

They're both good at the role, I just prefer the 2004 movie.


Asker wants to hear from Guys only. Login to share your opinion.
I personally enjoyed both but I absolutely love the Netflix version the most.
Jon berthnal gave so many emotions to that role, the raw intensity to the sad moments, the action, the other characters, etc. it was one of my favorite marvel Netflix shows ever.
I just couldn't watch like what the last half of the episodes, too much violence, I had to keep looking away
Yeah it definitely is gritty and violent which is what he’s supposed to be. He’s supposed to brutal but effective. I just like that raw emotion and displays of different emotions especially his internal struggles.
I sure did like the show... it's just
too much violence for me, makes me "feel" the pain, "physically", depending on what it is
Yeah I get it
Thanks for mho
your quite welcome
Same... I prefer the movie.
I definitely prefer the tv show since that’s how the punisher is supposed to be portrayed. A very dangerous man that can take down multiple baddies at once even when the odds are against him.
The 2004 movie was absolute crap. I did not like it at all, Thomas Jane’s punisher was nerfed so badly and it didn’t have that many fight scenes. Even Dolph Lundgren’s Punisher movie was better than Thomas Jane’s Punisher movie.
I thought Thomas Jane was good. I liked Dolph Lungren too,
Only seen the 2004 movie, after that, didn't want to watch a different guy playing in movie, the punisher, I was hesitant on watching the series one, but, I tried it, and bout the like 2nd half, I had to stop, too much violence for me, kept looking away
Jon Berenthal no contest. that dudes gaze is soo fucking intimidating!
I think they were both good
the series one, like the second half of the epiisodes was too much violence for me, kept looking away
too much violence for me, makes me "feel" the pain, "physically", depending on what
I haven't watched yet.
should i just watch?
The one Netflix? Hell yea
@adam_west I really think you should watch the 2004 one. first before the series, of you want to watch the series, i couldn't finish watching the series though, to much violence for me
Well, you're welcome!
Alright cool
well, now, you know, it's alright by me, have you tried the netflix one?
I am not really a series person, either. watch a movie, then it's done. Some time, I "started to" about a few years ago
Well, good. I never seen the other movies of the punisher. I just seen that one, and loved it. I didn't want to watch another movie of the punisher.
then I can't... I'll just keep looking away, I could be doing something I enjoy.
hmm oh, You were kidding...
I can only handle so much violence. If it's too much, I will "feel" pain
Not seen or heard of before
oh, okay
The movie. The original guy moves smoother.
Thomas jane & Dolph Lungren are the best
Henry Rollins
You can also add your opinion below!
Most Helpful Opinions