Why do people pretend they are a healthy weight or try pushing others to think so?

[Anonymous]

i don't really care but its annoying thick is the new thick then you see a photo of a girl with a big ass and small waist then a photo of a skinny girl saying no one can get this type of body which is bull shit.
am 6 feet and weigh 129-135 pounds which i known isn't healthy for my height or frame which i plan on changing one day.
here is a list of healthy weights for your shape and height.

am not trying to offend anyone but why can't we all accept when we are unheathy and try making a change?

girls be like thick no women your over weight accpeted it and change it.

fat guy riding a bike.

this is thick

this is also stick

this is what it looks like to be skinny nad unheathy

this is skinny heathy

[Anonymous]

The BMI scale is inaccurate because it doesn't account for muscle. Muscular people, because muscle weighs more than fat, are overweight on the BMI scale, so don't use that as your basis.

Either way, you're PARTIALLY right. The people you demonstrated as fat are not at a healthy weight. However, the people you showed as thick of healthy may not be healthy. They could be eating poorly, never exercising, and just got lucky with genetics but bet terribly out of shape. The "fat" people may be disabled or have a disease that makes it very hard to lose weight. The skinny and unhealthy may be naturally that way, again genetics. I know plenty of girls that eat tons and are still very naturally skinny. I know girls who eat healthy and exercise often and still have a lot of chub.

Long story short: BMI and body type don't equate to healthiness. Being larger and having fat isn't necessarily laziness nor is it always unhealthy.

Either way, it's not your business to tell someone that they need to do something t be healthy. I get that you want to help them and you may find it unsightly, but unless you're their doctor, their trainer, or they specifically asked you, it's best just to not mention it because it's not your business to.

[Asker]

First off let me say it agree with the first half of what you said but the rest is bull shit. Where was it telling anyone in my post what to do? I said why can't people admit when they have a problem then try changing it, if thats what they want or accepting themselves for who they are? Why do they instend try conviceing everyone to be just like them? please read the full post before you speak out of your ass

[Opinion Owner]

I read the post in its entirety. I was mentioning the fact that you wish people to step up and change their behavior, which implied that you feel it necessary to inform people of their poor health. This is also indirectly taken from the pictures. I may have gotten the wrong impression, but that is the idea you gave off. I do not know anyone who wishes for others to partake in unhealthy habits, but I have met many healthy people who try to change the lifestyles of others to fit theirs out of misdirected goodwill.

There's no need for you to talk to me like that. I did not insult you, simply discussed a viewpoint I disagreed with and explained why I thought it was wrong. If you are not imposing your lifestyle on other people by trying to get them to act healthier and are instead are looking to have people examine their health based on their choices when they notice a problem, then there is no problem and I simply misunderstood.
Is this the case?

[Pomegranate139]

First of all, I look how I want, and I'm DAMN sexy! Don't you judge me for it!

vignette2.wikia.nocookie.net/.../latest

Second that 'unhealthy skinny' girl is perfectly fine. people can be naturally skinny you know.
Also BMI charts aren't accurate.

[Asker]

Lol fuck your feeling am naturally skinny myself and am not telling you shit. I ask why can't people admit when they are unheathy and make a change if thats what they want. Why me like am skinny mean while your 250 pounds of be like am thick as fuck and be 300 pounds. Thats what I asked. So please get your facts straight. I then ask why can't people accepted themselves for who they are?

[Pomegranate139]

Maybe they like being big and like they way they look. If they like being big, let them be big. Why should they change themselves because you don't like how they look?
And you're being a bit contradictory by saying they should 'accept themselves for who they are' when before you said they should change.

I also have no clue what you are saying in that third sentence you responded with. Is English not your first language?

[Cody01]

Why the hell is there small frame, etc? Like if your a skinny mofo or a fatass? This chart shouldn't be taken seriously because there is no weight range for a certain Height. Like for my Height and "frame" I'm over the recommend weight range, which means according to this chart I'm overweight. Yet I'm leaner than the majority of the population & have a higher muscle mass than the majority.

[Cody01]

Use body fat%

[TallAnon]

"this is also stick" is probably the hottest out of all of em. 6"7 isn't on the chart, now I'm sad.

[BiPolyAlan]

Quit body shaming people. Lots of people do unhealthy shit that has nothing to do with weight. So just stop.

[Asker]

Why should i? Am not body shaming anyone only speaking the truth you can be 250 pounds calling yourself thick. But all I ask was how come people can't admit when they are unheathy and try making a change? or accept them themself for who they are. How is that body shaming?

[independentman]

I have 5'8" 121 lbs