Is it normal to be undecided on who I want as my boyfriend?

I've been double dating for some time and both of them have recently asked for an official relationship.

They don't know each other but since neither are my boyfriend yet, it's not cheating. I care about and like both of them. Both sound great. It's sad I can only select one and I'll have to drop the other one. Is it normal to be undecided between two guys?

Updates
+1 y
Neither of them know I've been double dating.
Is it normal to be undecided on who I want as my boyfriend?
Post Opinion