Apparently Christians pushed back against Ottoman rule and were punished for it. Some history below. They weren't nice, the Ottomans did not allow Christians to run for office and become mayors and governors, like in USA. They ended up..."harming" them.
Do you think they were intollerent and why were they intollerent?

Girl's Behavior
Guy's Behavior
Flirting
Dating
Relationships
Fashion & Beauty
Health & Fitness
Marriage & Weddings
Shopping & Gifts
Technology & Internet
Break Up & Divorce
Education & Career
Entertainment & Arts
Family & Friends
Food & Beverage
Hobbies & Leisure
Other
Religion & Spirituality
Society & Politics
Sports
Travel
Trending & News
What Girls & Guys Said
Opinion
6Opinion
comparing a pre modern empire to the modern day usa makes zero sense tbh back then nobody had democratic mayors anywhere in the world and if u look at christian Europe at the exact same time religious minorities were getting expelled or burned at the stake
under the ottoman millet system christians actually had way more religious and legal autonomy than minorities in Europe there were dozens of different ethnic groups living in the empire and when they eventually split off none of them had been assimilated nobody touched their language or religion
as for the genocide claims during ww1 they crushed separatist rebellions with the exact same harshness regardless of religion if they actually wanted to commit genocide they wouldve just wiped people out randomly when the empire was at its peak
when it comes to modern turkey i personally haven't run into any christians where i live though their numbers are said to be around 120k to 480k churches aren't closed or anything i actually visited one myself the other day so there's zero coercion i have tons of friends from muslim families who are openly atheist people believe whatever they want u can even worship cheddar cheese if u want
Also in the ottoman empire non muslims could rise to top governing positions pretty much everything except becoming the sultan
And Christians burned thousands of women across Europe. Christians went to both Americas and butchered countless. Christians went to Australia, Africa, Indian etc, it didn't end well for the locals. Want more recent look at what happened to single mothers and their babies in Ireland in the 60s.
We know muslims did bad stuff, we know Jews did bad stuff. Everyone did bad stuff. If you don't let go of it you just end up creating a cycle of hate like in the middle east
that... is not the question, -7 xper points! if you want your own point, post your own question.
to the last point, yes. but it keeps repeating. I don't see Christians doing such bad stuff in history, I see Catholics doing bad stuff. I guess there was those salem witch trials, but that was a rare event and they were crazy, and whats his name from Waco texas, not a christian.
But it's solidified in concrete in muslim texts. not so in christian, buddah, etc..
Catholics are the largest denomination within Christians. Why has this to be repeated over and over again with Americans?
The "over 700 victims of sexual abuse by nearly 400 Southern Baptist church leaders, pastors, and volunteers" doesn't count as "bad stuff", I suppose.
Motes, beams...
They absolutely were intolerant of Christians. Their slaves, called Janissaries , are children who came from Christian families who were stolen and had their parents and then forcefully converted them to Islam.
When you talk about the 15th century, it's usual to use the past tense.
@goaded They still aren't tolerable with Christianity.
Americans can beat their slaves and have any black person who strikes a white person killed without trial. (See what I mean about tense?)
A lot of them still aren't compatible with Christianity and ignore what Jesus preached. Some of it extremely clear, like, for example:
"And when you pray, do not be like the hypocrites, for they love to pray standing in the synagogues and on the street corners to be seen by others. Truly I tell you, they have received their reward in full.
But when you pray, go into your room, close the door and pray to your Father, who is unseen. Then your Father, who sees what is done in secret, will reward you.
And when you pray, do not keep on babbling like pagans, for they think they will be heard because of their many words."
Matthew 6:5-7
Ah, history! From centuries before Europe invaded America, by the look of the picture.
Today, the world's largest Muslim majority nation, Indonesia, has 77,000 churches. The USA has 3,000 mosques.
@goaded exception to the rule and you know it 🤦♂️
@KypHistory91 It's close to the population of the US, 290 million to 333 million. Where are you thinking of? Which of those places have not been invaded/bombed by the "Christian" West in the last 60 years?
You quite literally picked the one Muslim majority nation that is fairly open.
Don't even get in a history debate, you will lose badly. Nearly all of the current Muslim dominated territory was Christian prior to their conquests. By the 1st Crusade, nearly half of Christendom was conquered by Islamic powers.
Randomly choosing that one Muslim nation that is fairly open doesn't really support any weird argument you are trying to make.
To give you the pointlessness of your argument.
Muslims make up 1% if the US, and as you've kindly provided have around 3,000 mosques.
Christians in Egypt make BY FAR one of the largest Christian communities in a Muslim majority nation. They make up roughly 10% of the population and only have slightly more churches than Muslims have mosques in the US
You aren't really making any good points.
Christians in the middle east and north africa have suffered mass discrimination on levels with genocide with massive population collapses. (Barely a quarter of what it was decades ago)
This is due to various forms of discrimination and killing
www.theguardian.com/.../persecution-driving-christians-out-of-middle-east-report
This is sadly nothing new.
It's been centuries of this.
@KypHistory91 That would be the Middle East that was carved up by the US and Britain 70 years ago.
"Nearly all of the current Muslim dominated territory was Christian prior to their conquests. By the 1st Crusade, nearly half of Christendom was conquered by Islamic powers."
You mean, back when Christianity had conquered all the previous religions before Mohammed was born? You're still trying to tie ancient history to today and pretend there's no modern reason for the West to be hated in the Middle East.
bigedition.com/.../muslim-countries-with-christian-communities
I'd suggest you to study history.
Christianity became the faith of the Roman Empire, and therefore inherited all of its territory
Specifically Constantines conversion in 312CE and the edict of Milan the following year that legalized the faith. It became the state religion with the Edict of Thessalonica
Several hundred years later Muhammad launched his conquests which would take all all all Christian territory in the Middle East and North Africa, and large swaths of Europe.
Even under the Ottomans centuries later much of Southern Europe would be under their control.
Strange you are supporting the modern Christian Genocide 🤷♂️ I'm not surprised
Just a few more things.
Under the Ottomans (directly before the British and French conquered the territory) Christians were given Dhimmi status as long as they paid jizya. However, they suffer massive limitations. They couldn't repair or build churches, proselytize, and suffered legal restrictions that made they less under the law.
This meant they were allowed to practice, but not grow. They had to wear certain cloths, and were barred from owing weapons or riding horses.
The Ottomans also practiced Devsrime, which was the forced abduction of Christian boys, where they would be forces to convert and play roles in society such as the Janisarries.
Later on in the Empire, near its collapse, Christians suffered mass discrimination, deportation, and genocide. This was under the Young Turks (ironic for progressives 😂)
@KypHistory91 Of course every Roman instantly forgot about the old Gods and embraced Christianity in 312CE. Every power on Earth fought to expand their territory for millennia, most of them claiming they were chosen by their god. That's what the world order after WWII was intended to stop happening, and Putin, with Trump's approval, being the first major power to break the compact.
Then you lie about my position in a typical return to form. I wonder how long it will be before you go off the rails enough to bet banned again.
Nice job surrendering the topic, obfuscating, and whining.
Next time, better prepare. 🤷♂️
@KypHistory91 It's not whining to point out that you're lying that I'm "supporting the modern Christian Genocide". In fact it just proves what I expected, that you're pretending millennium old history is what's happening today.
Lol, you clearly are friend.
Just admit your leftist sympathies make it difficult for you to criticize anything that isn't European or Christian 🤷♂️
@KypHistory91 There is no "modern Christian Genocide", so you're lying both about that and my positions.
Thank you for providing a perfect example of the leftist dilemma 🤷♂️ 🤦♂️
not answering the question, -7 xper points.
So indonesia is being very tolerant, would like to go there.
Nigeria has a bunch as well, many being burned and people being killed or run out.
@KypHistory91 There's no dilemma involved in telling the truth to liars.
I know, anti white anti Christian, all else goes
@lightbulb27 in the second millennium, religions and countries were intertwined, every king was ordained by their god, and practically everyone was barbaric by today's standards. So, which century of the Ottoman Empire are you asking about? It was around for 600 years or so.
Since before 1914 there was a 20% non-Muslim population in Türkiye, it must have been quite tolerant for a while, at least. Since then, though, they fought a war of independence from the British, French, Greeks... Christian nations.
Maybe they associated being ruled from afar with Christianity. Same as centuries ago, when the Ottoman empire formed after the crusades. Centuries of resentment will lead to atrocities.
Iranians, Iraqis, Libyans, Syrians, etc. have been being bombed by Western countries for generations, it's not hard for a religious leader to turn that into being a religious war with Christians (and Jews) the bad guys. (Of course, like Catholics and Protestants, they've had plenty of internal religious wars as well.)
I'm unsure what you are even attempting to argue here? Are you validating the destruction of Christian society in that part of the world? Are you validating centuries of discrimination?
There are some serious fallacies here.
Just to name a few.
1. The Ottoman Empire formed after the collapse of the Sejuk Turks due to the Mongol invasions. Osman I, it's founder took advantage of that collapse and the Byzantines weakness due to civil wars and other internal strife. Bursa, which was part of the Byzantine Empire became one of their first major conquests.
2. I very clearly gave examples of Ottoman policies during its existence, and concisely described it's genocide of Christians (like the Armenians) during it's collapse
3. You seem to ignore an aspect of Ottoman collapse was the liberation of Christian territories, such as Bulgaria, Greece, Montengro,
@KypHistory91 This isn't your question, and it isn't your opinion. Answer the question I asked in my opinion to your other question and I'll read what you just said.
Que?
No, they allowed them to exist and practice their faith. Pre Christian Romans were intolerant because they threw Christians into caves with lions.
Just typical actions for Islam.
Most other societies have moved beyond it.
Not the Muslim world.
bingo.