Please help me decide on which boot I should buy?

I can only buy one pair of boots right now. They both fit great. I am looking for boots to wear this fall and winter with denim dresses, denim skirts, and jeans. Which ones do you think I should purchase?

Boot 1
Boot 2
Select gender and age to cast your vote:
A total of 17 votes were cast: 5 girls and 12 guys. See detailed results
Please help me decide on which boot I should buy?
Post Opinion