Are these custom MTG cards now balanced for commander and modern?

[SeekerOfTruth007]

Time Reverse 2UU

Instant - Mythic

You may pay U and skip your next turn instead of paying Time Reverse's Mana Cost.

Counter target spell.

===

Bandit Camp

Land - Rare

Bandit Camp enters Tapped.

T: Add W to your mana pool.

2W, T: Create a 2/2 white Bandit creature with Pillage: 2. (When this creature deals damage to a player, exile the top 2 cards of that player's Library.)

===

Avenging Elephant G

Creature - Elephant - Rare

Last Strike. (This creature deals damage last in combat.)

3/3

===

Celestriad 8

Artifact - Rare

Spells you cast have their mana cost reduced to 1.

===

Soul of Thamasa 4

Artifact - Mythic

4, T: Reveal the top card of your Library, if it is an Instant or Sorcery card, you may cast it without paying its mana cost this turn.

===

Master's Scroll 4

Artifact Equipment - Mythic

Equip: 4

Equipped creature gains Triple Strike. (That creature deals damage First, Normal, and Last in combat.)

===

Miracle, Summoner 2RGW

Legendary Creature - Wizard - Mythic

Flying

2RGW: Reveal cards from the top of your Library until you reveal a creature card. Put that card onto the Battlefield and the other revealed cards back on bottom of your Library in any order. Activate this ability as a Sorcery.

4/4

===

Salvation W

Sorcery - Rare

Search all Exiled cards you own and put one of them into your hand. Exile Salvation.

===

I weakened the cards the bot complained about, so I want to know what the bot thinks about them now.

[AI Opinion]

I love custom cards, so this is fun 😄

Time Reverse is still insane in Modern and Commander. Skipping one turn for a 1-mana hard counter is too strong, especially with extra-turn decks or if you cast it on your “last” turn.

Bandit Camp is underpowered now; a tapped land plus 3-mana for a vanilla 2/2 with minor exile payoff feels bad compared to real cards.

Avenging Elephant is fine but weak; Last Strike is mostly a drawback, so at 3/3 for G it might actually be okay but weirdly pushed for green.

Celestriad is completely broken everywhere. Making all your spells cost 1 is way beyond anything printed; it needs to be symmetrical, cost way more, or reduce by 1 instead.

Soul of Thamasa is strong but closer to printable. Probably needs 5–6 mana or a “once each turn” clause, since it can chain card advantage in spell-heavy decks.

Master’s Scroll is wildly broken. Triple Strike with any power buffs or infect is game-ending on the spot. Needs huge mana costs or to be toned down to double strike + bonus.

Miracle, Summoner is very strong but could be okay as a mythic. Six-mana activation at sorcery speed is fair; flying 4/4 for four is pushed but within legendary mythic territory.

Salvation is niche but fine. One mana to recover a key exiled combo piece is strong but narrow; exiling itself keeps it from looping.

Overall, Celestriad, Time Reverse, and Master’s Scroll are still highly unbalanced for Modern and Commander. The others range from fine to slightly under/over-tuned but closer to workable. 🎨🃏

[EmmaMary]

What the hell is this all about in pure simple English?

[SeekerOfTruth007]

It's custom-made cards for a 30-year-old card game. I'm mostly querying the Bot, since it is really good at comparing mathematical game mechanics.

[EmmaMary]

Thank you for the much simpler explanation... Much appreciated.