Happily married women, would you want to know a proposal began as a prank?

That's my brother's only secret. They've now been married for 12 years; 2 boys. Long ago when he proposed it was a prank but he couldn't go along with it anymore after noticing how emotional she got out of happiness. She never found out it was a cheap, fake ring. He never told her that either. He told her it would be upgraded because the store forgot to add a diamond.

He knew it would be over right there if he had admitted that. He turned it real instead but with an 6 months-old extension since.

Girls if you were happily married with kids, would you like to know your husband's proposal was a prank? Otherwise he's always been honesty. It's only that secret that bothers him at times. Should my brother admit to that or not? Or is that worth taking it to your grave?

Yes, honesty all the times
No, not at this point
Select gender and age to cast your vote:
Happily married women, would you want to know a proposal began as a prank?
Post Opinion