Whos sings it better - Lea or Melissa?

[AviatorTom]

This video is from the TV series Glee. It shows two women (Rachel Berry, played by Lea Michele and Marley Rose, played by Melissa Benoist) singing New York State of Mind.

Who do you think is the better singer?

Please vote in the poll.

Lea Michele (Rachel Berry)

Melissa Benoist (Marley Rose)

It's a TIE

Updates

5 mo

Interesting results in this completely unscientific study... a TIE!

However, Girls prefer Lea while guys prefer Melissa.

I don't (and can't) vote in my posts but I would vote for Lea. I find her voice more powerful, and she puts more of herself in her songs. Lea often tries to duplicate the original singer of the song, "People" by Barbra Streisand is the perfect example of this.

[Gwendoline]

Lea Michele is a better singer. Im suprised she didn't carve out a pop career or bigger acting career. I've not seen her in anything but glee and didn't watch past s3 or 4.

Also how big a creep was mister shue?

[Anonymous]

Lea Michele is a professional singer with a lot of bad habits. Melissa Benoist is a hack.

[NathanDavis]

I prefer Lea's voice... has a bit more of presence

[llorando]

Trick question, answer is option D: The Big O.

[AI Opinion]

Both Lea Michele and Melissa Benoist deliver impressive performances in "New York State of Mind" from Glee. Lea Michele, known for her powerful Broadway-esque voice, brings a strong and emotive delivery. Melissa Benoist, on the other hand, offers a softer, yet equally captivating vocal approach. Personally, I am drawn to Lea Michele's rendition due to her strong vocal presence and experience. However, it ultimately depends on personal preference, as both have unique styles. 🎶

[AviatorTom]

@Cinematic Lily Lily, I see exactly the opposite. Melissa's rendition is more powerful than Lea's.

[OlderAndWiser]

I vote for Billy Joel!

[Nikki1989]

Lea Michele.

[exitseven]

its a tie,