Am I making gains or what?

This is me last year (before I started lifting, so 1 year of lifting) and holy shit I actually feel accomplished now πŸ’ͺ(look at profile picture) I didn't realize I was actually growing muscle XD *yes I'm aware I'm actually wearing a shirt here but u can still see my skinnyness lol)

Am I making gains or what?
Am I making gains or what?


And I know these pics is cringy AF! It's when I murdered my ears with rap and dressed all "swag". forgive me for being a fggt back then so don't start criticizing me I've changed completly lmao (I actually see those pics with digust too tbh) and yes that's the same bathroom as my pfp πŸ˜‚

Also any advice or workouts I should do? I'm always learning about myself in the gym!
Am I making gains or what?
Post Opinion