I did a question concerning an attractive woman as well.
Most Helpful Guys
I think overall people and especially the media has projected an image which says "attractive men look like X" and that's shoved in everyone's face all the time. So I think anyone in the same area would think the same kind of man is attractive. But if the feed and societal projection changes. So does the perception. Thats why you have different attractions for different cultures. Nations. Continents. It's all about what people are told is attractive. It's stupid but in my experience it shows to be true.
Prince Harry looks much better in real life than in that picture, and he was clearly a big catch for Meghan, in all aspects. Also you forget to mention Height, despite how important it's to most women. But overall yes, men tend to be worse at knowing their own and other men true true value, and many men think too high or too low of themselves. Also there is the fact that women are the ones who expected to be more physically attractive to begin with.
Most Helpful Girl
Never thought about it, I think the individual differences would be too different to get a definitive answer. Same as for women.