What does it mean when a guy says you look different with makeup?

[Anonymous]

Is it necessarily a bad thing?

YES

No.

[experiencedguy]

Some times it is not some times it is...
When we r talking about Actresses, the do not look good without makeup...
But from my point of view, excessive makeup on normal girls dont suit them. They look good in some simple makeup only. If it goes to heavy they r not them.

[Dagrath]

It could mean that you actually look different than you originally did, so it could be a good or bad thing depending on the guy.

[bang678]

Like isn't that the point? Bitch i did not spend 30 minutes beating my face and making sure my wings are perf af just to look the same

[RJGraveyTrain]

Not necessarily. I guess it depends on his tone. When my boyfriend saw me without it he said I looked the same lol.

[taleets]

i think he thinks you don't look as good without it honestly. was this his first time seeing you without it?

[DoraDi]

Probably you just don't look like yourself. If it's a bad or a good thing you can only find it out from him.

[ace9881]

It means he is not used to seeing you in makeup, or having a hard time recognising you if I put too much of it. if he took a pause eg you look... different it usually means he prefers you without makeup or he is bad at complimenting beautiful girls 😅

[LittleSally]

When they use the word 'different' - it usually always means BAD.
When they say 'better' or 'more natural' or 'beautiful' then that means GOOD.

[Dme500]

no its not. different just means different. such as unrecognizable.

[LittleSally]

@Dme500 *I still stand by my statement. If for some people what you say is true: then it's still a diss - as in 'You wear waaay too much makeup - you look like a totally different person.'

[IAmBlueThunder]

Wtf else could it mean other than what it literally means?

[L_i_l_ly]

it's true everybody looked different with makeup on :)

[L_i_l_ly]

*looks

[Cloudy25]

Yes lol he's either saying that:
A) you don't look like yourself
Or
B) it makes you prettier
Or both, and I don't consider those compliments.

[hospitable_pepperoni]

Unless he says it in a mean way, it's just an observation

[Laetitia94]

perphaps he means you are more beautiful without it

[baileytabitha]

I'm not sure, but if a guy likes me at my best, he better damn like me at my worst!! (Messy hair, no makeup)

[ApplesDX]

It means you look different with makeup.

If you need an answer just ask him

[Carley99]

We all look different with makeup I guess it has a lot to do with how we apply it.

[asp123]

personally i'm not a fan of girls with makeup, because it hides her true self

[JustRollTheDice]

Not necessarily it could just be a compliment and he sees it as an enhancer

[Browneye57]

Well, don't you?
There's never a bunch of hidden meaning in what a guy says. Just accept it at face value.

[alice55]

No, it just mean that he didn't recognized you with it at first.

[Maria321]

it could mean good or bad im not sure I can't SEE YOU +_+

[Walrus_au]

it might be - or it might be that is his preferred look

[BanterBlitz]

It's a pretty neutral statement. It's not like he said you look worse with makeup.

[truemb]

the most girls looking better without any makeup...

and it means u look different.. i think he likes u more without it.

[zombiebabe]

no.. maybe he prefers you without

[sanaughty]

you look better with it

[dreads1991]

without!