is this punishment appropriate?

I have a younger brother and brother is 15, my sister is 13. Well a few months ago my brother made fun of my sister, calling her ugly, fat and a bunch of other hurtful stuff about her body until she started crying. Well as punishment my parents made my brother take his shirt, pants and socks off each day after school for 3 days...he was only allowed to wear his boxer-briefs around the house for those 3 days so he (and me and my sister) could see that he too has faults of his own.

I have two questions: 1. Do you think this is appropriate as punishment, requiring him to stay in just his underwear? Why or why not?

2. If you think it was appropriate, do you think it would be appropriate if my brother and sister were others words would this be an appropriate punishment for a girl if the situation warranted it? Why or why not?
is this punishment appropriate?
16 Opinion