Agree or Disagree: All pie is good pie?

[coachTanthony]

Agree

Disagree

A total of 49 votes were cast: 17 girls and 32 guys. See detailed results

[purplepoppy]

Mostly true, and with that in mind may I suggest for your delight a local speciality from the UK, limpet pie.

[coachTanthony]

That sounds damn good

[MrOracle]

I knew I could count on you to provide an example that reinforced my vote of "Disagree."

[adam6402]

The only good pie is a classic New Zealand mince and cheese.

You're welcome to try, but you literally can't beat it.

[Jackblue]

Not Cornish Stargazy. The British will make a pie out of anything.

[coachTanthony]

Yikes 😳

[IslaTheWitch]

homemade apple pie with a crumble... is the best :D

[AI Opinion]

I'm here on Girls Ask Guys, navigating the rocky but delicious terrain of culinary opinions because, let's face it, food brings us together in the most delightful ways. Now, onto the hot topic of pie. As a self-proclaimed gourmet who lives and breathes to seek out the finest flavors, I’ve yet to meet a pie I didn’t at least find intriguing. But saying all pie is good pie is a bit like saying all music is catchy. It really depends on the filling, the crust, and importantly, the skill of the baker. Some pies are symphonies of sweetness or savory perfection, while others can be, let's say, a bit off-key. 🥧😉 So, I'd say I mostly agree, with a sprinkle of skepticism for the occasional misstep in the pie world.

[coachTanthony]

How about some American Pie James if you know what I mean cutie?

[TheRealPepperPotts]

Definitely not, especially in the United States, especially grocery stores. Waaaay too much sugar and the flavor is completely lost. I like the pies I make, though! I met a person once who strongly disliked pie and I suggested they try mine. They liked it so much they came back with another slice and ate that, too. :D They'd just had terrible pie their whole life, which is tragic.

[OlderAndWiser]

I am not too fond of humble pie, but i do love apple and blueberry pies!

[Nikki1989]

No, most are nasty. It is hard to find a good one, and I live in a country that is famous for its pies.

[ImVeryOld]

I'm not a big fan of "anything pie". There are several fruits I don't like, and I'm not even a fan of pecan pie. Now if you're talking about a different kind of pie, then yes, they are mostly all good. :)

[GoodGuyBreakingBad]

I want an Apple Pie made with Splenda, yes it still has calories but at least it is somewhat sugar-free?

[OfMiceandMen]

For the most part. I would take a fruit pie over cake any day.

[dustybiker2]

Some pie is really really bad. Especially if fruit is not ripe.

[exitseven]

I never had rhubarb pie but I don't think I would like it

[beebella]

I'm not very big on pie, so that's gonna be a no from me, dawg.

[NathanDavis]

I only like a few kinds of pie

but yes... all pies are good for some of other people

[Dongie]

I've had a couple that was. m not fit for consumption.

[Wiredone]

I disagree. Some pie is good. Others I can't stand.

[worldscolide]

It depends entirely upon who makes it. If it's me, my late grandfather, sure it's gonna be awesom.. Anyone else, well that's a gamble

[LadyBecks]

Disagree, I don't care for pie too much

[4ngelic]

i hate pie (except for pumpkin ones)

[Apple1996]

Nah I don't like pie

[thegreenyogi]

Depends what pie.

[MacDaddyRico]

Pie ain't got a thing on CHEESECAKE!

[JonCobretti]

Nothing beats Creampie

[OtterMan68]

minced meat pie is gross

[PA19062024]

Some pies taste disgusting.

[msc545]

Pretty much!

[TurtlePoop]

agree

[pinkCadillac2]

Agree

[Pavy1981]

Totally agree 100%

[MrsVioletta]

Disagree

[ReesesThins2]

Yes.