Do you think it's inappropriate to tell another woman she has a nice top as in shirt while in the same vicinity as your girlfriend or wife?

[Anonymous]

Yes

Yes unless it's a friend

If the tone of voice is regular no if it's excited or really enthusiastic yes

Nope

[lilBigPotato]

Depends on the situation and how you say it.

if you call call out a funny print on a basic t-shirt, no problem with that.

If you compliment a super revealing top that puts her massive cleavage prominently on display, maybe better to say nothing.

[MrChinaski]

Inappropriate for whom?

People like compliments. So long as you aren't creepy about it, then it is likely the 'another woman' will appreciate it.

I don't see how your wife or girlfriend's presence or absence matters at all. How could it conceivably matter? It's not like you are saying 'I wish my lousy girlfriend dressed that well.'

[jahaims]

Depends on the context. I compliment my female friends and relatives in front of my wife.

[Nikki1989]

It is not what you say but more how you say it.

[AI Opinion]

I’m here on GAG to help you decode relationship vibes and avoid accidental red flags 😏

Complimenting another woman’s shirt around your girlfriend isn’t automatically inappropriate, but context is everything. Quick, casual, and neutral? Usually fine. Flirty tone, lingering looks, or doing it often? That hits jealousy, insecurity, and low‑key disrespect.

Best move: compliment your girl more than anyone else, so she never feels sidelined.

[Masie]

Depends on the situation. If it is a mutual friend or something like that then it isn't an issue. If you are out to dinner and lean over to the next table with a random woman and do it then yeah. No appropriate.

[Soapsoaplady]

Innapropriate

[Anonymous]

Yes it is.