
God can’t be All Powerful, All Knowing and All Good. So which is he?


And this is probably the main reason why I left religion.
I've always understood that god and monotheism is the main aspect, but when I think about it deeply with all his traits, the ones you mentioned, he seems kind of messed up and sadistic.
God is more than capable of creating a reality where only good exists and he could have created something other than humans or program them to be another way e. g. make them incapable of feeling sadness.
Even if god never created humans and the animals we have in this world basically ruled it, look at how sadistic it can be too, I mean how many animals kill and eat other animals, it's simply a cruel world and Mr All Powerful decided to make it that way, which says it all, but apparently the devil is the bad guy, I mean what does he even do, punish people in the hellfire, that god created for none-believers, basically doing his dirty work.
You are mistaken in your view. God IS love. He made it exist. It is his greatest attribute. The scripture says with evil things God can not be tried, nor does he himself try anyone. He Sent his only son to die for us so that we can be redeemed. And as the creator of all good things, he can undo all the harm that man has done. Soon he will, then we will welcome our loved ones back from the dead. Sickness, death, suffering, pain will all be removed. God has permitted man to use his free will in order to show us that we were not designed to rule apart from him. We cannot direct our own step let alone others. And we have no power to change the plagues of man.
It's no contradiction. You can do or live however you choose and God won't stop you. But because he created us he knows we have a need for spiritual things. Those who ignore it and instead try to live against what the Bible says have proven that while we can point our feet on a path freely, the end result is death if we try to live apart from his standards. This passage acknowledges this fact while not saying that we don't have the choice of what to do. GOD won't force us because he wants us to come to him of our own free will. Makes good sense right? You wouldn't want a wife who was forced to be with you. You would want one who wants to be with you.
God can choose to see the future, but it. Doesn't mean it is our destiny. He has foresight but only uses it to fulfill his Ultimate purpose. That purpose being a world united in peace under his kingdom. If God had destroyed Adam and Eve as well as Satan right in the beginning, it would have left room for others to doubt. Obviously some did, since before Noah's ark there were angels who materialized and mated with women. This produced the offspring known as the nephilim. It became so bad that God destroyed those wicked ones, with only some animals and Noah and his family surviving.
The evidence of what? That God is Real, that he loves us, or that he really cares about us? How about the evidence that we can personally be a friend of God? Tell me the evidence you need. I will provide you with the Bible's answer, which is God's word. It is no trouble. I want you to know the truth. Did you know God has a personal name, and that it is used over 7,000 times in the scriptures? He invites us to taste and see that he is good. If you are honest, humble, and hunger for the truth you will find that God will let himself be found by you.
You’re setting the definition of “good” at not letting bad things happen. But we know this isn’t true. For example, we all know that a helicopter parent that never lets their child experience anything bad is not a good parent. We know that people born unable to feel pain are in constant danger, to the point of near disability (don’t realize how hot the pan is, etc…) We know a forced apology isn’t worth sh*t. All the “good” deeds of a man done against his will, do not make him a good person. We know that progress is driven by discomfort, and that hedonistic lifestyles usually lead to poor quality of life and in society to a general lack of development and improvements. In his infinite knowledge and wisdom, and goodness, God chose to use His infinite power to create a world where some of that goodness could exist. And that included allowing bad things to happen.
This Negative disintegrating force is the Integrating Power working, so to say, at a lower level relatively to that at which it had been working in the organism that is being dissolved. It is not another power. Both the Bible and common‐sense tell us that ultimately there can be only ONE power in the universe, which must, therefore, be the Building‐power, so that there can be no such thing as a power which is negative in itself; but it shows itself negatively in relation to the particular individual, if through want of recognition he fails to provide the requisite conditions for it to work positively.
But I think the answer you are looking for is this: God is impersonal.
Thank you bot
Opinion
8Opinion
Bold of you to think you know what "good" is on a godly scale. I'm atheist, but I can still recognize that this argument fallacious, because you don't actually know all the repercussions of what happens.
Even ignoring that, if you were to think that freedom was the ultimate good, then you would also accept that people who are given it may do bad, and stopping it would be you betraying the ultimate good, yourself.
That would be like someone killing baby Hitler and you, not knowing what baby Hitler would turn into, say: "you think killing a baby could be good on a godly level." That question has a different context when you know he's gonna grow up to put millions of people into death camps.
It's a matter of perspective, and you don't know what you don't know.
Cute, but I never actually said that. But you keep on swinging at that strawman if you want to.
We’re human so we can’t be all powerful all good and all knowledgeable God can be the creator of the universe would be all powerful god sets the rules in which we live by so we can be all good, God knows what we’re going to do but he lets us have free will so he can be all knowledgeable. If human didn’t have free will we wouldn’t be able to choose good over evil we would just be doing good but that the same time we would just basically be like robots
Why don't you try actually READING the kjv Bible! It's all in there. Free will! People have free will! Through God's prophecy, he knows all things are set for a reason, changing anything would make God a liar and Satan equal to God. The meaning of life is to thwart Satan's plans.
Yes, don't put God on your level. This world is like a train station with students in a classroom taking a test to go on it. The one driving the train is God and he knows the answers to all the questions not to mention knows how you'll answer them before you do. You can still ask help from the teacher, from the one driving the train, from Jesus who is God, but if you chose not to, you'll fail and not make it to the trains destination which is heaven. But there is one in the class who failed already that is trying to give people advice, that one is satan, he finds it his job to do so.
.. thats one way of putting it.
... Or... wait for it... "All Powerful, All Knowing and All Good" are subjective and meaningless terms, and they are human centric! Should have finished school kiddo. God is God.
A lion will kill a rival male, eat it's children, and mate with it's females, plus fight to the death all it's life. A human doing that would be regarded as "evil". But to the other lions it can't be, as it's emulating what they do.
You're struggling with critical thinking.
Trying to apply logic to an imaginary being isn't very logical.
Still trolling Christians with click bait I see. I'd like to know what you believe as it doesn't seem to be in God. I take it you are really an atheist.
First of all God is all three. However he granted men free will to do what they want, including killing 6 million Jews. God knows what a person will do, including never accepting God's forgiveness. For those that he knows will He makes sure that they are not killed before that time. For those that never will their time comes to an end when someone ends it or from disease or old age.
You also don't read very well.
You are hopeless.
God is All Powerful, All Knowing and All Good.
God is not our servant to be forced to fix our mistakes.
God help us and show us the way, but we fix our own mistakes.
you didn't prove nothing.
God is all powerfull because it can create absolut anything, so all its creation will olso reprezent his power.
God know evrething, good and evil things that had, are and will hapen, but is not oblicate by nobady to stop them in the way we want. "a building is on fire and God need to start a rain" <is completly wrong to think like that because you limitate God power and influence on this entire univers. Eart is not the central of the univers. God will make shure we will remember that tragedy in order for us to be more responsable and prevent such things to ever happen and all the survivers from all thous bad things are God mercy, because God save them and give them a second chance to prove themself they are diferent.
God is all good, because God justice is absolutly right, God can bee feel the moust close to humanity in the worst moment of human life because only them people start to think about God and salvation.
And because humans do that good things happen in thous terible moment. A good example is to watch the video from Linkin Park - What i've done.
I prove, you didn't prove nothing.
God is All Powerful, All Knowing and All Good. Just because you you can not does not mean God can not...
Just ask him.
Superb Opinion