They are males first in foremost. I dont care what the fuck they do to their bodies they have a physical advantage over Females so it is not fair at all to female athletes. If anything trans should be forced into their born to sex class be grouped together or just banned from sports that have to separate by gender.
I think if people truly believe that their female then yes they will allow them to compete with the women. If not then the people that support their cause are just telling them what they want to hear in order to make them feel better. In other words, they don't really support trans. They already had this happen in MMA and women were getting their asses kicked all to support this agenda. Its actually good comedy more than anything.
1
0 Reply
Anonymous
(18-24)
+1 y
Taking testosterone/estrogen isn't like steroid usage lol. Every has testosterone and estrogen. Hell, I'm a girl with really high testosterone! XD
Anyway, I think it's completely fine because it still completely possible for anyone to win.
No, because men and women have biological differences in strength and stamina, sex change surgery does not change that. This then puts real women competitors at a disadvantage.
Dick or no dick they are still a male you can put tits on a guy they are still a male, they are bigger stronger then a female, so they will prevail over a born female. Question if a female changes to male and competes against born males the converted female will loose and will they complain about loosing because they are smaller weaker .
No they should either have their own category (unlikely there would be enough competitors in the beginning) or they compete as the sex they were born this should also extend to things like prison's in my opinion
They really should have their own category, it's really unfair to the women who've trained day and night tirelessly and suddenly some guy with some tits walks onto the track and smokes them..
Dude, the exceptions do not make the rule. Yes there are women who can outperform men, but they are few and far between. The AVERAGE man will almost always outperform the average woman physically.
Yes, because the average man works on it, the average woman doesn't.
It's a social applicant exception.
If the average woman would have worked on it with the motivation of a man in todays society, there is no proficient evidence that could prove she would've not been able to perform as good.
In fact, there's more proficient eviction that claims otherwise, especially when it comes to leg physique since in the history we know woman aren't very known for working on their upper body as much as they're known for their lower body.
When it comes to cardiovascular endurance there's no research neither is there evidence that proves either way.
99% of the time a biological male will have a distinct muscular and lung capacity advantage over a biological female even if she happens to be the exact same height and weight
I know, especially sports that require a quick power usage. Men have better developed fast-twitch fibers which are ideal for lifting heavy or do something quick (move fast on a short distance, jump high, etc). Plus, the hip bones give them an advantage for running, since men have more narrow hips compared to their overall frame they can run better as their femural bones are more perpendicular to the ground. These are all things that a gender change through surgery and taking hormones won't change
How about doing some research which includes finding out that trans athletes, both trans men and trans women, reach competitive levels of their peers with 1 year of HRT, give or take a couple of months for individual needs. I'd agree that someone can't suddenly say they're transgender so they automatically get into the division they identify with. But maybe with a doctor's and trainer's note, they should be able to compete.
0
0 Reply
Anonymous
(25-29)
+1 y
No. Biologically they are not female and have many unfair advantages over biological women. In combat sports this advantage becomes especially dangerous. I have nothing against transwomen, but this is something I don't agree with.
They should remove themselves. I am a strong supporter of trans people and I donβt feel that acknowledging the clear advantage invalidates their gender identity. Fair is fair.
I have reevaluated some opinions in regards to lgbt issues but this is one i dont. Men ( genetic) have a clear advantage until they are on years of hormones in many of these events.
I say this purely because of the fact that biological men have a stronger build then women so it would be biased. But women still kick ass (especially trans women!) But I would want to make a competition as fair as possible.
fuck no. Just a guy that couldn't make it in the mens leagues so he goes and try the woman's. What happen with getting your ass kicked and it giving you the modivation to bust you ass and work harder at the sport you were competing in
Maybe in their own league. Biological males hold a distinct genetic advantage over women. So allowing biological males, even former males, compete with women is unfair.
It has always been defined what is man and what is woman as they appear outwardly. If an individual changes sex then he / she can compete in the championships of his sex. Therefore a transsexual woman must compete with other women.
The biological males should compete with biological males and the biological females should compete with biological females. Surely by now they should realize how uneven the playing field is if they went by gender and not biological sex.
Fuck no. . thats someone's son after all... trannys have taken their shit to far... i dont care what their fucked up head thinks if you got a dick your a man... i identify as a bird... dont mean i can fly
What Girls & Guys Said
Opinion
79Opinion
They are males first in foremost. I dont care what the fuck they do to their bodies they have a physical advantage over Females so it is not fair at all to female athletes. If anything trans should be forced into their born to sex class be grouped together or just banned from sports that have to separate by gender.
Separated by sex*
I think if people truly believe that their female then yes they will allow them to compete with the women. If not then the people that support their cause are just telling them what they want to hear in order to make them feel better. In other words, they don't really support trans. They already had this happen in MMA and women were getting their asses kicked all to support this agenda. Its actually good comedy more than anything.
Taking testosterone/estrogen isn't like steroid usage lol.
Every has testosterone and estrogen. Hell, I'm a girl with really high testosterone! XD
Anyway, I think it's completely fine because it still completely possible for anyone to win.
*Everyone
No, because men and women have biological differences in strength and stamina, sex change surgery does not change that. This then puts real women competitors at a disadvantage.
Dick or no dick they are still a male you can put tits on a guy they are still a male, they are bigger stronger then a female, so they will prevail over a born female. Question if a female changes to male and competes against born males the converted female will loose and will they complain about loosing because they are smaller weaker .
No they should either have their own category (unlikely there would be enough competitors in the beginning) or they compete as the sex they were born this should also extend to things like prison's in my opinion
They really should have their own category, it's really unfair to the women who've trained day and night tirelessly and suddenly some guy with some tits walks onto the track and smokes them..
Words taken right out of my friend's mouth.😂😂😂
It's not true that men got a biological advantage, there are enough woman with big ass legs that can run like fucking werewolves...
There should be freedom in the choice so I believe there can be a female specific race and male specific as well as a general gender race.
The ones who claim to be what biologically they aren't should go to either general or their original gender.
Dude, the exceptions do not make the rule. Yes there are women who can outperform men, but they are few and far between. The AVERAGE man will almost always outperform the average woman physically.
Yes, because the average man works on it, the average woman doesn't.
It's a social applicant exception.
If the average woman would have worked on it with the motivation of a man in todays society,
there is no proficient evidence that could prove she would've not been able to perform as good.
In fact, there's more proficient eviction that claims otherwise, especially when it comes to leg physique since in the history we know woman aren't very known for working on their upper body as much as they're known for their lower body.
When it comes to cardiovascular endurance there's no research neither is there evidence that proves either way.
No, the average man is just born with advantages.
Such as?
More muscle mass, denser bones better hand-eye coordination, to name a few.
99% of the time a biological male will have a distinct muscular and lung capacity advantage over a biological female even if she happens to be the exact same height and weight
I know, especially sports that require a quick power usage. Men have better developed fast-twitch fibers which are ideal for lifting heavy or do something quick (move fast on a short distance, jump high, etc). Plus, the hip bones give them an advantage for running, since men have more narrow hips compared to their overall frame they can run better as their femural bones are more perpendicular to the ground. These are all things that a gender change through surgery and taking hormones won't change
Exactly
How about doing some research which includes finding out that trans athletes, both trans men and trans women, reach competitive levels of their peers with 1 year of HRT, give or take a couple of months for individual needs. I'd agree that someone can't suddenly say they're transgender so they automatically get into the division they identify with. But maybe with a doctor's and trainer's note, they should be able to compete.
No. Biologically they are not female and have many unfair advantages over biological women. In combat sports this advantage becomes especially dangerous. I have nothing against transwomen, but this is something I don't agree with.
They should remove themselves. I am a strong supporter of trans people and I donβt feel that acknowledging the clear advantage invalidates their gender identity. Fair is fair.
I have reevaluated some opinions in regards to lgbt issues but this is one i dont. Men ( genetic) have a clear advantage until they are on years of hormones in many of these events.
I say this purely because of the fact that biological men have a stronger build then women so it would be biased. But women still kick ass (especially trans women!) But I would want to make a competition as fair as possible.
fuck no. Just a guy that couldn't make it in the mens leagues so he goes and try the woman's. What happen with getting your ass kicked and it giving you the modivation to bust you ass and work harder at the sport you were competing in
Maybe in their own league. Biological males hold a distinct genetic advantage over women. So allowing biological males, even former males, compete with women is unfair.
How comes I don't see transgender males doing sports on the male teams? ohh yea because they know they don't have a chance
It has always been defined what is man and what is woman as they appear outwardly. If an individual changes sex then he / she can compete in the championships of his sex. Therefore a transsexual woman must compete with other women.
The biological males should compete with biological males and the biological females should compete with biological females. Surely by now they should realize how uneven the playing field is if they went by gender and not biological sex.
Fuck no. . thats someone's son after all... trannys have taken their shit to far... i dont care what their fucked up head thinks if you got a dick your a man... i identify as a bird... dont mean i can fly