Trans - women are not real women. Can you prove me wrong?

Question

Daedelus · Accepted Answer

I know you’re just trying to piss people off, but the fact is that this entire question depends on what you refer to as “real women”. Some people in the replies have said that real women are those who can give birth - suggesting that children and the elderly are not women. Some have said that they need to have a “female” sex organ, ie. a vagina - suggesting that trans women who have had vaginoplasty operations count as “real” women. Some have said that your gender depends on which genitals you were born with - which raises the question of what gender intersex people are supposed to identify with. And, of course, there’s the argument that your gender depends on your chromosomes - but, as several people have pointed out, you can be born with all sorts of chromosomal variations that don’t fit the XX/XY binary. Your arguments seem to be rooted in prejudice and stereotypes (hence the image you so kindly provided us with), rather than anything approaching a reasonable claim. Trans women suffer constantly because of the views you are advancing, views that are harmful and small-minded. Trans women are women.

worldscolide · Accepted Answer

I can't because its true. The one major thing that separates women from men is the ability to carry children.

A contradiction can not exist in reality. Not in part, nor in whole.

To believe in a contradiction is to abdicate your belief in the existence of the world around you and the nature of the things in it, to instead embrace any random impulse that strikes your fancy - to imagine something is real simply because you wish it were. A thing is what it is, it is itself. There can be no contradictions.

Trans people are walking talking contradictions.

Anonymous · Accepted Answer

Yes, through science.  Although if you're one of those conservative nuts that doesn't believe in science than nothing will convince you. Believing trans women aren't women is using your feelings as your reasoning rather than logic science or facts which all point to trans women being women. I don't respect the opinions based off hurt feelings.

MissDawn7961 · Accepted Answer

boy that photo has 1 ugly looking thing N it ! U R right ! for these trans have no - natural vagina , do not have a natural reproductive system so they can not give birth or breasts that can have milk N them to feed their new born baby with - ! thanks

RingOfFire · Answer

Of course they're not "real" women. Every cell in your body contains DNA that indicates your gender. Mutilating your genitals does not change that DNA. There are only two genders, male and female. And you will remain the same gender you were born your entire life regardless of what surgical changes you make.

PS: Hermaphrodites are not exceptions to the rule that there are only two genders. They are not a third gender, they are a combination of the two possible genders.

I just want to state that facts and science are separate from opinions and views. I have sympathy for people who are not happy with the gender they were born and struggle to deal with it. But I have no sympathy for those who think that denying facts, for the sake of not upsetting these people, and enforcing some kind of fascist speech control on everyone else is a form of compassion. It's not.

jasco · Answer

Medically speaking your right, mentally speaking your right, physically speaking yea your right but well some people argue against that yea. Personally i want kids by birth and if she wants by adoption. However a trans women can't give me that first one which is why i refuse to date one, will i condemn anyone who fines them attractive and datable? No by all means do you, do i think it's a problem if men/women are turning into the opposite sex? To a extent i feel like if this keeps going with the low birth rate, it could lead to some problems in the future but in present time, uh no not at all

chHaynes · Answer

I don't really care what you believe but my intake is you're not a real woman when you have a penis and a ballsack this is more fact did not the only people who like these kind of females is usually gay guys or gay girls no straight guy will ever go out with tranny he don't want to get poked in the eye when he's having sex with her with her penis

Dchrls78104 · Answer

Of course they're not real women; more like weirdos and perverts with too much time on their hands and not enough sense to find something worthwhile to do with it.

slatyb · Answer

That’s just a word game. The only interesting question is what should be policy regarding trans-sexuals? There are very few situations where it matters. Single-sex restrooms but it’s not proven to be a problem to let people use the restroom of their choice. It seems the only remaining controversy is deciding how is eligible to compete in women’s sports.

Anonymous · Answer

That only depends on gender, not assigned sex. If you mean trans girls aren’t cis girls, THAT’s what is technically true. However that doesn’t mean you get to complain about something that isn’t even causing you any real problems.
“Real” only has to depend on gender, and if you mean chromosomes and that kind of thing, it’s more correct to distinguish people by “trans” or “cis”, so you literally can’t make any argument why that bad treatment of trans people is ethically right.

TruthBringer · Answer

Does that look like a woman? No. Does "she" have the genes of a woman? Was "she" born female? No. So is it a woman? NO.

jakerson181 · Answer

How many times have you jerked off to that picture? Be honest.

Everglow5 · Answer

It goes for men too. Trans men aren't real men either. You were either born with breasts and a *place* or born with a *thing* nothing can change what sex you are.

oddwaffle · Answer

Like this one? It's a trap.

TheFlak38 · Answer

In a healthy society trans people would be changing their genders (yes plural) every five seconds from inside a prison facility.

GirlsTonguesHOT · Answer

Username checks out. Fun Fact: The death toll in Southern states is at an ALL-TIME high. Gotta love Karma.

BCA6010 · Answer

No, because for all intents and purposes, your statement is correct.

Anonymous · Answer

Are you saying that you wouldn't like to have sex with one of these beautiful ladies?

John_Doesnt · Answer

That's no woman, that's a man, man.

Trooper205 · Answer

We are born with unchangeable genetics, chromosomes and DNA. Once we're born, that's that.

Bananaman177 · Answer

Neither are a lot of *actual* women. . .

Alexandrubaschet08 · Answer

No, you are 100% right. Biology don't give me 1 chance, sorry.

Anonymous · Answer

What is real? If real is what you can feel, smell, taste and see, then 'real' is simply electrical signals interpreted by your brain.

Archerer · Answer

Can’t prove you wrong but what’s it to you? Let them be. It’s more a matter of consciousness than biology, you understand that right?

Gedaria · Answer

To put it crudely. They don't bleed. They don't have s monthly cycle..

FriendlyEnigma · Answer

Hm all i see is a women in that picture. Also, why tf do you care? ☺️ why not get a life

BeMuse · Answer

Is that your facebook profile pic?

Bee-Hatch · Answer

Can you prove you right?

John_Galt · Answer

BuT uMm... ScIeNcE aNd StUfF!!!

abc3643 · Answer

Trans women are not real women. Period.

offendedsorbet · Answer

What is a real woman?

Stoner710 · Answer

Nope I completely agree with you

joeldalton · Answer

I can not prove you wrong.

jshm2 · Answer

Why do you need to be?

pigoat · Answer

The legs are too slinny for the rest of the body

jacksmith01 · Answer

I can't prove you wrong because you are right.

NorthwestRider · Answer

They are women and why you care soo much lol

Aiko_E_Lara · Answer

I instead would like to prove you right.

KrakenAttackin · Answer

If you have a penis you ain't a woman, full stop.

Anonymous · Answer

And it's your concern how?

TadCurious · Answer

No, of course not.

blondfrog · Answer

Nope your right.

Kingofkings1992 · Answer

You are correct👌

CubaPirate · Answer

Definitely not

Anonymous · Answer

No, you are correct.

Trans - women are not real women. Can you prove me wrong?

Most Helpful Opinions

What Girls & Guys Said

Are trans women real women?

Trans - women are not real women. Can you prove me wrong?

Most Helpful Opinions

What Girls & Guys Said

Are trans women real women?

We're glad to see you liked this post.