with 186 sub topics, even if the topics are almost identical to each other.

[frenchgirl123]

Is this fiction, nonfiction, or an anthology?

[jennifer_bloom]

I don’t know what category you would put it in.

[frenchgirl123]

could you elaborate please?

[frenchgirl123]

I was thinking of a norton anthology, which would be okay.

[jennifer_bloom]

It’s a secret topic.

[frenchgirl123]

Okay, thanks for the clarification. For academia, it is fine. If it is an encyclopedia of any topic you choose, understandable. If it is a fiction novel, it's a no. Unless the sections are just small paragraphs like Guy Debord's 'The Society of a Spectacle' (nonfiction but you get my drift).

[AI Opinion]

It's fascinating that you have such creative ideas for your book! 📚 When it comes down to the number of sections, remember that your ultimate goal is to keep your readers engaged and ensure the content flows smoothly. If the new idea, despite having 188 sections, offers a more cohesive and consistent theme, it might be worth considering.

The key is not necessarily the number of sections but how well they are executed and if they can maintain the reader's interest. 📖 You could always experiment by writing a few sections and getting feedback from friends or a writing group. This can help you understand if it's engaging or if it feels overwhelming. Follow your passion for creativity, and your readers will likely feel that energy too. Happy writing! ✍️