Are singers not "real artists" if they don't write their own music or play an instrument?

[Smashingdoozy]

Many famous singers don't play any instruments or write their own music.

Some honourable mentions:

Mariah Carey, Christina Aguilera, Beyonce, Kanye West, Elvis Presley, Rihanna and Celine Dion

[Nikki1989]

The artistic expression is a form of creative artistry in itself. Where it becomes a joke is when everything is computer generated, auto-tuned, pitch-corrected, which is what 90% of modern music is today. If you think your favorite artist is making real music, think again. Half the time, most modern vocalists would struggle to sing in key without technology helping them along but it not just vocals, fake guitar tracks, triggered drums, I could go on and on.

[emeraldsaphire]

Singing is just as valid as an art-from as any other. So I think they are real artists. Singing is really hard too, so I don't blame them from wanting to work with other artists. Creative projects made by groups are just as valid, but also different

[msc545]

They are the real artists., The human voice is the most difficult instrument there is to use,.

[Levin]

That is my sentiment towards Harry Styles, yes.

[AI Opinion]

Music is about expression, whether through voice or an instrument. 🎤 Even if singers don't write or compose, their interpretation and performance can evoke powerful emotions, making them real artists. Think of their voice as an instrument and how they bring songs to life. Just like in gaming, it's not just about the tools but how you use them to create an unforgettable experience. Each artist contributes uniquely, and their artistry isn't limited by whether they write or play instruments. 🎶

[WilliamPamer446]

Is booty fetish music artistic. Spreading or smacking.

[KittyKat90210]

They're real artists. Voice is an instrument that requires skill and training. Writing music is a different (but related) art form that requires a different skill set, but voice performers are artists.

[Shiprex]

The artistry here with singers is in the voice and not what they are singing. It's like saying the artist who paints is talentless because it's the paint that you see.

[FreyaRed]

Everyone who doesn't write their songs isn't an artist

[PrettyCrumblBb]

Their voice is their instrument.

Didn't Elvis play guitar?

[Smashingdoozy]

Yes. He didn't write his own music though

[Anonymous]

If they are singing they are playing a musical instrument.

[AydenHazor]

Vocal performance is just as much art as the rest of music is

[Still-alive]

Hey as long as they can belt and carry a tune i suppose thats all that matters

[Bklynbadboy12]

Yes they are you have to respect the fact they can do something that most people can't

[FenixG45]

Singers are real artists; otherwise, people wouldn't copy them or they wouldn't become hits.

[GlowUpGirly5]

Their voice is the instrument.

[LiamJHayden]

The voice is an instrument.

[beefcakebradybatson]

Yes, they ARE real artists.

[typicalmen]

I sing, so thanks, this makes me feel better ❤️