trans 👏 girls 👏 are 👏 real 👏 girls
no
Select gender and age to cast your vote:
Please select your age
Are trans girls real girls?
No, transgender women are not real women. Being male or female is not based on what a person feels or identifies as, but rather strict biological criteria. Being male or female is determined by a person's role of reproduction, which is, in turn, determined by a person's sex chromosomes. If a person has 46, XX chromosomes with the biological role of producing egg cells and carrying a fetus, that person is female. If a person has 46, XY chromosomes with the biological role of producing sperm cells and fertilizing egg cells, that person is male. The genitals, the penis and vagina, which are also determined by sex chromosomes in the womb, ensure that these reproduction roles are carried out, meaning that genitals are basic indicators of a person's sex. Simply identifying as the opposite sex and/or undergoing hormone treatment and surgery to resemble the opposite sex doesn't alter the sex chromosomes or biological roles. At best, such treatment can stop the biological roles from functioning correctly, but not actually completely change them. Thus, regardless of how convincing they might look, transgender women are still men and transgender men are still women. Believe me when I say that this answer isn't coming from a place of hate, but rather a place of science. You can't argue with science.
Most Helpful Opinions
-
Uh yes. Some people are really transphobic yeesh. Like they aren’t bothering you, they aren’t trying to control your lives like your trying to controlling theirs. (Not saying to the asker specifically but in general)
They are objectively, literally, 100% undebatebly. NOT real females, women, or girls. I know lots of people out there are mentally ill, entitled, and MASSIVELY immature, but you cannot change what you are just because your feelings wish it were true and you're extremely insecure with yourself. Otherwise, I'd be 6'8" with a huge dick and muscles like Dwayne Johnson.
To demand and shame people into believing in what you believe in is the same kind of crap we wouldn't tolerate of anyone else. You wouldn't tolerate Christians trying to "cancel" atheists for not believing in God, or side X of American politics not voting for side Y. People don't even tolerate others living as the race they want to, like super-white, tanned and permed-haired Rachel Dolezal claiming to be "black on the inside." So why would or should anyone else tolerate a tiny percentage of the population demanding everyone else bow down and kiss their asses and give them everything they wish for, like bratty children? What are you going to do, claim we're "transphobic" because you're acting like an a**hole?
I go into this more in MyTakebecause it's too big to fit as an answer on here.
www.girlsaskguys.com/social-relationships/a63554-transwomen-this-is-how-society-will-accept-you-but-some-of-you-might
"Trans-racial" isn't a real thing, Rachel. But transiwomen are?
-
Its complicated. I know some trans people and for real, I couldn't even tell they were trans. Some are able to "look the part" better. I also think if somebody has the cash to do so, then yah, I guess why not? But I think the average joe doesn't realistically have the cash or time for gender change surgery. So doing so anyways well, I think it's going a bit far. And anyways, I don't know how many surgeons do that stuff, but I prefer the medical personnel available focus on real emergencies and not optional stuff. Better for society to just be more chill about feminine and masculine stereotypes, then to have so many surgeries, because anyways, all they really chance is the look and maybe sex parts. They don't prep the mind for the challenges of being the opposite sex. And yah, biology has an affect, but it also depends on the person in the end.
I will add too, that all the trans people I knew happened to be at least middle/upper middle class. I don't think that's a coincidence either.
What Girls & Guys Said
44
Opinion
104Opinion
- 1.2K opinions shared on Girl's Behavior topic.
So if they also had a condition where they cpuldn't lactate too, thwt only leaves them with a pussy
-
I am friends with a couple of trans women - and have been more than friends with two of them. It's interesting skimming through the comments - and not surprising to see the mean ones. I've always scratched my head with why someone cares when it comes to gender, sexual orientation, race, religion etc... variety is what makes the world a beautiful place. Why hatred for those who are different... ignorance I guess.
To your question, not sure how you are defining "real girls". The trans girls I know would readily say they were assigned male at birth and they still have male genitalia so they are not real girls in that sense... and they would say that.
But they look, act, feel, behave, etc like a real woman - and I will say whenever I've been with them (whether the setting is sexual or not), I've always felt like I was with a woman.
Funny and sad how people quickly judge with no experience on a topic... wish people would stop hating on people over gender, sexual orientation, race, religion etc... the world would instantly become better and healthier and more fun... -
I've wondered the same thing and finally got the answer about a year ago. I can't help that what I'm about to say may be offensive, at the same time we are all free to speak our thoughts.
According to fairplayforwomen. com "More and more males are now choosing to ‘live in role as women’. But they can’t actually BE FEMALE. It’s a medical impossibility." Also, a man's head is 10% larger than that of a woman's. Even facial structure differs between the genders,
Now, shemales on the other hand are another story. They genuinely look like a woman with the exception of their private area. I once ran into one online and asked if she was born with male parts or had an operation and said born with. I like shemales because they virtually are women with the sole difference that they have a dick. Check out the link below to see a more in depth look at the differences in genders, I think you'll find it very interesting. Hope this helps
https://fairplayforwomen.com/biological-sex-differences/#:~:text=Differences%20Between%20Male%20and%20Female%20Heads&text=WOMEN%27S%20SKULLS%20ARE%20THICKER%20by,backwards%3B%20women%27s%20are%20more%20vertical. -
I vote NO and I hate trans. I'd been mistaken for trans many times, being very tall as a woman, many horrible people call me a trans on several occasions. Not far ago me and my two olso very tall girlfriend's were at a bar, and son guys came up to our table and asked for a dance when I stood up the guy got intimidated and instead of swallow his male pride ( men think they have to be taller and stronger than us) he began to shout , I were a horrible trans, I felt horrible but asked him if he were a little girl with a dick as he were so short
-
No. And im not transphobic by the way I just don't think a million surgeries, makeup, hair, clothes etc makes someone a woman. I totally will support what they wanna identify as but i believe you have to have the female parts us women were assigned at birth inside and out.
-
They're not, but if you want to be friends with people it's not something you want to say out loud.
Being offended, loud, aggressive, explosively wordy, or outnumbering the opposing opinion is the new "right" for people who aren't me.
I only deal in reality. It's probably why I'm bad at making friends. I'm not willing to cater to anyone. Eventually they always ask me my opinion on something they're looking for a bad answer for; it's likely due to insecurity.
Honestly you can call yourself whatever you want. Just don't expect me to join you. -
Some are real hot. Did you ever see Daisy Taylor? She looks like 100% girl until you see her huge peen. And she is always hard. lol. Her videos are fun to watch. She is riding dudes with her rock hard peen waving all over the place. :)
Daisy -
Trigger Warning: No I personally don't. I respect their choice to identify how they want and acknowledge they have their own experiences and struggles in life, but to say these trans girls who grew up as guys have gone through the common experiences and struggles as girls is not just not correct.
-
They can't even feel the way us girls can.
They don't even think the way us girls do.
One might change his gender but they don't get their all nerves connected exactly like us girls do so they don't feel exactly the same.
And you can't change once mentality... they might become a trans woman but their thinking will most probably be the same as any other men.
Just because someone identify their gender as a female after making their body like a female and behaving like a female doesn't mean they are a female.
Same goes for any other trans male.
Period. -
They exist but aren't women. No amount of pharmaceutical drugs, hormones, clothes, make up and surgery will ever change that.
- 684 opinions shared on Girl's Behavior topic.
The ones who demand to be called/recognized as females definitely are not.
For eons societies didn’t care if someone made themselves blend in 100% as a different gender. Even today if there’s someone out there who has 100% of everyone who sees them convinced they’re female it’s not an issue. It becomes an issue when they demand special rights, or tell us to ignore our eyes/ears and pretend they’re somewhere we don’t believe they are.
They want all the benefits of being something with zero accountability. I’ve seen videos of trans women attacking men & if the man defenda himself he’s charged with a hate crime & assaulting a woman. That’s total BS.
The trend of parents raising their kids as a different gender is child abuse because we know less than 1% of people are “trans” so there’s a 99% chance you’re making the wrong guess by changinv your kid’s gender. -
An interesting thing about minority groups is that they don't need a majority vote for validation.
Say 1% of the population has some sort of fetish, like popping balloons helps them orgasm. The fact that 96% of the population doesn't understand how that is sexually stimulating doesn't mean voting "popping balloons is not a valid way to achieve sexual release" means that popping balloons is not a valid way to achieve sexual release.
It just means the majority have no understanding of the minority. -
Depends on what parameters we use to consider what a real woman is. If we consider biology, they aren't. If we consider level of femininity showed through their social behavior, some trans could be more femenine than me, cis heterosexual girl. I have in mind Blair White, which I see as more stereotypically femenine than I am.
I sometimes wonder if there are structures in the brain that could cause this opposite gender identification. But there's yet too much research about the brain to make, and there's not enaugh research to prove this concept might be true or false. - 559 opinions shared on Girl's Behavior topic.
Self-evidently they are not real females.
They have XY chromosomes, which means that they are a biological male.
They may or may not have been surgically altered to have an poor imitation of a vagina.
At best, a transexual is a male who has been mutilated surgically and pumped full of oestrogen.
There are no ovaries, no uterus and no womb.
The male skeletal structure, muscle structure and brain remain.
They are severely delusional and tortured souls who are self-evidently seriously mentally ill, which is also the opinion of psychiatrist Dr Paul R. McHugh, a former head psychiatrist at Johns Hopkins Hospital.
https://www.cnsnews.com/news/article/michael-w-chapman/johns-hopkins-psychiatrist-transgender-mental-disorder-sex-change -
I know this is a highly sensitive subject. in my opinion... no. It might suck but what you are born, that is what you are. The beauty of the world nowadays is, you no longer have to live that way all your life. If you want to live as a woman, you can. If you want to be a guy, more power to you. You can even go through the surgery and get all the parts so that you look like whatever you want to be. But, you were not born that way, so at your core, you will never be that. However, what does that matter? In every other respect you are whichever sex you want to be. The rest is just a technicality.
- 325 opinions shared on Girl's Behavior topic.
biologically? No. Genetics determines that not your feelings. Now that isn't to say you need to punish them for being trans or even that you cannot treat them as a woman, but they are not biologically female.
Its a complicated issue as neurologically speaking they do have brain structures that are that of a woman, but being female is genetic and reproductive in nature and in those two ways a trans female is going to be lacking.
Its not the answer most transgender people will want to hear but it is the honest one. - 344 opinions shared on Girl's Behavior topic.
What gender were you born? Female? Then you are a real girl.
Just because you buy a vagina and try to dress and look like a chick, you're still a dude and need serious mental help. -
I personally have no problem with the LGBTQ community. Let them do their own thaaangg.
The first time I met a trans girl was about 10 years ago. I was one of the dancers doing pow wow, and she interviewed me for her blog (or I think it was a research paper). Even though we had cultural differences, she was very respectful, very friendly and did not disagree with my opinions. That’s what a real feminine woman is supposed to be.
In today’s world, most real girls are oozing masculine energy instead of feminine energy. Just go to the club or bar and look at the hottest girl who frequently visits the place. She’s difficult, non submissive and no man has dared to put a ring on that, that’s why she’s there.
People’s self image opinion is not a threat to whether you’ll be sleeping good tonight. Leave em alone lol. -
If someone is mutilating their body in any way. Trans is not a necessary medical treatment. The real treatment needed is therapy. The problem is Gender Dysphoria and the trans community will deny this up and down. I see it no differently than if someone wanted to turn their body into that of a cat or a horse. When does it end?
Why can you just not be happy with the body you have?
If you are born a dude and like other dudes or feel more feminine coolio. You're a feminine dude and I ain't got no problems with that.
The big problem people have with Trans is the mutilation. Someone willing to do that to themselves is obviously not mentally stable. -
- biological - to where they can become pregnant and/or birth children - no - however medical science might one day. find a way for them to be able to
- after gender reassignment surgery, with hormone treatments and with or without any implants - yes besides reasons above.
- before gender reassignment surgery, however with hormone treatments and with or without any implants - more or less a chick with a dick or dude with tits.
- before gender reassignment surgery. before hormones treatments and before implants - their most likely still deciding and/or confused what they want to do.
Click "Show More" for your mentions
Most Helpful Opinion(mho) Rate.
Learn more
Learn more
We're glad to see you liked this post.
You can also add your opinion below!
Most Helpful Opinions