How can a non-operative (non-op) trans woman with a functioning penis navigate everyday life, socially and practically, while living authentically as a woman?
What are the emotional and psychological implications for non-op trans women who use their penis during sex, and how does it impact their sense of femininity?
Does having a penis create a sense of disconnect or conflict with their feminine self-image during intimate experiences for non-op trans women?
YES, trans women are women. Trans women are individuals who were assigned male at birth but identify and live as women. Their womanhood is authentic and valid.
NO. They're Different Gender!
They're Victims Of Gender Dysphoria
Select gender and age to cast your vote:
Please select your age
Are trans women really women?
Post Opinion
Like
Share
Follow
1 likes
What is your opinion?
Add Opinion
Most Helpful Opinions
Anonymous
(25-29)
1 y
The only thing that makes navigating life difficult for me as a trans woman is the bigots and confused people. I still had to deal with that lot back when I was just a more feminine "man" though, so I don't think this is a problem for me just because I'm trans. I think life is more difficult for anyone especially women who looks or behaves out of what some people consider "normal" and those some people decide to make it a problem for her.
The biggest thing is I have to be careful about using public restrooms as a trans woman, but even that I still had to be careful about before because I had a baby daughter and men's rooms didn't have changing stations.
Things that make life harder for trans people make life harder for EVERYONE. Even "normal" people. Whether we're men or women we're all people and some basic respect goes a long way.
I'm going to be honest and non-biased when I reply to this.
Gender and sex are two different things. Gender is a social construct, and sex is the chromosomes, marrow, and other genetics we are assigned at birth. Girl and boy are labels, or social constructs. Male and female are sexes.
A trans-woman is someone who experiences gender dysphoria and wishes to change their gender presentation to match who they feel that they are on the inside. Whether it be operational or not. As to how they tackle living in a body they do not like? Cosmetics, growing out hair/wigs, wearing clothing they feel comfortable in. For those who are aspiring to be operated on, it likely triggers dysphoria. Those who choose to be non-op usually work around it.
"Trans-women" are 100% male. They have male chromosomes, hormones, bone structure and reproductive systems. They have never experienced what it is like to have a female body. All they can do is fantasize about it and mimic female behavior. They are essentially just super gay because they are men who want sex with men.
Drugs and surgery are as cosmetic as makeup and clothes.
Lots of trans-women are fully aware of and acknowledge the fact that they are not women. They just want to attract men and be treated like women. The ones who actually believe they are a woman in a man's body are as mentally ill as a man who genuinely believes he is Napoleon or Jesus.
I mean 1. Gender Dysphoria is indeed a condition that leads biologically born women & men to dress like their inner self on the outside. 2. Transgender is obviously a different gender to be labeled as such. 3. They’re women from self identification though as a group will stand loud & proud to be Trans (in other words, not faking being a biological gender they weren’t born as)
XY chromosomes in every cell of his body (except the sperm, which are haploid.) Grew up swinging man meat between his legs. Does that sound like a real woman?
Yes they are, and I describe them as women. They identify as women and they live as women. The way they feel and who they are is valid and will always be valid to me and I will always respect it.
First off if you have a dick you are a male and not female. I don’t care what you want to call yourself. Second chromosomes don’t lie. Even after the operation it is still male. You can put lipstick on a pig and manipulate it all you want but it is still a pig.
If you mean, people that started out male and had surgery to become female, yes, except that they don't have a fully functioning vagina. They have tits and no longer have a dick. To stay male but present as fem is more along the lines of cross-dressing: transvestitism, not transsexualism.
No they are pretend women , they were born a male not a female , whether he has his dick chopped off and transformed into a vagina or he has boobs implanted on him , he is still a man pretending to be a woman
Of course they are not women. Every cell in their body contains the same sex chromosomes they were born with. No matter how they mutilate the parts of their body or what hormones they take they remain the same sex as they were when they were born.
1
0 Reply
Anonymous
(36-45)
1 y
Of course not and even the people who mindlessly chant "trans women are women!" know that. It's why there even is a term "trans woman." If they really were women, they'd just say "women are women!" But then we'd all just nod in agreement at their tautology and go on with our day knowing that if an adult has XX chromosomes she's a woman and XY he's a man. And no amount of surgery or wishing on a star will change that.
I know of a guy that accidentally lost part of 2 of his fingers and a local Dr. gave him some powder that he invented that caused the guy's fingers to grow back. Does that mean that he's PRETENDING to have all of his fingers? If someone's born with a limb missing or accidentally loses one and Dr.'s have a way to replace them, even if it's a kind of fake, does that mean those people are PRETENDING to be whole humans? Do you also make fun of those people, too?
just look at their bone structure. A female's bone structure is different from a males. So, while on the outside they may act & dress like a female, on the inside they are a male.
Nope, I like to compare them to children throwing a tantrum, society is sick and tired of listening to the hissy fits so we just entertain these defective copies delusions now.
If you have a penis, YOU ARE NOT A WOMAN AND NEVER WILL BE!
2
0 Reply
Anonymous
(45 Plus)
1 y
A transvestite is simply a male or female who likes to dress up in the clothing of the opposite sex/gender. Their mental illness, or fetish, does NOT change their TRUE sex/gender
Trans women are technically women, their chromosomal make-up doesn't align with their genuine gender identity.. causing gender dysphoria. This mismatch drives their transition to align body and identity.
Crossdressers (transvestites) on the other hand are some crazy men who are mentally disturbed by extreme fetish and obsession to woman's fashion, these individuals may dress like woman but they're not woman by gender.. they need the help of a psychiatrist.
Girl's Behavior 
Guy's Behavior 
Flirting 
Dating 
Relationships 
Fashion & Beauty 
Health & Fitness 
Marriage & Weddings 
Shopping & Gifts 
Technology & Internet 
Break Up & Divorce 
Education & Career 
Entertainment & Arts 
Family & Friends 
Food & Beverage 
Hobbies & Leisure 
Other 
Religion & Spirituality 
Society & Politics 
Sports 
Travel 
Trending & News 
Most Helpful Opinions