Girls, how do I solve two women crushing on me?

Anonymous
Dear Girls ask Guys,

There's a girl I know that is showing every sign of interest in me; teasing eachother, lovings eyes, catching her gazing at me from across the room, and sitting opposite me waiting for me to initiate conversation.

The problem is, now there's another lady who is outwardly pursuing me too... I don't really know how to react. The shy one was on my mind all week, but now the pursuing one may scare her off.
Shy guy in the middle...
Shy guy in the middle...
I want to give myself to the shy one, but I still want to be friends with the pursuing one... Being a lonely guy, I've accepted both their advances.

Pursuing lady has asked me to go on a day trip with her friends, whereas shy girl is probably signalling she wants me to ask her out.

What should I do? Should I try to act more exclusive with my mutual crush? PDA? I need some help.
Updates
+1 y
I designed a Valentine's card for the shy girl who certainly has a crush on me. When she realised it was in the bag, she half opened the envelope and said "oh no" (in the 'you shouldn't have' voice).

I don't know what this means. The card is a short poem of gratitude and acceptance of who she is. Additionally, this poem is essentially me admitting my feelings without saying anything.

I hope she likes it...
Girls, how do I solve two women crushing on me?
2 Opinion