I'm 36, she's 25...what should I do?

I have a dilemma...I like her and she likes me...she's been very aggressive and wants to date but I am 11 yrs. older than her...mentally, physically, I am much younger than 36 (I act and look like I'm her age) and that's partly why younger girls seem to get attracted to me but still...the age, will it matter? Should I let her go or try to make it work?
Updates
+1 y
great arguments, guys, and thanks for responding, you've been really helpful :)
I'm 36, she's 25...what should I do?
Post Opinion