I read a guys story about how he first slept with a transwoman who eventually went on to be his girlfriend of 3 years. At some point in the relationship they ended up living together. Now, I'm just curious as to whether guys on this site are open to have a relationship with a transwoman that could eventually evolve into you guys living together as a couple.
For example - Your girlfriend use to look like this when she was a guy but has since been on hormones for 5 years and replaced her penis with a vagina, which is self lubricating and is capable of having orgasms.
Would you be willing to live with your transgirlfriend as a couple?
YES
NO
Select gender and age to cast your vote:
Please select your age
Guys, Would you ever have a transgender Girlfriend and live in cohabition?
Post Opinion
Like
Share
Follow
Asker wants to hear from Guys only. Login to share your opinion.
Yes, personally I'd be fine with that. Kids have never been a goal of mine and regardless I am not against adopting. I find the trans terms a little confusing, but I'd be willing to date and potentially marry a woman who was born as a man, I wouldn't really be okay with it before the operation, but afterwards I don't see the problem. If someone has gone to such lengths to be what they feel comfortable as then I will see them as that. That said I find pre-op people questionable sometimes. I had one friend who thought he was trans for a while and another friend currently going through hormone therapy but quite irregularly. I guess I'm just skeptical but supportive about it until they finalize it and go all the way, then I'm just supportive.
You can think what you want, I really couldn't care any less if you want to assume that about me. Shaming tactics dont work on me, engage me in a real conversation if you want a worthwhile response.
Disgusting. And a insult. Degenerate society enforcing homosexuality that nature doesn’t even approve of. Feminism has truly ruined everything bc these transgenders are more feminine that western women. Smh
Nope! I only date and sleep with WOMEN who were BORN a WOMAN! I'm NOT into men who think they are women and certainly NOT into women who think they are men, they ARE just mentally sick and were raised wrong and need mental help and not some "operation"!
I'm sorry, but if I ever decide to get a relationship, it will be because I can imagine starting a family with that person (as of now, I don't want kids OR a relationship), and currently, a transwoman is not able to have children. "But you can always adop..." No. I can't. An adopted son is a fake son. An adopted daughter is someone else's daughter, not mine. I know it's rude to say that, but it's how I would feel, and I wouldn't want "my" kids to grow up with a dad who didn't really want them.
If she is post op I'd be willing to give it a shot. I don't have any experience with it though so I don't actually know what the vagina would feel like, hence the I'd be willing to try it part.
Yeah that's right too but I think the fierce infiltration into the wider society is not of a real concern. These procedures might cost milions on elite level. Not everyone who feels he/she borned in wrong body is able to afford it. Beside that transgenders are even rarer then gays or lesbos.
@lovetobreed Well, in my high school there is a guy who "is" now a girl. He looks like one at least, and i dont think he ever had any plastic surgery yet. I dont know how this gender transition works, but if i didn't know that he was a guy before, i wouldn't guessed it now.
Yeah everyone can make some homemade transformation but in that case the gear will be still hanging down there. We already advanced in this topic & speaking about top level transgender transformation where supposedly u cannot differentiate original from fake.
Because bysexuals will not pay so much attention to the penis obviously. Heterosexual will be disgusted. Maybe some gay would fall for it too but he would be disgusted by female feature again. Hard to say I am not pro but I could not live with transgender personally 🧔👍
You seem to be ignorant. The asker said post operation, which means they've gone through hormone reassignment, likely got breast implants, and replaced the penis with a vagina. Most of the time you won't be able to tell a transgender woman apart from a normal woman even when they're both naked and side by side. Look at that picture of above of the transgender woman in the bikini, look closely at it and tell me where the penis is? Cause I can't find it.
It's not about spoting it. It's his moral & ethical obligation to inform his potential partner about it. No matter how well surgeon faked it he us still not capable of delivering offspring.
It's not about spotting it? Your entire first argument was based on what a person of each different sexuality would think when seeing a transgender person. Your entire first argument was built on spotting the fact that she's a "man" and getting disgusted.
You're right about that part, currently the procedure doesn't allow for pregnancy. Why is it her obligation to inform anyone? Are infertile women morally or ethically obligated to tell you they can't bear children? Why would it matter to a lesbian if a transgender woman can't bear children?
You right about the basis of my initial argument. Let me recalibrate my statement. I am very open minded & support innovative solutions as this one is. Let's say he is perfectly faked from inside out. His personality & body is feminine just as the original, then I would probably give it a shot, why not the transformation reached perfect result.
There are plenty of woman who cannot bear fruit (may god give them cure). I think they have to inform their partner about this. No discussion, no exception. What if I want to have kids? So by that being said then transgender should also openly tell what's going on. The attitude of secrecy is a sign that something in his personality is not in level & that's bad & not fair.
Here's a big fat contradiction for you... why should transgender people have to tell their partner when the tranformation isn't perfect? The person should be able to tell beforehand, if they can't it would be their fault for not being aware enough? For example, if you saw a gay man on the street and thought he was a woman and flirted with him and then kissed him, would you blame him for not saying he was a man? You should have been more aware if it is so obvious. What I'm trying to say here is that if you can't tell the difference between a transgender woman and a real woman based on sight alone then what about it is imperfect im the recreation of a woman other than the ability to produce offspring?
Now to read your second paragraph. I don't know of any cases of God curing such women, luckily science is searching for a solution. Alright, so when does the woman have to tell you she's infertile?
After how long of dating? I don't think all secrecy is bad, in this case it's often used for protection as transgender people are often targetted for attacks, violence against transgenders is higher than average and most transgender people just want to be seen as what they see themselves. Therefore as a middleground couldn't they just admit they can't bear children to their partner? It's effectively the same thing since your argument is based on the ability to have children, why is the need to specify transgender included?
I don't know why u think transgender should keep secret that he changed gender, honestly. Even if I consider your argument that they might be targeted by less sensible people & haters. I am not saying the information should be delivered publicly but to that person he think will be his longterm relationship. I assume it should be nice guy who love him & even trough first shock should be able to accept him. Doesn't they say love have no limits & borders? What if the transgender subject will have some serious health complications connected with previous procedure. Another lie? Back to kids then. Why we cannot have kids we tried so many times? Another lie? You would be lying all your life. Only way is making it natural as possible and tell how things are. It might mean lowered chances of getting partner but we cannot just drop the basis of moral & ethics. It would not be fair towards his partner.
Obviously in the scenario with your gay character on street it's nonsense for him to shout on all street "don't kiss me I am not woman". That accident might happen no big deal. You cannot compare this to long term relationship with transgender.
When should infertile woman tell: In the moment when they entering into the stage of more serious long term relationship.
@lovetobreed I don't think they should keep it a secret, I'm saying they somewhat have to, even violence from partners is common.
You're saying they should be required to tell people such a personal secret and risk their safety? Then again we get into the discussion of when they should have to tell. If they have to tell on first date then there is no time for love to build, if they tell later then the chance of violence against them increases, the amount of people I hear say they would beat the shit out of a transgender woman if they kissed and didn't know it was a "man" is astounding. They say lots of things about love, yet you don't think you could love such a person.
What if your wife had a health complication from a knee surgery she had to get 4 years before she met you and never told you about? I'm not saying lying is the good answer, I'm saying that it's illogical to expect such a thing from transgender people when the outcome is so likely to be violence.
Again there are plenty of women who can't have children and who have previous health issues related to surgery, why does the person specifically have to admit to being transgender when they can simply admit that they had a surgery and that they can't have children? neither of those are lies, misrepesentations of the truth, yes, but not lies.
What part of your morals tells you that you need to inform people of the gender you were born as? This really feels targetted at just transgenders but if we make it a moral thing then why does it apply to only transgenders?
You know that is not specific at all, right? When they enter into the stage of more serious long term relationship... that could be after 3 months or after a year. Further, everyone has different ideas of when that stage would be.
When should transgenders have to tell their partners?
I sensing that you are too paranoid about assault on them. None will hurt transgender more then they would hurt woman. Its no logical reason. Domestic violence is existing & have nothing to do with this topic. I think revealing the truth as soon as possible would even decrease the chance of violence. I think they should reveal it before first sexual contact. Let's say u let him sleep with you & tell him next day. He might take it far more offensive as you literally took his ability of choice. Same as with incapability of delivering offspring. It's deliberately taking the decidion power of the partner. What about woman. You think real woman would like some man walking in transgender uniform & lying to the face of whole society would appreciate it? That's not the way it's hard topic but I feel it's wrong.
The reason why they hide it is because of fear of violence, some people get offended at the very idea of transgender people existing and attack them, there are tons of stories of it. Feel free to ignore it all as it is anecdotal though.
So basically they should reveal it on the first date? May as well demand she put it on her tinder profile too.
The transgender person didn't take away any choice from him in that scenario, he/she withheld personal information.
I have to ask, why are you or anyone else so obsessed about the gender they were born though? Why should they be demanded to reveal personal information to others that affects nothing? You could spend an entire lifetime with this person and never realize it yet you would get offended from sleeping with someone who appears in every way to be a woman? I want a serious answer.
I'm not sure what you're implying about that statement of women, are you saying women in general would disike transgenders?
Lying to the face of the whole society? You know there is a difference between having a secret and telling a lie, right? You feel like changing your gender is wrong? Or do you mean that it's wrong to not go around telling people intimate details about yourself? You just don't like that someone wants to change genders, be honest. Get over yourself, let people live their lives and be who they want to be, transgender people aren't out to lie and manipulate everyone they're just trying to be who they feel like they are. Their actions don't hurt you, even if you go your whole life married to a transgender and never know.
As for the children thing please don't go back to it. It's very hard to hide that you're not fertile, so the person has the choice to leave when they find out. The transgender person can waste your time and I agree they should be open about that fact (I think everyone should be open about desires when it comes to kids and everything when they start dating seriously, probably after the second date) but I don't think they should be morally obligated to tell you that they were born as a man. If it is something from their past that doesn't directly affect you then why do they need to mention it?
Maybe the thing that would help the most would be for you to explain why you see it as wrong, and to clarify what exactly you see as wrong.
Transgender could attack a reputation of some very poverful people on high positions for example by form of blackmail.
What about religion? You have people who will swear to God transgender is blasphemy on highest level.
It's not about those poor transgenders only. There is society around. And if we want to introduce an novelty into society we rather make damn sure we calculated it properly before hand.
Woman would not love fake woman who is actualy a man to be promenading around in transgender uniform pretending be woman & hiding its true identity. Its abusable, sick & I doubt the psyche of such a person would be damaged.
If we neglect moral & ethics then whore nation! Your santa Claus 666 will arise, trust me. The rabbit hole is deeper than you can imagine.
Anyone can blackmail. Also, isn't blackmail illegal?
What about religion? They have to prove their God and religion to be true before it holds any value. Why should I care if they see it as blasphemy? It doesn't negatively impact them they just choose to see it as immoral.
I agree we have to be careful but what is the problem it causes for society? People can get upset by whatever they want, people being upset by it doesn't make it wrong.
I disagree, many lesbian women happily date transgender women. Regardless I don't see how people being upset by it makes it wrong. It's abusable? How? Sick? How? I'm not sure I understand what you mean with that last sentence.
I agree that morals and ethics are important but whore nation? That's gotta be a joke right?
For the record I'm atheist, I don't believe in or worship any deity. That sounds like a conspiracy lol.
The problem for society would be the issue we discussing the whole time. You cannot sneak into heterosexual's life in transgender uniform. You directly taking from that person his right to decide. Transgender is whole new concept. Hybrid gender. Its fake & majority would not accept it. There is no reason. We can chose proper original woman from God's assembly line (billions of them).
I did not say anything against assimilation of transgender into society. If you remember I was even so generous I told u I would even live with one myself if the fake is perfect. I am able to make that sacrifice but only added he told me before we even jump to bed.
Do you realise keeping in secret means that transgender person did not accept himself from perspective of psychology. Why would anyone accept them. Your argument of violence is nonsense. Jews are persecuted & gased for last 70 years they still proudly tell they Jews. (Just as example)
You cannot prove existence of God by means of science it's foolish request.
I am sure government will give guidance once more transgender start poping up and we will all have to humbly accept it. I hope there will be obligation to inform otherwise sexual contact of this type will be illegal.
Yeah I'm not sure this snowflakes guy understands what gay is lmfao. You're not attracted to men, you're attracted to someone who is virtually indistinguishable from a real woman.
You didn't read the question. OP specifically stated: "... and replaced her penis with a vagina, which is self lubricating and is capable of having orgasms."
Again, she does not have a penis. This question specifically stated that she had it removed and replaced. Read the question before you start commenting lmfao 🙄
Well are you turned on by her dick? Or are you turned on by other men? Or are you ONLY turned on by her when she's dressed up and identical to a normal woman?
Well if you're attracted to someone who looks like a woman, then you're obviously straight.
Now if she was naked, with her dick out and everything, and you were still turned on, I might say you were bi, but it sounds like you only find her attractive if she looks exactly like a woman, like in a dress or something.
@Rambler221 If you see a 10/10 woman, wearing a dress, who looks no different than any woman, and you're turned on, you're straight.
It's not like you see the dick. Skali specifically said he's not turned on by dick. Nor men. Being attracted to the feminine form is a straight thing lmao
LOL glad U saw the sarcasm... Man, here in Manhattan (New York City) you see hot "women" all the time who are either dudes in womens clothing or women who were born as a guy! I'm glad I married a woman who was born a woman! I'd hate to be out there dating nowadays, too many obstacles to hop over and run from out there now! I really couldn't date/live with or marry a woman who was born a dude! It would always be in the back of my head that it IS biologically STILL a man, even if HE had HIS pecker chopped off, he had one! And I really dislike the whole world calling MEN who dress like WOMEN "Her" or "She", cause it IS jut a HE and a HIM! Born with a pecker=MAN Had pecker removed=You were still born a MAN Last woman I would ever wanna be with is one who looks like Heidi Klum but can fix my truck and mow my lawn like a dude!! lol
Girl's Behavior 
Guy's Behavior 
Flirting 
Dating 
Relationships 
Fashion & Beauty 
Health & Fitness 
Marriage & Weddings 
Shopping & Gifts 
Technology & Internet 
Break Up & Divorce 
Education & Career 
Entertainment & Arts 
Family & Friends 
Food & Beverage 
Hobbies & Leisure 
Other 
Religion & Spirituality 
Society & Politics 
Sports 
Travel 
Trending & News 
Most Helpful Opinions