- smiles a lot
- talks a lot
- lots Of friends and hobbies
- average in looks (5-6/10)
Pretty but shy
- doesn’t smile too much
- doesn't initiate small talk unless she’s interested in a topic
- not as many friends or hobbies
- attractive (8-9/10)
my guess is most men who are average looking themselves (5-7/10) would go for the first but half of the good looking men (8-9/10) would go for the first and half would go for the second
No; your guess is likely wrong. Looks have almost nothing to do with it. introverted men would go for the introverted woman, and extroverted men would go for the extroverted woman.
I'm introverted and quiet (but not shy) so, the "Pretty but shy" girl sounds near ideal for me. Outgoing girls require too much mental energy to deal with, for me.
And although you don't have to, I dislike it when these kinds of questions don't come with visual examples, to here ya go.