Well I don't think guys would mind. My girlfriend used to wear it but I told her not to cover up her real beauty(aw sweet isn't it). So yeah feel free to wear whatever you want because with a good personality, who needs looks. Looks just draw guys in, but it's your personality that's going to make them stay for good.
Just make sure you don't over do the look. Too much can be too much for us.
Yea..Makeup specifically eye liner, personally if you do it a lot, that's just odd looking, and personally I like my girls to be totally organic, I love no make up, even if you need to cover up what ever on your face. I like natural girls but, some wouldn't agree, its only my opinion.