Based on logical reasoning.. would you say that God if he exists is all-good?

[Anonymous]

Yes he is all-good/ omnibenevolent!

No he is pure evil/ purely malevolent!

He is a mix of good and evil!

[normalice]

I would say an existing god would not define good and bad by what we do in life but rather in the afterlife. The entire vast universe as we know it would just be the inside of a seed to such a being, with a whole forest blooming with each soul that sprouts from it. What difference would it make if some inner part of the seed did something awful to some other part of the seed. The god would not be able to tell the difference.

[strateguy632]

about awful.

[Lliam]

I don't believe in gods. But the Hebrew God that Christians worship is a sadistic maniac, no matter how loving they try to paint him.

For example, he is all about self-denial and sacrifice. And what parent would condemn their child to eternal torture for not "worshiping" them properly?

[Anonymous]

If we’re talking about the Christian god. There’s absolutely no way that he’s all-good, have you read the bible? Not to mention the fact that so many of his followers are terrible human beings who use his faith as an excuse to harm others.

[Opinion Owner]

I mixed up nothing. I meant what I said.

[TheUniqueOne96]

If he's all powerful and all knowing along with being all good, then no.

The world we live in is an example of that.

God chose to create humans who he knew were assholes, like why didn't he just choose to create the good ones.

There's also the argument that good can't exist without evil - like is a god who's that amazing incapable of creating that kind of reality? Simply create one where we all know what's right and wrong, but will choose to do right and at least not wrong on a major level.

[jshm2]

You assertion is moot, and your statement farcical to begin with.

Logic can only apply to something physically quantifiable - God is not.

Likewise, reasoning can only be applied to something which the reasoner has enough of an understanding of - no human ever can.

As for "exists," the term can only apply to something with a beginning and end. God can be neither as he is beyond such trifling's.

[strateguy632]

logic: people need air and water & food. coincidentally we are born in such a world with oxygen hydro water and fruits and cows, logically god must exist and be beneficent provider.

[Subglacial]

Thank goodness God gave us glove-shaped hands. If our hands were any other shape, all of the gloves we have now would be useless. If that isn't divine providence, I don't know what is.

[jahaims]

Yeah babies getting cancer and raped clearly shows God is good

[strateguy632]

you can only blame the rapist for choosing and doing evil. god didn't do anything

[Agape93]

Nope