We don't want a fierce discussion ok? Just drop some words of your opinion or simply scroll away :)
Thanks in advance
Thanks in advance
Girl's Behavior
Guy's Behavior
Flirting
Dating
Relationships
Fashion & Beauty
Health & Fitness
Marriage & Weddings
Shopping & Gifts
Technology & Internet
Break Up & Divorce
Education & Career
Entertainment & Arts
Family & Friends
Food & Beverage
Hobbies & Leisure
Other
Religion & Spirituality
Society & Politics
Sports
Travel
Trending & News
What Girls & Guys Said
Opinion
10Opinion
If we can’t draw the line at genocide and killing children, then what are we even doing? What the Israeli “settlers” are doing is proof positive as to who “the bad guys” are in this dynamic.
It’s a longstanding conflict, older than most of us. But it’s hard to argue for just displacing a bunch of people just living their lives, and then being forced out or killed because someone decided they have a historical right to the land, based on THEIR personal religion that no one else is obligated to observe.
Learning that Netanyahu had prior knowledge of the October 7th Hamas attacks, and he just let it go down because it would make Israel a sympathetic figure in a situation where they’re kind of the main asshole…. I was done with Israel at that point, the government anyway. The people look to have attempted to vote out Netanyahu, which I’ll take as a positive. But I don’t know enough about the guy who won to say if it was good or just a lateral move.
As a rule, I oppose any nation trying to expand its territory in already-settled areas. That’s well outside of my code of morals and ethics.
Completely valid. Just like the strikes and economic warfare against Iran are justified
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4Ik9eZ3k5ewHamas in Gaza is a terrorist organization with popular support.
It is supported by the IRGC, which also supports Hezbollah, the Houthis, and other.
Now, most of those organizations are significantly weakened, and Iran is facing economic collapse with a 10% GDP fall, the rial is nearly 3 million to $1, and it's incapable of exporting oil due to blockade while the Persian Gulf sees exports higher than pre war levels
Now we see more protests after 10s of thousands were murdered by the regime
gamaan.org/.../...n-2024-GAMAAN-Report-English.pdf
www.reuters.com/.../
https://www.iranintl.com/en/202611135975
Good riddance
BREAKING: Uprising Erupts In Iran - US Military Strikes IRGC - Endgame For Islamic Republic / Tousi TV
The question wasn't about Iran but seems you liked to speak that way. Ok
It's connected.
The IRGC support and fund them along with a lot of other proxies.
More specifically on Palestine.
1. Israel has historical claim
2. Israel has almost always responded defensively
3. Palestine has a long history of resorting to terrorism, such as in Jordan.
4. Most Muslims nations hate them, and even Egypt walls them off. However, they try to use them as a counterweight to Israel.
5. Most Muslim nations have given up trying to beat Israel
6. This particular war was started by Hamas
7. Hamas loves to use civilians to protect themselves.
Honestly, the only reason Palestine gets sympathy is due to Qatari funding of the west.
Qatar is actually the largest foreigner funder of US education
'Raises a lot of questions': Qatar has spent nearly $100B in the U. S. to gain influence: Report / MS NOW
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iyGW1KiB4eE
I don't get your words as jokes, i believe you really think like that.
I'm 100% sure
Which part do you disagree with?
Thanks for your calm yet respectful way of asking... But before answering, just like i mentioned in the description i mind answering only until its this calm and without getting it extra seriousluly. Is it ok for you?
Lol, sure.
My warning is, unlike most westerners I'm actually educated on this topic. 🤷♂️
Ok
I first go with Israel historical claims
Before speaking any words... You really believe that? That the matter is a religious prehistoric promis someone has had for them and it makes that land belong to them?
I don't really care either way.
However, if you asked a pro Palestine person in the wear, the assumption is that the Jewish people magically appeared in the land arund 1948, and that Palestine was a historical kingdom.
If I remember correctly, even the Quran dictates it's Jewish land and to be returned.
Both of that is antihistorical.
My position is that it was won, and therefore it's their land.
Won? You mean... What you mean by that?
In 1947 after the UN partition plan was confirmed, many Muslim launched a war against Jews. Eventually, this turned into an all out war between the new state of Israel and transJordan, Egypt, Iraq etc.
Israel won.
So you mean if Russia wins the war against Ukrain you'll stand with Russians.
Right?
(Not skiping to another note... Just wanted to mention you look winner-oriented) Russia was only an instant. I could make many more
I'm saying it gives justification to their territory.
The Islamic Republic exists due to the 1979 revolution. That's a fact. It's a real territory. Doesn't mean I'm required to accept everything about it.
Pro Palestinian figured on the west often argue against the legitimacy of Israel. They often incorporate "colonialist" mindsets.
I find the arguments pointless.
If Russia conquers Ukraine, then that is what happened. I may see it negatively, but I won't deny history to create a narrative, which is a common practice
Pro palestinians... You repeatedly talk about them that has nothing to do here with us so leave that please.
Ok lets finish this part:
You feel nothing about truth and believe only power speaks. The strong writes the history and you dont care how.
Right?
Not necessarily.
Being a historian myself I'm often annoyed by those that misconstrue or outright lie about history to make a political point.
Facts are truth.
Israel won the territory, so now its modern Israel. Even if many would love it erased.
With a grounding in history we can make better informed opinions on topics.
If someone argues "its always been Palestine ad Jesus was Palestinian" then they have a misunderstanding and their perspectives might not be informed.
It's the same anywhere 🤷♂️
Here, ill give it simply.
In order to make informed opinions, it's best to have a decent understanding of the subject.
If someone were to vote for President, it's better to have an understanding of core issues than to make judgements on things like "I only vote for my party' or "he looks handsome" or whatever.
Many people are poorly educated and therefore are easily manipulated and make uninformed decisions
With the Palestine Israel issue, it's best to have an understanding of the subject 🤷♂️
Agreed?
So you support terror, as long as it's state terror.
@Yeboncé trying to be edgy. Good job.
@KypHistory91
Pros call what you did "red Herring fallacy" but i don't want to argue.
You gave me what i wanted:
An israel supporter who claims that no morals worth paying attention when you're steong and should praise whatever the powerful does.
It was self defense. The Palestinians want to kill the Israelis and Oct 7th attack showed that again. They had to be hurt bad to stop future attacks so Israel did it. Hamas is -practicing scorched earth war and now so is Israel.
https://www.youtube.com/embed/mKmSHZ5bLH8Clinton added: “And I think part of it is that Hamas did not care about a homeland for the Palestinians. They wanted to kill Israelis and make Israel uninhabitable.”
I think it is sad when anybody dies in war and the victim is not an aggressor such as the children or families that are getting bombed. I do not blame Israel or any Jewish citizen, I blame the ones that are sending people to bomb these people. There are Jewish people who have died trying to deliver aid to Gaza. There are Israeli doctors that have saved Palestinian lives.
You blame israel and add you don't blame israel? How?
The ones who send people to bomb the innocent is the exact definition of israeli gov at this point
The Israeli government is made up of politicians. Not all Israeli individuals are members of the political party, and not all members of the political party want Gaza to be bombed. It is just like, when I cannot blame you for something your parents or siblings or friends did. You are your own person. You are not responsible for what other people in your family or social group do.
Genocide + gaslighting the entire world + having people in Western countries cancelled/fired/imprisoned/deported for speaking up about it.
Disgusting. Free Palestine.
Genocide. It has been an extreme over-reaction to an unforgivable attack designed to keep Netanyahu in power and thus out of prison.
That's if they didn't ignore intelligence warning about October 7, which wouldn't be unthinkable.
This has been and continues to be genocide, plain and simple.
isreal is committing genocide
It requires dolus specialis 🤷♂️
War crimes could be argued though
@KypHistory91
Specialists believe Israel gov has commited war crimes
https://www.icc-cpi.int/defendant/netanyahu
They painted themselves into an expensive corner with no end in sight.
Israel has gone way too far in their attacks on Gaza. I support the people of Israel to defend them selves but it has to be proportional.
@Spencer10 why proportional?
@KypHistory91 Well because Israel is supposed to be the good guys... so proportional response is important to maintain global support.
Was the US response in WW2 proportional?
@KypHistory91 Which one?
Either
Massive civilian casualties
Massive kill ratios
Destruction of industry
Etc
They should have done a better job. There's survivors.
@Agape93 lol and the population has been growing contrary to genocide claims
I WISH they'd do a genocide and get it over with. Ffs, they started it, they dont get to complain when israel drops bombs through their dick holes.
But you can't say that! Lol it's raaaciaasttt
I never understood the leftist obsession with terrorist groups. 🤷♂️
They'll always support the darker complexion of a demographic.
Notice how in the Russo-Ukraine war and that attempted genocide, they've said fuck all? White on white violence.
Or Venezuela and Guyana? Nothing, brown on brown.
But israel and palestine? Brown vs white passing, and they can't stfu glazing the brown people.
Shit ever since Oct 7, not a single Muslim has denounced it, and on the left the ONLY one who has, was Goaded, after basically pulling his teeth.
Agreed. I have fuck all hope for msc545, his dumbass doubles down on every stupid thing once confronted on anything. Dude got mad a while back because I talked about shooting deer. He said literally beating deer to death bare handed was more humane and equal.
Lol wtf? Somehow I'm not surprised. Msc545 blocked me early and whines about it.
Goaded seems to be very pro Islam though. He posted on a question about Ottoman crimes against Christians..
Made some weird argument about Christian churches on Indonesia vs mosques in the US.
He seemed to imply muslim nations were more open than Christian nations.
I replied, and let's just say I'd be surprised if he tries to continue down that road...
More open? They throw gay people off roofs, rape women and children as a matter of religious adherence and seek to murder non Muslims. There about as welcoming as a badger on crack
Exactly 🤷♂️
It's bizarre how people like him exist.
Shows how much our institutions worship people who are white or Christians
Yeap. He claims he's a mental health professional but doesn't know basics of well known issues. Like for example, I'm diagnosed with ASPD. I am incapable of guilt or remorse. But according to him, at some point in the future, all my widdle bad things will suddenly overwhelm me with guilt and regret 😭 lol
Do you think Ottoman muslims were intolerant of Christians and why? ↗
He surrendered that fast 🤷♂️ just decided to run off on another topic when cornered and complain.
I've talked with him enough. The only honest thing about him is profile making him look Iike asshole with too much time 😂
Lol they removed my comment about him in this thread for being offensive 🤷♂️
@KypHistory91 Genocide is not defined by population growth levels.
They did not in fact "start it", that is the kind of supreme ignorance common among supportersnof Israel. There was not peace before October 7th, Israel was not some innocent country randomly attacked. Israel is a murderous occupier and had already killed hundreds of Palestinians in 2023 alone.
But no surprise that people like you only follow the news when you get major stories spoon fed once in a while.
@Yeboncé of course not, however it's an argument of the left.
Genocide requires dolus specialis
@Yeboncé when did I claim it started on Oct 7th?
Be careful, or you will embarrass yourself like the last convo we had. You left that quick
@KypHistory91 That was a response to OP.
@Yeboncé lol right
@KypHistory91 Unfortunately, multiple leading figures in the Israeli government have made genocidal statements since October 7th, statements that have been backed up by their actions.
@Yeboncé it depends on if it's government policy.
Hamas in their 1988 charter defined its goal of destroying Israel and exterminating Jews. It launched an attack with that goal in mind
Is that genocide?
@KypHistory91 If you look at the Myanmar case, that was ruled a genocide based on inferring intent from the totality of the state's actions.
I am agnostic on whether October 7th was genocide. Maybe too small?
@Yeboncé the size doesn't matter.
The definition is based on the Serbian case in the 90s. It requires singular intent.
Israel doesn't fulfill that in multiple ways.
1. It's not it's a stated objective
2. It's offered mitigating standards (like relief) and warnings.
Claims of genocide are largely political 🤷♂️
@KypHistory91 It's clearly its objective unless you are autistic. It keeps making maps showing "Greater Israel", it keeps annexing land from Palestine and Lebanon, it keeps killing Palestinians, its ministers keep calling them animals and talking about how they should just leave Gaza altogether so Israel can build hotels there, etc.
Those "warnings" are not offered in most cases, also, the fucking IRA offered "warnings". Is that the standard here? The Nazis offered warnings, dude. As for the relief, it steals that and blocks its entry, it doesn't provide it, although it does try to take credit when others provide it, and it does fire tank rounds and large caliber machine guns at civilians collecting food aid.
@Yeboncé some Americans leaders said the invasion of Canada was for conquest, yet the objective was to hold a bargaining chip against Britain. What matters is state policy.
I've seen plenty of claims of Israeli statements and they've always been taken out of context.
You keep saying "it's clearly the objective"
Obviously not. It's never been a stated goal and Israel has provided support to Palestine (which voting on massive support of Hamas after Oct 7th).
Sorry, it doesn't fulfill the requirements of a genocide, hence the reason it hasn't been officially declared one.
The only side with a state goal of genocide is Hamas
@KypHistory91 The last election in Gaza was in 2006, and Hamas voters were motivated by dissatisfaction with corruption. In any case, if you look at the Palestinians killed, tens of thousands of them weren't even born back then. Plus all the ones that were under 18 at the time.
So it's nuts to hold them responsible for the actions of a government they have never voted for.
@Yeboncé im not even sure what you mean by the Nazis offering warnings?
I'm not sure why you are bringing up the IRA.
Hamas steals the relief or other opportunists🤷♂️
www.nytimes.com/.../hamas-un-aid-theft.html
Israel is an occupying force, it is required by law to offer basic services. What you're saying is like if you gave the Nazis credit for allowing some food into occupied France.
@Yeboncé you are attempting to use war crimes as a proof of genocide.
Please learn your terms
@KypHistory91 I got my definition of genocide from the US Holocaust Museum.
@Yeboncé that's not even relevant to our discussion, and seems to prove my point?
So unsure why you brought up elections
https://www.pcpsr.org/en/node/997
Most supported Hamas immediately after Oct 7th 🤷♂️
@Yeboncé obviously not 🤷♂️
You haven't done a good job
An useless battle but they had to fight to defend themselves, the opposite side did the same!
Palestinians deserve it
Deserve what exactly?
Everything they’re getting