
Don't immigrants work harder than native populations?


You're assuming that the same type of people would come here if we had fully open borders. Bad assumption.
A lot of scam artists and thieves come here too. Around here there has been a gang of South Americans who come up on tourist visas, commit burglaries for a few weeks, then go home to be replaced by others.
Also, the cost of housing, both rent and purchases, has skyrocketed the last few years in most of the country. Adding more people makes that problem MUCH worse, something that doesn't seem to occur to the idiots running California.
False association. Gun laws wouldn't work because criminals would disregard them and leave those who obey the laws at a disadvantage. Stricter immigration laws would allow the removal of those who ignore the laws, as opposed to now where anyone who isn't a known felon can show up at the border and be released into the country pending "hearings" that likely never occur.
That is because native born PEOPLE are more numerous.
It is laughable that you call me a "right-winger". The Trump lovers here call me a libtard. The reality is I am a logical person who doesn't go for the BS propaganda from either side. In other words the kind of person who bothers both sides because we call them out on their BS.
I love this shit. Popcorn time. Two lefties having at it. One accusing the other of being too radical. Always good times.
In average this seems to be true.
The term ''immigrant'' should not only be seen from a stereotypical ''American'' view.
Each country has its own typical immigrant group.
What they have in common is that local (original) population some kind of looks down on them, grabs the 'better' jobs for themselves, and leave the ''shitty'' (or unwanted, or hard) work to the ''immigrants''.
Of course, there are also ''career immigrants'' who import the energy that most locals are too sluggish to come up with.
If you immigrate, then you're aware that it's YOU to take care for yourself; there's no ''home government'' to wipe your arse each time you fuck up. So you try harder :)
No. For one it's not right to hire illegal immigrants who are using fake social security numbers to work. Or worse using a legal citizens ssn leaving them to deal with identity theft. 2nd it's also not right to use them because they will work for lesser pay.
The jobs we have should only be given to legal citizens including the immigrants that came here legally.
I'm sure they might. It depends on a person's work ethic. But I wouldn't say they would work harder than me because I give 100% when I work.
When people are standing around talking during slow times I always make sure I'm doing something for the time I'm being paid for. But in general I do notice most of my co-workers including managers slack off.
With that said it doesn't mean illegal immigrants don't get too comfortable and slack off eventually too. I have known a family of illegal immigrants which is why I'm aware of them stealing ssn to work and get drivers licenses. The father had good work ethic but his son was a slacker just like American kids can be.
They often take the jobs that nobody else wants to do. Fruit picking for example
I would love to pick fruit. Sign my ass up.
@Agagagagaga Yeah, where are these fruit picking jobs? I never see any of this on Indeed.
There are tons of Americans released from prison who need jobs.
A couple of million Central Americans working illegally undercutting wages.
@Agagagagaga We need to abolish minimum wage, bring back manufacturing jobs and bring back indentured servitude for non citizens to reach our full productive capacity as a civilization. Libs want people to be lazy bums.
@Stupidsigninpage seriously. Those jobs are available. It would require you to go to the farmlands moron, not keep searching indeed.
Well, sounds like there's more of an issue of properly advertising jobs than our need to open the border during a climate refugee crisis.
@Stupidsigninpage and please keep talking about indentured servitude and slavery. You’re a walking billboard for liberalism.
You can still promote some aspects of liberalism without going overboard with it.
I bet you're not a a liberal who supports abolishing prisons. I hope you're not that dumb.
A lot of liberals have been advocating prison abolition movement and now blue states are witnessing increased crime.
Open borders too and then they wonder why there's homelessness in blue states.
High inflation? That can't be from shutting down businesses during the pandemic, giving everyone free money and banning fracking.
So we have a climate crisis, are you okay with allowing billions of climate refugees to enter the US?
How will they get housing? You okay with more deforestation?
You libs are hilariously uneducated.
@Stupidsigninpage yes. Because statistically they’ll work harder than native born poverty welfare bloodsuckers.
Then get rid of welfare. Derp
Opinion
17Opinion
Sense the beginning of America immigrants have busted their asses! In particular Hispanics go to extreme risks to come back to their land that was stolen from them to work the jobs no one else will do for much less than fair wages and working conditions and living in fear of deportation.
This is a stereotype and it is irrelevant.
Any nation should have a say and control how many immigrants are excepted in.
The numbers coming into the U. S. are at psychotic levels.
We should be taking in about 50,000 a year... but we are taking in millions.
Hard work? That is moot to the overall issue.
No.
If you bring in immigrants you devalue labor. We shouldn't be paying people such small amounts of money for such laborious and physically draining labor. The best thing we can do for the economy is hold the oligarchs accountable and start massively overhauling the labor system.
That is just the worst aspect in my opinion. I think a country will cease to be a country if there is open borders however. We have to maintain at least a good percentage of a native population that has been here for a few generations or our culture will vanish. Having a culture that values free speech for instance ensures it survives to the next generation.
I don’t see the point of differentiating native to immigrant, when the difference is time. Only decades ago “natives” were immigrants.
But I only said open borders as an economic policy. I do see security issues important too. But I’m just trying to point out how effective immigration is at boosting economies.
Maybe? But that’s dubious speculation at best. It’s an emotional argument, The issue with illegal immigrants is the free rider issue. They don’t pay the same taxes we do, yet they utilize our resources. Opening up borders would destroy our country. Why not just come in legally?
They always work hard in most places for that I can accept. And the more they work hard they end end up being hated by some natives in some countries, Saying that "these immigrants are steaing our jobs. But in actual sense them natives at a big numbers they hate working. So that is how the world we. Live in is fucked. @OddBeMe
Marriage has always been a pathway to citizenship for anyone.
But I’m open to taking that option away from all of the immigrants.
Do you realize we're going to have water shortages in this country within the next 10 years?
And yet you liberals want more immigrants coming in taking away water for natives.
Everyone will soon flee the west and move to the eastern half of the US which is already overpopulated as it is compared to the west.
And why do weed more non skilled workers when it's forecast by the WEF that 30 % of the country will be out of a job by 2030.
So why do we need more immigrants.
Keep them in their country and let them starve.
Global warming is about to trigger a massive climate refugee crisis in the next 10 years and the WEF predicts a billion, a BILLION displaced by 2030.
And sorry, I accidentally omitted 2 question marks.
@Stupidsigninpage shows your thoughts about immigration is racism rather than rational. They're the other who doesn't deserve our water.
Again, I'm not racist.
If it was Europeans flooding into our. country and we can't absorb them, I'm still opposed to that.
I'm starting to think you're an idiot and to be honest, I can't wait for civilization to collapse and people like you starved.
I am anti-overpopulation, not racist.
@Stupidsigninpage how you choose which ones to include and which not to, makes you bigoted.
First, I want to protect my own nation, my own friends, my neighbors.
Do you know why animals are territorial? Let's talk about that.
Why did animals evolve to become territorial?
You think the alpha gorillas are keeping outsiders away from their territory because they are dumb bigots, or does it have anything to do with resource scarcity?
Learn about Gibbons and Baboons and why they are vastly different in territoriality.
You are extremely naive.
I know gorillas are smarter than you.
B. S. and propaganda you been told. Natives would work hard if you actually pay them their fair amount for the work asked to do.
Immigrants usually poor ones regardless of country get exploited for hard cheap labor.
Immigrants are desperate and exploited. Why should a native subject themselves to pennies and work like a animal? Pay right and they will work.
Immigrants are more likely to use welfare than native born residents.
Look it up.
So how are they more hard working?
If you want to ensure they work harder, bring back indentured servitude like we had in the 1800s before liberals ruined everything.
You know there are dozens of other sites that debunk that one site.
And you do know who owns CATO right? It's a think tank for neoliberals.
This totally contradicts Koch funded CATO: www.google.com/amp/s/amp.usatoday.com/amp/71517072
Even Wikipedia affirms American illegals are more likely to use welfare.
I live in Alabama and illegals have been banned from living in public housing and rent has never been cheaper.
In California, Oregon, New York they provide public housing to illegals and look at their homelessness rate.
Incidentally, the state with the lowest homeless rate is Mississippi.
Do they work harder on average? Probably
Would it be best? Certainly for the mega corporations who want to exploit them for cheap labor. I don't know about for everyone else.
In a way, yes because they have to rely on themselves, and are always given the shittiest jobs

It varies.
Actually, no. Well, depends on the immigrant's culture.
I have seen that they do. Most of our American young generations are way to spoiled to do the hard work.
Some do. A lot of them just collect welfare.
i don't know? what is your experience?
Some do, some don't and some are here to freeload.
They have a lot more to prove than natives, though
Not at my shop!
Borders are already open to immigrate LEGALLY.
Really? I’ve know several people who immigrated legally from South and Central America. They are not rich people by any means. Yet somehow they managed to do legally what millions of people don’t.
How would you know?
I have several researched papers. Some from right wing orgs like Cato that usually don’t agree with.
www.cato.org/.../workingpaper-13_1.pdf
https://itep.org/immigration/
risep.fiu.edu/.../...rants_spring_2007_reduced.pdf
CATO is globalist/neoliberal. Fake libertarian organisation. There are multiple sites that debunk that one site. I gave them to you. So why are you still posting that crappy source?
Yes i think
You can also add your opinion below!