Girls, do you prefer musicians or athletes?

[RandomStudent]

So at my school it would seem that guys who sing/play and instrument, and guys who play sports get the most girls. Which feature do you consider more attractive?

Musicians

Athletes

[jerseycountrygirl]

Either can be attractive, to me. A lot of girls would go for the musician partially because they admire creativity but also because of the perception that athletes are stuck on themselves. But musicians can be just as stuck on themselves if they're really good. So they share that downfall but both have there benefits.

Musicians are creative and athletes are muscular. Musicians have the tendency to be introverted and gentlemanly while athletes are outgoing and funny. So both havetheir benefits and downfalls.

However, I'd go for athletes because most of guy's I've dated were athletes.

[emzy-89]

I'm a musician and have been for the past 20yrs. Many f the guys I hang out with are musos, so that's common ground that I find attractive. However, the guy who i've been most attracted to is a Phys Ed teacher, so I don't know. lol. I think if we're just talking about the 2 personas, i'd go musician, but it depends on the individuals other attributes.

[RandomStudent]

Of coarse, I just ment which feature is more attractive. If there is some asshole musician, and a kind athlete, of coarse people will choose the nice one.

[miniscruff2000]

Musicians, but that might just be because girls may look at them as the bad boy type, but also the sensitive and creative kind all the same, which is like hitting the jackpot for girls lol!

[cavmanier]

I asked a similar question. It seemed like they liked musicians more. www.girlsaskguys.com/.../q965782-would-you-rather-be-able-to-sing-really-well-or-be-a-great-athlete

[LittleSally]

I'm a musician myself, so I get along with them because we have a lot in common.
Athletes, the ones I've met and had conversations with, are usually not very bright, but nice, they don't really read books, listen to my type of music or like almost any of the things that I do, so I have nothing in common with them.

[musicbrain5]

A musician, because I'm a musician too. We could play together! I do play sports, but music is first.

[sammy_31]

Although I love music, I enjoy a guy who is athletic a little more. :)

[Hidden_P]

Musicians. But that's partly because I am one, common interest.

[rgb008]

An athletic musician?
Haha I love both but I'd have to say musician

[naima17]

You can be both, ya know. But ok have a truck for swimmers, soccer players, runners and basket ballers :D

[naima17]

I* thing* not truck

[MaskofInsanity]

Musicians. I admire creativity and I love music.

[ruviniamasha]

Thing is... Guys who do music can be really sexy in my opinion... shows they have that sensitive side

[bubblegumtaylor]

creativity = attractive

[lamebabe]

Musicians! I love artistic men. LOVE.

[LovelySerene]

Musicians, cause sports are boring

[Anonymous]

Muscians i love mark foster from foster the people. he's so sexy

[Cowardscrossplanet]

Agreed 😍

[obligations]

Atheletes... something about testosterone :)

[knotme]

Athletes, because of the bods...

[mandira]

athletes but if he plays piano he beats them all.

[bubbletrouble]

I prefer the athletic type.

[Anonymous]

definitely prefer musicians :D

[Anonymous]

Musicians because I could relate to them more:-)

[NoMoreDreams]

Musicians :)