Are they too skinny?

[Anonymous]

So, I'm trying to loose weight and get skinnier. My all time goal and dream is to look a bit like many female K-pop stars do. Maybe like one of the girls in Girl's generation ^^

https://sv.tinypic.com/r/j7xjc3/8

Many people that i have talked to about this says that they are too skinny thought and that it is not beautiful, personally I think that they are beautiful with their very slim bodies, but what do you guys think? :)

Beautiful

Too skinny

[Anonymous]

well, first of all, this photo is pure photoshop. If you need a a target or an ideal, I think you should check for real pictures of real girls.
Second, just becoming skinny will not automatically make you look like them. Are those models? Perhaps you are lucky, and you have such long legs, but in most cases, you will lose weight in a lot of places and in some others don't. Plus your bone structure, I for example, lost a lot of weight, I am skinny, and I just don't have such a petite, slim frame as them.
That's the female bodies. I am not trying to put you down, I just don't want you to set impossible standards for yourself.
Otherwise, I won't stop you from chasing your dream, but if I were you, I would rather go after some real, fit girls.

[Snow-Wolf18]

They are very slim and pretty, but don't forget about the power of Photoshop, so they might not be quite like that in real life. Also, you can get thin if you want, but please don't over do it and become a walking and talking bone person. Please keep your health in mind before starting any diet or exercise plan and continue to keep it in mind.

[WeaponZero]

Considering the fact that Asians have more slender frames I would say it's not too skinny for an Asian. But for a woman of European or Latin descent she would probably have a naturally thicker build and there's no way she could reach that level of "thin-ness" without becoming unhealthily underweight.

That being said I don't find it attractive. I prefer athletically built girls.

[sirspauldo]

You don't need to be super skinny to be beautiful, but if you already plan on losing weight, just do it in a healthy way. I think they are pretty but if they were not so skinny they would still be pretty.

[BertMacklinFBI]

no they're not too skinny, imo.

[Izzy2102]

I don't know it's heavily photoshopped. The thing is that photoshop hides signs of thinness that are clearly visible and concerning on real people

images.huffingtonpost.com/2014-01-04-12-thumb.png

At the same time they often make the frame even smaller. But that's not realistic. You can't trust images like that. Or look of unedited pictures of those girls

[rUinSAYAN]

that's what I think sometimes when I see a skinny woman. normaly girls such skinny (bulemia) show their bones (but not with photoshop) and this is a big turn of. I more likely feel pity for them

[Ghosty]

A little bit to skinny. But it's more about them just being skinny. Nothing else. I find it by far more appealing if a girl has a fit body, not just "I hungered for months", but "I've hit the gym for months". Then it looks&feels better imho.

[jointhepatriarchy]

They're pretty girls, but yeah, too skinny. Look at their thighs. My arms are bigger around than that. I don't see how they can stand up without their femurs breaking.

[EpicHam]

Could use a bit more meat on the legs , but as an Asian myself... I know far too well how Asian girls have this "Musclephobia"

[Anonymous]

i think some of them look good and others are a bit too skinny. I think they would all look better with ten more pounds on them. I certainly would not go any skinner than that for sure

[goretcki]

If it won't cause you any health problems, go for it.

[TheNewClassic]

They are skinny and beautiful.

[syd48]

Natural is best and not too skinny.

[CourtJester]

They're attractive but too small for my liking.

[Ihav2fart]

Beautiful!

[queen-b]

Skinny,,,,,,,,