If you found out for sure that your sibling was the reincarnation of your True Love, would you get romantically involved with them?

Question

Inspired by the story of David and Morwen in the RPG Changeling the Dreaming.

Carbon-12 · Accepted Answer

No. First of all how would I know they are my true love? Like is my sibling 20 years younger than me? That's a genuine question, I don't know the story.

Second, I am a strong believer in true love/soulmates. However I don't necessarily see these relationships in a romantic way. If someone is your soulmate, it means to me that they are someone you get along with to the core. Someone who truly understands you. I do think you should try to find a romantic partner that is your soulmate, but other soulmates can just be your very good friends.

If they are your sibling, great! Spend a lifetime together, but not as a couple.

thenewgirlll · Accepted Answer

So let’s pretend this could be true, then destiny would play a part too, I guess? Was it a mistake that you two are siblings now or is it the destiny?
Anyway my answer is no, but taking in consideration that “true love” is pretty strong and especially if you’ve loved each others in a past life. I think most people wouldn’t care about incest eventually.

coachTanthony · Accepted Answer

--------------It reminds me too much of Pet Sematary.  Can't do it!  Won't do it.  Don't ask me to do it.

Jean-Marie_Céline · Accepted Answer

I would not, and please don't give her any further excuse...

mikeB71 · Answer

Absolutely not that would be incest in Tiger Ridge and all kind of stuff God has burnt whole city down because of Sodom and Gomorrah and turn them into a pillar of salt and other things happened to when you fuck your family your kids come out with three eyes and one leg

QueenTanya · Answer

i don't believe in reincarnation but since this is hypothetically speaking then i know it'd be weird but i might

Jjpayne · Answer

Nope... I might bond with them but our relationship would change to fit the family relation.

DeeDeeDeVour · Answer

I can't live with the thought of having committed incest.

Dav1ss · Answer

Well if it was definitely true and it was real sure tons of people thought I liked my sister anyway so not too big of a change lol

james2018dean · Answer

I dont believe in reincarnation.
The answer to that is that thoughts are energy. And we've learned that energy is never destroyed.
This, in my thinking, is the answer to people who believe that they are reincarnated.
The population keeps growing. Why wouldn't everybody be reincarnated? And where are the new lives coming from?
Do you think you'll remember this life after your death? If you do, where were you before you were here? What do you remember?

BuckWild · Answer

"True Love". That's pretty rich! What's up with the trick questions?

GoodGuyBreakingBad · Answer

I would love them and hope to be close than my Sister is with me but nothing romantic cause of the genes.

Duckysback · Answer

None of the things in there are real. Me having siblings, reincarnation, or true love.

Celtero · Answer

I'm much more inclined to believe in reincarnation than 'true love.'

BoxySama · Answer

In that instance, the karmic ties must be real strong, I would consider you lucky to continue that relationship

Lotusinwater · Answer

No haha but I’m pretty sure my brothers kid is a reincarnation of a Japanese war general 😂👊👍🏼

wynn-ing · Answer

I don't believe in any "true love" for myself or my life so they wouldn't exist to begin with.

brigfrey25 · Answer

All polls must have " none of the above " as an option to vote for. I have so much to say about this topic but... 😏😁

soleil2666 · Answer

Opposite sex most certainly. The only risk is inbreeding. Same sex no way (I guess we'd be very close but what else could you do?)

poneglyphs · Answer

Not really but I treat her better than most of my family members

some101 · Answer

Search for "autumn in my heart" korean drama. It has similar situation.. not quite tho.

I might have a good relationship with her as siblings... tho wish that never happen, that would be heart breaking.

moonpie89 · Answer

I don't believe in reincarnation. Sounds like a weird situation.

Exorcist_Rampage · Answer

Yes and you know my situation already, so no surprise, madam WhiteShoulder of New Jersey!

theCobbler · Answer

Thats a sick idea let alone a? question!!! Thats Your family and In breeding = Retardation..

Davidstang · Answer

Lol funnny question,  Same sex or opposite sex?

Liam_Hayden · Answer

While I believe in resurrection, I do not believe in reincarnation.

Pete671 · Answer

Sure why not, we're only here for brief time so why not be happy?

SydneySentinel · Answer

Nope, no thank you.

beebella · Answer

It'd still be my sibling, so no.

jay1966 · Answer

That's not normal on any level. If you think about.

knewbie · Answer

Too many genetic diseases and all of my siblings are brothers... Even if it was a sister no... Would go full MGTOW first.

bananathunder · Answer

looks like i'm sharing a bed with my sister lol

Fuentes · Answer

Is this a trailer park question Eewww af lol

Onepiece_fan2000 · Answer

No it’s still a sibling

Lemia · Answer

Depends on the circumstances

JesseJayNeak · Answer

Isn't it kind of incest-y

Internarchitect · Answer

I am sorry, but very weird.

NickiB · Answer

No...

Countrywildmangirl · Answer

Hellyeah.

Anna0125 · Answer

I couldn’t be with a siblings.

Jerre · Answer

Unfortunately I don’t have female siblings

the_sinner · Answer

Eww No for god's sake.

PimpJuicy · Answer

For sure

Avicenna · Answer

No way

coolhandroo · Answer

Finially an important question

Silent_Eyes · Answer

Wtf? Hell no

Philyouup · Answer

eeewww. lol.

Sweetnessxoxo · Answer

ew no

GreenGold1992 · Answer

wtf?

JustforLaughs1 · Answer

... Nope!!

If you found out for sure that your sibling was the reincarnation of your True Love, would you get romantically involved with them?

Most Helpful Opinions

Most Helpful Opinions

What Girls & Guys Said

If you found out for sure that your sibling was the reincarnation of your True Love, would you get romantically involved with them?

Most Helpful Opinions

Most Helpful Opinions

What Girls & Guys Said

We're glad to see you liked this post.