
Why is breastfeeding in public frowned upon?


I have seen everything from women who nonchalantly whip out both their naked breasts to feed their babies to conservative mothers using scarves and blankets to cover up or going into fitting rooms or other places out of sight to feed their babies. None of it bothers me at all! Breastfeeding is a strictly functional process of making sure an infant has proper nourishment and it has got absolutely NOTHING to do with sex, indecent exposure or anything disgusting so, if you think it's acceptable to starve an innocent little baby by hindering and harassing a it's mother who is trying feed it, I suggest that you all go home and start a blog and make your rants there because women are not going to stop feeding and caring for their babies because a perfect stranger can't accept that. Just saying!
It doesn’t make it any less distracting though. The fact that men are also attracted to boobs just makes it more awkward.
@BraveHeart97 I get what you're saying, but it's really messed up to tell a woman who is trying to just feed her kid that is she is disgusting or shameful and tell her to leave. If I had a baby and was only trying to feed the baby, I wouldn't care if a man was looking at my breast in fact a lot of mothers don't care about being watched. If you're going to get an eyeful of some titty, go for it! But harrassing someone or trying to stop her from feeding the baby just isn't right.
Bruh, these comments. 🤦🏾♀️
Breastfeeding is tf normal. y'all are out here fuckin in public places and freeing the WHOLE nipple but y'all are sensitive about a mom breastfeeding? While I personally wouldn't do it because I feel like that would be special time for me and my baby, I'm damn sure not gonna shame the next mom. And FYI, all babies don't like to be covered. Most of them pull the covers off or get fussy being covered. It's hot and uncomfortable. If it happens to be an emergency and I do have to publically breastfeed I wish someone would say something to me about covering my baby!!!
What? Who's fucking in public? Are you crazy?
@MoreThanFriends you'd be surprised
@markscott rightly said! ^^
LOL!
Agree. And I do have sex in public lol. And no one says anything if they notice what's happening. They just kinda smirk and blush. So why should these people have an issue w a kid eating a meal if they don't have an issue with walking by seeing a chick half naked getting pounded against a tree? Lmao stupid.
@markscott exactly.
@kaskas19 right. Not every place is even suited for covering your baby temperature wise so there's that.
I dont know...
Its kinda... You know she kinda flopped it out and i was you know... In front of her and on the bus ride i had to face the other way... Concious... Embarrassed... Scared...
I dont know i just dont wanna see that..
And if you ask OH MEN LIKE TO SEE
well its not the same some stranger than my girl
Boners are natural
And men are forced to hide em you know why
Just so you know. Most of us aren't hypocritical. I would be MUCH more against having sex in public than breastfeeding in public without a covering. But I am against them both.
And like you said. The guys who don't care about breastfeeding. Also don't care about sex in public. So they aren't hypocritical either.
Gees... Where are you getting these "facts" anyways?
@Prankster13 what are you even talking about?
Your "people are fine with sex in public but not breastfeeding" bullcrap. I'm not fine with sex or breastfeeding. And most people are all or nothing. No one is being ridiculous about it like that. You took half of the opinion of one side and stuck it with half the opinion of the other side. Of course you don't see how it makes sense. That argument IS stupid.
Breastfeeding in public is fine. But COVER UP. Sex in public isn't fine. I done see what's so stupid about that.
@Prankster13 first of all, I didn't claim anything as a fact. I used what is called an EXAMPLE. Heard of it? Whether you feel its stupid or valid is your opinion, I don't care. And breastfeeding in public is fine whether she's covered or not.
Then why is there such thing as indecent exposure? And why does it apply in every other situation besides this one? Huh?
@Prankster13 indecent exposure? I see women walk around and in pictures with the amount of boob that's showing in the second picture as cleavage! So what do you mean? You wouldn't look twice if it was just a regular woman walking around with a love cut shirt on. But because you know what she's doing, you're making a fuss about it. Never mind that I told you that babies don't like being covered tho right?
I'm talking about like no coverage. As in if the baby moves you have full frontal. Put like a bonnet hat on the kid or something so you're covered if he nods or some crap. I don't know. People have been able to keep themselves covered decently for ages. Why can't we do that anymore? Why can't the baby keep doing what they've been doing?
How many years does it have to breastfeed for anyways? One? One and a half?
@Prankster13 so you're worried about seeing the nipple if the baby unlatches? Lol, women can feel that. We can feel when they're feeding and when they stop. If for some odd reason you see a nipple, it's more than likely going to briefly. And then, the only way you'll see it is if you're watching her.
And different moms feed for different amounts of time. Generally a year is good
Okay. I don't think the baby will mind being fed with a balnket on it's head only while in public. Only for one year of it's life. Overall. I don't even remember that I doubt they will once they're older. So why does that matter so much to use a cover?
And ya they probably can feel it. But that doesn't mean they fix it or that they can in time. I just don't see why they choose to take that risk. And in public. When they could just use a damn cover and be fine. At least don't do it while you're eating or shopping and actively engaging with people through that.
@Lovi87 I don't hate it. I'm FOR breastfeeding. But just use a covering if you're buying something from someone who's job it is to address you. If you're just sitting on a bench? Fine. That's your own business. I guess.
But when you're in someone else's business? How hard can it be to just use a covering? Seriously? Just while you're buying stuff from people?
@Prankster13 the baby will mind. He/she will be uncomfortable and fussy. And while they are uncomfortable and fussy and wanting the blanket off their head they aren't focused on eating. The next time you sit down to eat, try doing it with a blanket over your head. We'll just have to agree to disagree.
I'll eat with a blanket over my head. When in public. For another year. If you take my side.
I mean I did it once when I was that age. I turned out fine. So sure I'd do it again. Like that. What's the big deal about that?
@Prankster13 lol stahp it. No you won't.
I will. I swear. My boss will hate it but hey he can't fire me over that...
Will you agree it's not that much hassle to use a cover if I use one when eating in public for a whole year to prove it? Starting tomorrow.
And if I forget the blanket I'll go hungry or eat in a bathroom stall. Deal?
What the he'll did I just read
Hell *
@Prankster13 lol you don't understand that it's not about the hassle. A woman feeding her baby shouldn't be something that offends you.
It doesn't offend me. It offends me when she can't be bothered to be held to the same dress code as everyone else. When it's so easy.
And are you calling off the deal or what? I gotta know whether to pack a blanket in my bag for work tomorrow.
@Prankster13 lmao would you stfu about this deal
If you would stfu about it being not easy to just cover up.
@Prankster13 I won't. Ever. So 🤷🏾♀️
Why? It is really easy. And it makes you covered.
I have no problem with people breastfeeding. What I can't support is people ignoring decent coverage because they have a baby. When it's so easy to still have decent coverage.
@Prankster13 : I'll agree that a baby should be covered while breastfeeding, when those who are against open breast feeding, start eating their meals under blankets. Honestly, are you afraid of seeing a breast with a baby suckling on it? What great harm comes from a baby being fed, and people seeing a woman's breast for something other than sexual attraction? I mean, do you think the sky will fall?
@markscott Me a few comments ago:
"I'll eat with a blanket over my head. When in public. For another year. If you take my side.
I mean I did it once when I was that age. I turned out fine. So sure I'd do it again. Like that. What's the big deal about that?"
I'll do that. For the same amount of time and such the baby will have to. I already offered that. And I've ALRRADY DONE IT while I was a baby! Chances are most people who are against breastfeeding without covering have also ALREADY DONE IT covered up while they were babies! I'm not asking any more than I'm willing to do. And I'm willing to do it twice to convince you.
So suck it and get over yourself because we've already done that when we were there age. And it's perfectly fair.
Or have me do it again as an adult and get over yourself because I'll damn well do it to shut you up. So which will it be?
@markscott please don't get him started again 🤦🏾♀️🤦🏾♀️
That is what you guys are so mad about right? That the baby won't like it? It's one damn year they'll get over it. I did. I'll do it again. To prove you wrong.
It. Does. Not. Take. Any. Effort. To COVER THE HELL UP.
@Prankster13 no, that's not what we're so mad at 🤦🏾♀️. At least that's not it for me. That's just part of it. The fact that you feel the need for her to cover up means that you're looking for a problem. You see a woman breastfeeding and it makes you uncomfortable? Why? Explain that to me.
Because she's not covered. And in any other circumstance. That isn't exceptable. I'm not any more comfortable with that than I am with girls going topless at beaches. A restaurant is not a topless area. I don't see why having a baby makes not covering up any more exceptable. It's a double standard and I don't have it. Sorry if treating nursing women like they have to cover decently just like everyone else makes you mad. It makes sense to me.
@Prankster13 she's not topless. She's not sitting there with her tits hanging out for the boys. She has one breast PARTIALLY exposed to feed her baby. The nipple is covered. Like I said, you're looking for a problem.
It doesn't matter WHY. It matters is the same stuff showing? Yes.
Only one of two? So? If I cover one eye I'm still gonna be able to see. And partially uncovered? Yes. The nipple isn't showing. As long as the baby doesn't move it's head and people are in front of her as opposed to beside.
And even then. Sorry but those protesting girls last year with tape covering their nipples and nothing else. Did make me uncomfortable. And people didn't like that even though they were "covered" I don't see how this is showing any less-- besides just one of two.
I'm not looking for a problem. I'm only seeing one because it's the same problem as with other situations: cover yourself up.
Just because I think that applies to *anyone* not covered. And I don't take babies as an excuse. Doesn't mean I'm looking for a problem. It means you're making excuses for this part of the problem. And I don't see why.
@Prankster13 : The purpose behind why the breast is showing, makes all the difference. a woman showing her breasts in a doctor's office, has a very different purpose, than someone showing them at a party. Breast feeding is not a sexual act. it's an act of love, connection, caring and nurturing. Yes, when I see a breast, be it for breast feeding or other reasons, it does look good to me. But my thought patter is very different, when I see a breast, when a mother is feeding her baby. I've seen women's nipples when the baby pulls back, while breast feeding. I don't get turned on by that, because the situations, and intent, is very different, from seeing a nipple to arouse me. If we have such trouble differentiating between sexual and nurturing exposure of breasts, then we need to self educate, and use some common sense.
@markscott I have common sense. Who the hell said I was turned on by that?
I know there are different reasons. But in public? Unless you're shirt's on fire it's not really excusable.
The doctor's office is in PRIVATE. Not PUBLIC. And yes I would have a problem being in the same room as the doctor while she had a mamogram or some crap. That is not by business. No. It's in private for a reason.
@markscott Agreed.
I can't believe this is even still an issue. When I was a kid in the 60s, it was common (the hippie chicks did it a lot). Even my prudish mother didn't make a big deal out of it as long as they weren't blatantly exposing themselves more than necessary. And now 50 years later it's still an issue? Come on now, that's absurd.
Society as a whole has moved soooo far to the left since then, but this trivial issue still persists. People seriously need to get over a few square centimeters of skin that looks exactly like the skin on the forehead or back of the hand. If they are seeing anything other than a content little baby bonding with it's mother, something is wrong.
I voted "no" because your options did not account for whether the breast feeding is done discreetly or whether mama flops her tit out for all the world to see. I have observed women breast feeding in public but with a drape that shields their breast from the view of others. There is absolutely nothing wrong with breastfeeding in public as long as it does not serve as an occasion for some unnecessary exhibitionism.
I've never actually seen a woman flop her entire breast out to feed her infant, so that it's in full view. Then again, maybe it's the warm Florida climate that makes some women do that.
@musicbrain5 I have not seen that either but I have seen YT videos of women doing that. Maybe it doesn't happen very often. If I witnessed such a thing, I would feel like I was an intruder.
Of course, there are also videos on YT of women breastfeeding their 4 year old son or their 9 year old son (seems that it is never a daughter!)
I have seen exactly that happen. A lot of the gung-ho activists are these crunchy closet exhibitionists who have some kind of problem with their breasts. Breastfeeding is natural but being discreet is an act of courtesy.
@OlderAndWiser I'm betting a good chunk of those videos were staged or edited to validate arguments against breastfeeding in public. I never take any of those videos seriously. Public breastfeeding actually seems to be pretty common where I am, and I always see them using covers or wearing special nursing clothing where very little is exposed.
@cherryphi82 Oh, I agree with discreetness for sure. What gets me is people who complain about women not being discreet enough for their tastes when breastfeeding, but then not saying anything about cleavage.
@musicbrain5 Yep, can't disagree with you there. That is certainly hypocritical!
I get slapped for gettin a NON horny boner and im not aroused
A natural thing yep...
Also im not flopping my dick out just so you know
@musicbrain5 @cherryphi82 - As pointed out very well by others on here, some babies do not accept their faces being covered. Plus it can get very hot under a cover. Our daughter would not accept a cover over her face and the feeding time became fussing and fighting time. Much easier if those of you who seem so offended by a natural act would just look away and mind your own business. Some cities and states have passed laws and ordinances that prevent people or businesses from interfering with breast feeding mothers.
@Red_Arrow There is a huge difference between having a right to do something and it being the right thing to do. It is not against the law to pick your nose in public; is it the right thing to do?
@Red_Arrow I breastfeed three kids. My kids fussed. Not only did I manage not having to feed in public very often, many public places such as malls and churches have a room for nursing mothers, and I was able to get my kids accustomed to the cover. It's not as "free" feeding with one, but it can be done. Most mothers I know are doing it just fine.
@Red_Arrow I'm not offended by breastfeeding at all, nor am I going to force women to use a cover. You don't even see much of the breast anyways, especially with the kind of nursing bras and clothing that are available now.
@bang678 No, I'm pretty sure that's not what he is saying. There are times when you don't have a cover and you just need to feed a baby. But there are bunch of mothers out there, I personally a few, who are very blazee about this and don't even make an attempt to cover, turn away or be in any way, shape or form, discreet. Exhibitionism is an action. It's not conditional to breastfeeding alone, but can be done in correlation to it because it does involve the use of an intimate part of the body.
@cherryphi82 Yes, that is exactly what I was suggesting. Thanks for clarifying that point.
@bang678 There is a difference between having the right to do something and it being the right thing to do. Social responsibility requires more than a simple stubborn insistence on exercising your legal rights. It is a response to a sense of a higher and greater obligation, one that is founded upon an understanding of the sensibilities of others and a respect for others. If your mother and father did not instill this in you when you were young, I probably cannot convince you now and I can only conclude that your parents fell short of the mark on this significant part of their undertaking.
@bang678 Adolescent response to my point.
"I have observed women breast feeding in public but with a drape that shields their breast from the view of others. There is absolutely nothing wrong with breastfeeding in public as long as it does not serve as an occasion for some unnecessary exhibitionism."
@cherryphi82
Or someone who respects a mothers choice to do what she needs to do. Meanwhile you shame other moms who want to be comfortable over something so simple.
Not to mention a mom with no sensitity to someone who may have fertility issues and may have lost a baby. You dont know shit but you sure seem to have a big mouth.
And backtracking much? "Meanwhile you shame other moms who want to be comfortable over something so simple."
@cherryphi82 Obviously, this is a lit up SJW on a mission and logic has no place in her argument. I've heard enough of her drivel.
@cherryphi82 TIme out! This is not going anywhere constructive.
Thanks for MHO!
Opinion
135Opinion
Why is eating spaghetti with your hands in a restaurant frowned upon? Because it is bad manners. Just because you can do it and it is "natural" does not mean it is appropriate in all times and places.
Frankly, the current view of public breastfeeding is a - historically speaking - relatively recent development. Moreover, there are at least some indications that it may be changing.
That all said, the notion that it is some offense against women and nature that public breastfeeding is not approved of is absurd. Urination is natural too, I'd just rather not see it on my front lawn.
there should be an aim to be as inconspicuous as possible but beyond some woman standing in line at mcdonald's with a child hanging from their boob there should be no consternation about breast feeding in public.
Get over it. It's a natural occurring phenomenon. If you don't like it then don't look.
I loved the comments from the few men in this comment section that clearly knew where breast were biologically created for in the first place, I also saw a lot of comments saying that breastfeeding in public should be covered up because it is common decency to others around them etc. some had even compared an exposed breast to basically any other body part example that did not serve any purpose to baby feeding needs...
Most of the people who made these type of comments had neglected the needs of a baby, yes sure you can find it disgusting to look at a breast feeding women and her child in public but no one ''No one'' forced you to look at it, the moms who are breastfeed in public are doing what they are suppose to do, they are putting the needs of their own child first breast feeding is necessary an other lifeforms, mothers cannot be selfish to their babies needs because breast milk is a necessity and we should respect that, if breastfeeding to a baby was irrelevant to a babies needs it would be a different story but it is not, therefor it comment to respect any mother just trying to do her job and care for the baby wherever it is needed.
I respect breast feeding moms in public and so should you
I am fine with them breastfeeding in public. But it's so "so" rediculously easy to just have a covering.
No. No one is forcing me to look. But it's right there. And I do have peripheral vision. So it's hard not to and still address them.
It will not hurt the baby or take away from it's needs to have a covering on for a little bit. What is so hard about a covering? Huh? I wear pants ALL FREAKING DAY LONG (in public at least, normally...) and you don't hear me complaining. It really is very easy to cover up.
If I went around naked no one is "forcing" people to look at my stuff. But yet it's still indecent exposure. I wonder why...
@Prankster13 difference between you wearing pants and a mother covering her baby is vastly different. She's not just sitting there thinking I know I'll let my boob hang out, she has to put a baby under that covering. Babies fuss or get hot and could easily even pull it off. Maybe some babies don't feed with the cover on if it bothers them. Breastfeeding can actually be really difficult for a mother and I think mothers who do all are amazing. The baby has to be contented for it feed properly, and a covering over its head may not make it happy.
@Sbgirl Fine. So don't so it out in the middle of everything if the baby can't handle it! No one's forcing her to stay in the open instead of going somewhere a tiny bit more private. Like a bathroom or something.
No one cares if she's comfortable any more than they care if I'm comfortable. The baby gets a pass cause it's a baby. You got me there. It doesn't know better.
So just go somewhere a little more private. Or just don't do it so freaking openly that it draws attention. Just do it in a closed off-ish area and be quiet about it. No one needs to know you can't cover it up. You don't have to do it in the most public place possible.
All woman saying it's disgusting, check inside your shirt and tell me how horrible the view is. The body is not disgusting (1). Those girls at the mall in the video, shame to them, because they must have so little self-love that they feel the need to project it onto others.
I see many woman saying it's ok but the mom should cover. Why? Don't tell me you never saw breast before. And if you really haven't, know you were a hungry baby once, and I hope your mom didn't hesitate to feed you. If you're not comfortable seeing a part of the human body, because you think it's disgusting or you think it's a sexual taboo of some sort, then you need to work on: your self esteem and or your self control. Your discomfort comes from your mind being corrupted by the ideas of your culture, the ideas of others.
It's the same for kids, if they understand the purpose of breastfeeding then they won't feel uncomfortable. If people around them don't make it taboo, then it won't be.
It's only disgusting in your head, it's only oversexualized in your head. Try to understand the bigger picture. The baby is hungry, the mom feeds him. Every other animal does the same. And yes, we are animals, we breastfeed, we're not metal, we're not robots. So work on your perspective, and your misconceptions, because there's nothing wrong with a mother fulfilling her duty.
I'd say no. While it's true that breastfeeding is natural and there's nothing to be embarrassed about it, it doesn't change the fact that breasts are still sexual and a very private part of the body, and the convenience of public breastfeeding is not worth the creepy stares of perverted men. I don't want states at my baby especially! Remember, they don't care about breastfeeding they just wanna enjoy looking at an exposed breast.
It is not very practical either. It can leave a woman at a very vulnerable state. Covering is not always a good idea especially if the weather is hot, and you may risk suffocating the baby.
The alternative to public breastfeeding would be pumping milk in a bottle, which is lengthy and tough. Despite trying so hard you can barely fill half of a small bottle. So that doesn't work either. Better not use formula if the baby is not not 6 months old yet.
I believe that we need more nursing rooms in places, so wherever mothers go with their babies they have a place to sit comfortably and breastfeed their babies. Oh and it has to be in a secure place to keep creepy dudes away from there.
You can't compare breastfeeding with pooping. If you're grown up then you can control yourself until you can get to the bathroom but babies don't understand that and they will cry for milk when they are hungry wherever you go. I'm not sure if I want to continue breastfeeding my babies when they learn to speak because then they will ask for milk in front of people and that would be so awkward especially if they are loud and obstinate.
@Kiels01 oh so you ignored the part where I wrote that more nursing rooms should be available? You're clearly not an attentive reader. Most women don't breastfeed in public and I never saw that a baby was left starving for that reason.
My sister had a baby when I was 12. And she lived in our house when my niece was an infant. She had classes and other places to go but she never had trouble with breastfeeding although she does not do it in public! I never saw my baby niece being left starving or something. Try proving me wrong, I have seen several cousins, nephews and nieces growing up throughout my life and I know that public breastfeeding is not needed, unless you have no shelter.
@Kiels01 first of all, better not go to the park too much unnecessarily. Secondly, usually in this case mothers breastfeed their babies at home before they go out and plan to come back after a certain amount of time. Usually mothers know how long their babies remain full once they are breastfed and mothers also know the babies sleeping pattern so they plan accordingly.
@Kiels01 I did not avoid your question I literally answered it. Breastfeeding the baby before going out and coming back on time works very well. I would avoid even letting myself in a place where I am likely to fall in such situation.
If I really do, because mishaps occur, I would go just quickly go wherever I was going and get a private place in there.
@Kiels01 what on earth do you mean by no private place to go in the first place? If I'm out then I'm definitely going somewhere, right? To someone else's house, a mall, a museum... In many places they have nursing rooms or other private rooms for women only. Or do you think mothers of newborns actually go out to just walk around the streets or the park? Cause even if I did go out for a walk around the house then I could easily come back home when the baby is hungry.
Make sure that your question makes sense before you tell me how to answer. You sound like you won't stop until I say "alright I'll breastfeed in public in that case". That would be when I am homeless, have no shelter, be begging for money and can't even get a place in the bushes.
@Kiels01 it's not an issue. If I can't find any place at all then it's better to finish our work (like shopping) ASAP and then come back home. Making the baby wait for some time doesn't kill anyone.
Go ahead and make an issue out of something that women never had trouble with and totally forget that there are real issues in the world. Seriously, stop making it seem like babies grow up with disability if not exposed to the outside world while being nursed simultaneously.
@Kiels01 newborns do little more than eating and sleeping because their body is still very delicate and in development, including their brain. At this stage they need mostly peace, quiet and to feel safe and comfortable. How well can a little baby sleep (and their brain develop) in a shopping mall or restaurant, surrounded by strangers, loud noises, weird smells, not to mention dust flying around and bacteria?
Also, a baby's heat regulation system isn't the same as of an adult, they're very sensitive to variations in temperature even at home, much less in a park or supermarket.
Of course I realize many parents cannot provide such ideal conditions even if they wanted to but, in my opinion, such moments should be exceptional and not the rule.
You clearly don't sound dumb with the way you are exaggerating stuff in your distorted mind.
@Kiels01 only because it's natural doesn't mean that there should be no privacy in doing it. Breastfeeding IS private between the mother and baby and only the father and other close women from family or friend circle can see it. Changing clothes is also a natural and normal thing that everyone does but will you just take your clothes off in public? No. Bodies are very private to people. And it's not natural to somehow just defy that fact.
@Kiels01 in my opinion, and I think that's also what @CubsterShura is saying, by the time a baby is old enough to be taken out a little more freely (say 6 months +), they're probably not being solely breastfed anymore. By that time, the parents should also be able to plan ahead and know when the baby is going to need to be fed or not.
Anyway, it's not like I'm condemning or even criticizing other people for doing it, or thinking they shouldn't do it ever, ever. It's just that, personally, I tend to think that many women nowadays do it for their own convenience and because "I can, therefore I do it", rather than for the baby's sake - as they try to argue.
Another point is that we usually have this cute idea of breastfeeding in that the baby cries, the mom shows him/ her the breast and everything goes smoothly and is over in a few minutes, when for many mums it can be even a bit dramatic, tiring and time-consuming trying to properly breastfeed, with the baby crying or falling asleep
I've seen experiments like this before. And it really angers me. Personally, if were to ever breastfeed, I'd probably cover myself as much as I can (personal preference) and my mum always covered with a blanket when she fed me in public. But what the general consensus seems to be when the examples given are a breast feeding mother and a woman in a low cut top is that because breastfeeding isn't a sexually appealing thing, its seen as disgusting, whilst the women with the boobs out at least gives something nice for the men to look at. Well, newsflash people but breasts are actually there for the purpose of feeding babies. That's their function. They are not a sexual organ. Whilst it is ok for a man to admire aspects of a woman's body, and breasts do have appeal to them, they are a sexual organ, they are there to produce milk if the time comes.
Society has such mixed opinions on these things. There are magazines and television that are showing breasts as sexual e. g. porn, magazines, etc. But meanwhile, many people hold the view that 'breast is best' and they should be giving their babies the best nutrition possible (its perfectly ok to bottle feed a baby if that suits you better though). If we want this, why aren't mums allowed to do this in public? Their nipples won't even be out for long because the baby will be sucking it.
I think its disgraceful breastfeeding mums are shamed. They're raising the next generation on the nutrition that's there for this reason.
Ya but you were raised that way too. Just go the extra one millionth of a mile. And use a damn covering. It's literally so easy.
@Prankster13 yes personally this is what I would do as it's a personal preference. What I'm saying is that you would barely seeing any anyway. Nipple is being sucked on by the baby and the rest is just fleshy and could be seen in any skimpy outfit. Whilst I think covering up is what I'd do, it's natural thing and who says you have to look anyway.
I'm just saying. It's not necessary if you want to breastfeed a child that you MUST do it without covering up. And the baby can nod.
You made it seem like if you are against her not covering herself decently then you want every baby to be fed formula from the store.
No. I'm in favor of breastfeeding. But I'm also in favor of dressing appropriately. Just cover up. It's really easy.
I feel that it should be okay but I am a curious dude and if I am just strolling by and women breastfeeding a baby popped in my face. I don't want to be called names such as "Pervert" or a woman looking at me with a face of fear just because she was in my field of vision for about a second.
A great example would be: if I am at work with a lady that brought her babies to work. She likes talking to me and then she wants to talk to me while breastfeeding her baby, I am sorry but I will stare at titties sometimes because it's in my face.
Also, If I put my hand up to my face to block the vision of her chest area, I feel that the lady would be heavily offended I did such and thing and tell me to grow up.
I also feel like Americans are going to find a way to troll breastfeeding rights such as pranks where girls running around shooting breastmilk at everyone. Or girls shooting breastmilk on someone's food, drink or coffee if they don't like them.
Also, you know there are going to be some lazy ones in public transits such as breastmilk stains all over train seats and such. It could potentially be a biological hazard for those breastfeeders who have HIV or other STDs.
"A great example would be: if I am at work with a lady that brought her babies to work. She likes talking to me and then she wants to talk to me while breastfeeding her baby, I am sorry but I will stare at titties sometimes because it's in my face."
Great example of exhibitionism. That's not just feeding a baby, that's called being indiscreet.
That's cool. I just think it's hypocritical of women to act like a breast is suddenly not sexual just because it's used for a non-sexual purpose.
@cherryphi82 I believe you there because Americans will find a way to do something stupid, such as:
You find a girl breastfeeding in public thus making her breast automatic non-sexually or w/e, then you have some weirdo or prankster who pokes at her breast while feeding her baby.
Do you think she is not going to call the police and say something related to "Rape"?
Or you have a couple where the lady breastfeeds her mate in public because he/she is hungry and he/she is playing with her other tit while sucking. What is that considered and what happens there?
Adults breastfeeding other adults... the world is getting sicker by the minute.
I've never encountered that latter scenario. I would consider that indecent exposure. We're talking about breastfeeding a baby.
Breast feeding is totally natural.
I have done it many times. 90% of the time no one says or reacts any different.
Its not like I'm whipping my tit out and showing off my nipple or waving them around in the air. I'm literally feeding a hungry baby.. So using my boobs for EXACTLY WHAT THEYRE MADE FOR!
It you dont like it, dont look. Or go somewhere else. Its fucking 2018. Women can wear nipple stickers out in public with no top on but god forbid a mother feed her child without a blanket over their head.
Its fucking stupid.
Except a woman wearing nipple stickers can still be a distracting sight.
Lol I completely don’t understand why this has to be such a topic of concern.
It is legal in all 50 states for women to breast feed in public.
However, private property is not subject to public law in this regard. An owner of private property may choose to set rules that prevent it just like they can say no food or drink allowed.
For every woman I’ve ever noticed breast feeding in public I’ve seen 50 articles threads questions complaining about the fact some people don’t like it. You no more have the right to tell them what they should think is ok than they do to tell you what isn’t ok.
Do what you are going to do.
To me, this is also a cultural and religious thing.
I find breastfeeding to be natural, I think it should be done discreetly in public. It's a private moment, but yet a normal moment.
We have booths here in Sweden, for the ones who wants to use them, otherwise we breastfeed openly with the shirt pulled down just above the baby's face. Others put their blanket over. It's really not a hard thing to do.
Breasts are sexual, always have been, more so in some areas of the world than in others. I'm however raised in the 80s with topless being the normal occurrence on beaches. To me, there is an incredibly heightened drama around this, nowadays.
Just because it's natural, doesn't mean it needs to be flaunted in people's faces.
Use common sense. Be respectful (goes both ways).
Reset "normal".
Society views breasts as a sexual thing, so when a woman "exposes" herself in public instead of everyone having the mindframe that she's just feeding her young the way any other mammal does they automatically get the thought that she shouldn't be exposing herself and she needs to cover up or go elsewhere. Breast are meant for babies. If a mother wants or needs to feed her child she should be allowed to do so wherever and whenever she deems fit regardless if she decides to cover herself or not. Her child needs to eat, people can get the hell over themselves.
It should be a private thing for mother and child. Just because it's natural it's still a private part of a woman's body. It's fine if you're discrete and not showing your whole breast. But my kids don't need to see a woman tits. Women did it for years discretely just fine. But now women are entitled, selfish, and lazy. They care about them and what they consider an inconvenience to cover themselves. They don't care about other kids. My vagina is natural too but I'm not having sex in public because I'm naturally making a baby. Most normal parents teach their kids that boobs, butts, penises and vaginas are private parts you don't show to strangers. Unless it's an emergency situation there's no need to pull your tit out for everyone to see.
My son won't even look at boobs on a movie because he feels it's disrespectful to her. So yes some would be quite bothered by it. But hey there's some teens that would love looking at a womans titties. Just don't mind if they keep looking. Or maybe they like that attention. I can't think of any other reason to do it when you have options to cover.
@PinkMichae
Since you live in the USA your kids will see boobs. It isn't like every women is going to be 100% covered up from the neck down. Their are women who show cleavage which will show part of the boobs. A lot of swimsuits, dresses, shirts do that.
@MysteriousDarkness. You're seriously gonna compare cleavage to a woman with her tits completely exposed? If you're gonna come at me please make sure it's not a stupid comparison like that. And so far he hasn't been forced to see a full set of tits. When he's ready and chooses to see them on a girl then that's fine. But don't force it on him or other children and people. He understands what breastfeeding is and has seen a woman do it covered up. And that's fine as she wasn't pulling everything out for people to see.
I swear people act as if the world should just become one big nudes colony. Women want to walk around topless, breastfeed exposed. Next we won't have anything left for the imagination. Our kids will be so desensitized and can walk around naked too like mommy a d daddy. And all the sicko's can target them and get their rocks off. I'm sure the sickos are all for mom's exposing themselves as well.
@PinkMichae
Some clothing leave very little of the boobs covered.
@MysteriousDarkness. I don't take my son to strip shows or where all the hookers walk. I've lived a lot of different places and have yet to see a bunch of women with even half their tits out. Even growing up on the beaches of San Diego, Ca their bathing suits cover the nips. And a trust me don't think I don't have issues with women wearing g string at the beach with kids around too. I'm definitely not a prude as I don't see an issue with women wearing low cut tops. Just don't completely expose yourself. It's really not that hard. I'm a mom. There was nothing hard about pumping milk into a bottle of I was going out to dinner or if it was spontaneous using a cover wasn't hard either. I don't need people staring at me nursing my son. I didn't care yo bring that sort of attention to the family I was enjoying a meal with. It's unnecessary no matter how much you think you can argue it.
@PinkMichae
If guys can show their nipples lets say at the beach then women should be able to. Not all women can use breast pumps. On top of that i have known babies that will not eat ifcovered up. Then what should the mother do if she wants to breast feed?
@PinkMichae
and she does not have a bottle with her.
@MysteriousDarkness. Then breastfeed but discretely. I don't care if a woman breastfeed her baby in public. I care that she does it discreetly without feeling entitled to take her nipple out for everyone to see. So now that this conversation has gotten to the point where I'm repeating myself. Enough said. There's nothing more I can say to help you understand. Have a nice life.😎
@PinkMichae
I have been to all 50 states and some other countries. I have never seen any woman breastfeeding in public. People like you make this a bigger issue than it really is.
Feeding a baby is like peeing or having sex. It's a normal body activity, but people would rather not watch people do their business or excrete fluids. The breast is a sexual organ to adults, plain and simple. I could walk by a mother breastfeeding just fine because I'm an aunt so I've seen it. Men will probably stare tho. I can understand it from both sides. It's natural but it's also distracting because it's an exposed squishy boob. We may just have to accept that this debate has no right or wrong. Moms, just do what you like!
You're bloody retarded mate.
Because breast are amazing. They look good when full and plumped, they nurse you/your child. There is a lot more to breast than you think, they are so magical. They are sacred.
We all know this deep down. Hence the various feelings people feel when they see them. Mostly intimidation though. The female body is so capable of so much things we all know but I believe so much more. Don't think I'm discrediting men I'm not, I don't know what it feels like to be a man. But the energy and love a mother presents when Brest feeding especially it makes others uncomfortable. It's deeper than just Brest in my opinion
I don't agree with most public decency laws anyway, and think women should be able legally walk around topless regardless of if they're breastfeeding or not. However, even if I didn't think that, I don't know how breastfeeding would not get a pass. Feeding babies is a necessary part of our existence as a species, and breastfeeding is the natural way to do it. Of course you could argue that sex is too, but humanity doesn't exactly need people to have sex every couple hours in order for us to survive, so we can arrange for it to be more discrete.
Should sex be legal in public?
Why not? I thought that's perfectly natural, too!
Mothers with babies are already the most entitled people on the planet, I encounter them on a daily basis shoving people aside with their baby carriages, and they are totally smug about it... ugh! Don't take it personally, there are obviously NOT annoying mothers out there, but many succumb to the "motherly superiority" syndrome, where they think they can do whatever the fuck they want.
So, they are already at the peak of entitlement, and you want to give them even MORE bullshit rights?
OK, let's play this game. Abolish public indecency as an offense, and we can talk about breastfeeding.
Nope. It's disgusting to see a mother feeding her baby in public. I can not believe the audacity of some people the fact they just freely whip their boobs out to feed their crying baby so it doesn't go hungry and calms them down. Like how dare they. I was in Victoria secret one time and I the conner of my eye right by the big poster of the model modeling the underwear there was this lady and she was breast feeding right there in the middle of the store it was unbelievable I am still scared from it. It was an awful experience.
Disgusting?
Yeah you both missed what I was saying lol.
Men are disgusting. Breastfeeding is a beautiful and natural thing, if anyone in public is uncomfortable then they should just leave because it's their problem not the mother's problem. Babies don't have a particular schedule on when they need to be fed, so often times they need to be fed when they are in public and if not then the baby will start crying and cause a scene, all I see is disgrace upon people who frown on public breastfeeding. Laws and society should not interfere with natural things like this.
There was this one woman in Cracker Barrel who was breastfeeding her baby at the table but she had this specially made cover that went over her shoulder to cover the act even though you knew what she was doing you couldn't see it occur. I thought it was an incredible invention and a responsible way of breastfeeding your kid in public.
I don't support free the nipple or slutty attire either by the way and I understand the difference between that and breastfeeding. But still, don't show your tits in public. That is a sacred moment for her and her kid.
I breastfeed my son no matter where he is if he’s hungry or thirsty he has it on demand as I exclusively feed.
I don’t cover his face or my boob because well frankly he’d pull it away not to mention it’d be hugely uncomfortable for my son especially on a hot day. Imagine being sat with a sheet over your head whilst you eat or drink your food I’m pretty sure it’d annoy the hell out of you.
I think it should be allowed at some point, and in some places and not now. I don't want any woman or baby to be assaulted during that, so if you don't educate people, don't show that it is normal or don't educate to be ethical and help if help is needed, it won't end up very well sometimes and it's not a good option for that reason. You can't deny the fact that there are people who would hurt you. Your right to live and be safe is much more than the right to breastfeed in public. How can the countries keep you safe if a rapist would try to rape you? Think about that. You would try to cover it, and you would try not to be in a crowded place so it would be even easier to rape you. You could be sexually harrassed. It's definitely a thing I would be worried about if it was allowed in my country. I think you should wait a bit, figure out how to solve some problems first and then allow it.
Feed your kid whenever they're hungry 🤷♀️ I only notice when a babies crying and I look to see why lol
Most people that complain are women who don't want their men looking at another's boobs in public. Most guys could careless. There's plenty of other boobs to see that aren't spoken for 😂
The thing is: breastfeeding boobs aren't the most attractive. So I think that argument is moot.
You're also sexualizing the act when you're saying this.
Fact of life boobs have been sexualized for many years. Point is most guys could careless if your breastfeeding in public or not because it's not attractive in that way. It's the women (40 + years old usually) that want you to cover up or hide in a bathroom.
That hasn't been my experience.
I remember reading an article a while ago, that suggested that the reason some men don't approve of public breastfeeding, is because the thought of a women's breasts being out for something other than his own enjoyment upsets him. I've never forgotten it
That’s bullshit. Most men don’t like it because it can be distracting and an awkward sight to see. I have no problem with women breastfeeding in public but like I said, it’ll still be a distracting sight.
Because in our society breasts aren't seen as a tool to sustain a tiny life, they're seen only as something sexual.
I've heard my boyfriends brother in law shame his own wife about how brazen she was about breast feeding their baby while out for dinner. She had none of his shit and told him "ok I'll go pump, come back and you can either go sit in the bathroom and feed her or go sit in the hot car and feed her, either way she will start crying, so you have fun with that. Ill sit here and enjoy eating my meal. Or i can feed my baby whenever she's hungry in the quickest and easiest way."
I usually tell people "Dont like it? then you dont have to look at them."
People at the restaurant where I work do that too. And I'm the waiter.
I literally have to stand directly in front of them and make eye contact. Which is like inches away. And I have peripheral vision. So yes I basically have to see it. And it's very awkward.
@Prankster13
And seeing this is a problem because? You can't avoid looking her boob? You can't not sexualize her breast? You can't cope with the concept that breasts actally aren't indecent?
And if a womans eyes are literally just a mere few inches from her nipple, im concerned 😅
Like six or seven inches. Less than a foot is what I meant... and it's hard to look at a window without seeing the windowsill. I'm not looking at her breast. But I can still see it. And it's right there.
And yes it does make me uncomfortable. Because it is hard for me not to sexualize it. And at the least the nipples are indecent. For reason by law. And the baby nods you know. Sometimes. At the most inconvenient moments.
It would take so little effort for her to just cover up. I'm fine with breastfeeding. But just please for goodness sakes cover up! That's all I'm asking. Everyone is expected to cover up in public. Why is she not? What's so different that she can't cover up?
@Prankster13
Its YOUR porblem you can't control yourself over something so simple. And yeah cover up so both mom and baby are uncomfortable. Most babies hate coverings. It value the babys comfort over yours
It's not that hard to cover up. I've tried one of those coverings on before while I was at my sister's house. It's not uncomfortable at all.
You think pants are comfortable compared to nude? I'd much rather go without them. But I don't. Because people don't wanna see that.
How complicated would it have to be for me to be allowed to be uncomfortable? Huh? Streaking is pretty damn simple too. And no one says "gees why does something so *simple* bother you so much?"
Well golly. I don't know! Maybe because it doesn't take something super complicated to make someone uncomfortable.
It's not YOUR problem if I strip naked in front of you and you get uncomfortable because of it! It's MY problem because I'll get freaking arrested! It's indecent exposure just cover the hell up. It's SOOO easy to cover up. And it's called common decency. It's not complicated either, you know.
@Prankster13 you grow some tits, have a baby and produce milk, then your opinion on comfort while breast feeding is valid. Until then your voice means shit
... so but does having been a baby count? That's technically part of it. Right?
@Prankster13
Sorry I guess I should've thought twice about trying to explain such a complex concept to someone so mentally challenged
Okay.. that's false and uncalled for. But I'll take it.
Please explain it like I'm mentally challenged. Maybe I'll get it then.
@Prankster13 because you clearly can't understand what you're reading
Then spell it out for me. Okay? I really don't see where I went wrong..
I may have not had a good score on the ACT. But I did ace the reading part. So please explain what I missed here?
@Prankster13 you makes you think having seen a baby before means shit?
Been*
Yes!
People who say it's nasty/unnatural and so on, are the nasty ones. Perverts sexualizing feeding your child. It's the most natural thing in the world and people should relax and go home to rub one out if it turns them on so much instead of complaining like little bitches
While I don't have a problem with it, I suppose if I think about it I could understand where some people might. I guess some people would rather not be reminded of the fact that the tits on a female of any mammal are actually for feeding their young and not the "fun bags" they usually like to think of them as. When they see a woman breastfeeding her child, it's hard not to draw the comparison of a cow or dog or some other less savory animal.
And no, that's not me comparing women to livestock, I'm simply trying my best to explain other people's thinking. I could very well be wrong, this is just the best and most rational conclusion I could come up. Now then, I invite the downvotes and/or insults from anyone who hasn't bothered to actually read and understand what I've just said.
Yes. To all those saying "they're showing too much" or "it's indecent", etc., when the baby is nursing, it's mouth is covering the nipple, so there's no nudity. And how much time is it between "freeing the nipple" and putting it in the child's mouth? 15 seconds (or less)? Plus, a lot of times, the mother lifts up her top on one breast, so that basically covers the top of her boob and the baby's head basically covers the bottom part.
But, if she's in church... Most churches have a nursery where they should go to do it. I mean, the root of "nursery" is "nurse".
In the state I live in, there's a chain of supermarkets that have a "mother's room" between the restrooms, where moms can breastfeed (or change diapers) in privacy. But, personally, I have no problem with them doing it in public as well.
Who has such an idiotic sense to actually stop and make a negative comment...
I’ve never seen that before lol... I mean I’d just walk by... EVEN if I did find that disgusting, which I don’t, I still wouldn’t say anything...
Ehhhh cause like who cares...
These people who said something seem to be the overly opinionated ones that don’t know when to shut up at a party
If my baby is hungry, I'm gonna feed my baby. I'm not letting my child starve because of what the public think. If you don't want to look, turn your face. It's a natural thing so I don't see why there should be a problem.
With all do respect...
Please don't rape me
You know its true and your baby needs like milk and stuff to live but
- _-.
I dunno... Like on a bus ride it was crowded.. And a women flopped her tit with no remorse or discretion and i died of embarrassment i faced away and tall people were behind me i was asfixiated and she wasn't even discrete
So she stared at me with this mad look and i had a women feeding her baby that's fine...
IN FRONT OF ME STARING AT ME WITH THAT MAD FACE I PEED MY PANTS i was so scared dude
I just wanted to go home and not see that.
Also boners are frowned upon and its natural we can't help it so 🤷🏼🤷🏼🤷🏼🤷🏼
my mom thinks breastfeeding is okay, but all the women in my family lay a thin cloth over their breast/shoulder so no one can see their baby eating. They don't want strangers to look at their breasts, that's only meant for their husbands to see. Also people consider breasts to be sexual, the sight of breast gets men riled up and even some women, so that's why people think it's best to do it privately.
Because as a society we've sexualized them so much that we see boobs, we're more likely to think sex, which is obviously not appropriate in league with kids, but if you see boobs for what they actually are, and not what we've made them be associated with, they couldn't be more appropriate for kids 😂 it's basically the packaging for a babies meal 😂 they fact that some people say "boobs aren't suitable for kids" is pathetic, they couldn't be more suitable if you remove the idea that they're about sex.
Pricks. I'd tell them to fuck right off.
She is feeding her baby.
If women didn't have children,
we'd ALLLLLLL be flat chested.
"That's hot" and "That's disgusting."
Should have said, "Well you best not be
out in public either then, because you're
disgusting yourself, mate."
Very few people care or have strong feelings against breastfeeding in public. The media just likes to report on isolated incidents because big milky tits generate views to their articles.
A couple years ago I read a story about this hot mom who had a professional photographer take pictures of herself breastfeeding her babies. Nothing wrong with that, except she shared the photos on her Facebook page, and when people saw her giant gazongas they left all kinds of nasty comments.
No worries though, the media gallantly saved the day by writing dozens of articles, all of which featured pictures of her massive jugs for the world to see. Now we get to fantasize about those delicious hooters. Err-I mean, we get to have an open dialogue about breastfeeding in public.
Yes, it should be acceptable for women to do in public. Any sane person should prefer a child getting fed over a hungry child screaming next to them.
And yes, they should be allowed to do it anywhere, without having to excuse themselves. If they want to cover, fine, but if their baby doesn't like the cover (many don't) then no big deal. It's a normal and natural thing.
huh.. well i always see people breastfeeding in public it's completely normal and nobody gets disgusted or whatever here. there is always a cloth to cover which i think its important bc come on people are either gonna think it's gross or they're gonna think sexually - it's nearly impossible to change what people truly think yk.
and lets say babies get their milk from a dude's ball. ain't nobody wanna see that 🤷♀️
i know a lot of people don't agree with me because it's "natural" but i still think you should cover and yes i agree that breastfeeding should be OK in public
I think it's fine. It's natural and when i have the chance to have a child i'll breast feed wherever i am. I'm not covering up if i don't want to. I'll try to keep my nipple covered with my shirt but for when i am latching the baby on that nipple needs to be out.
I'd only use a cover if it's cold and the baby was a bit cold. I'm not making my baby overheat under a blanket on a hot summer day though.
You don't like it? Don't look. Easy enough.
I'm not bothered who sees me breast feeding my baby in a natural and bonding way. If they stare, they stare. All they will see is the back of the babies head.
having sex is also natural for two people to bond and procreate so no one should mind if me and my lover choose to have sex on a bench in times square. avert your eyes and cover your childrens'.
@COCOCHANEL
Taking a big shit is also natural. I should be allowed to squat wherever and whenever I want. It's my body, I do what I want.
A baby feeding and natural bodily urges are different. Shows how immature you are.
This is one of the silliest and most immature controversies out there. I have yet to encounter anyone across Europe who even remotely has a problem with this. Americans...
@Pamina I think that's a very important point. Breastfeeding in public doesn't generally happen that often. It is very easy to avoid, and most people with infants don't go to venues that are geared toward the single and childless. It is really a situational thing.
It's as natural as taking a pee or doing # 2.
However, do we do this publicly proudly go around telling everyone about it? I don't think so.
The same goes for breastfeeding. Yes, it's normal but there needs to be some discretion. If I were a mother, this would be a special moment between my child and I.
It amazes me that people have a problem with breastfeeding. It's normal and natural, and very good for the baby. It helps establish good health for the baby. How amyone can be Okay with skimpy clothing, but find breast feeding disgusting, is beyond me.
Breast feeding is ok just cover and be decent about your breasts being exposed because most people, men and women alike find breast to be a sexual thing and for arousal. Breast feeding is neither but still it’s uncomfortable to most and can be distracting as well. So happily feed your babies in anywhere but with courtesy in decency.
Reading through these comments biwilders me.
I see so many people out in public go braless and make it noticeable by wearing a sheer top /white tee... but for some reason when a mom chooses to feed her child which is a BIOLOGICALLY PHYSICAL need, people shame the mom with uncomfortable looks. If there is no place to feed the child, if the child is frolicking and doesn't want to be covered while feeding, who is to shame a mom in doing her duty to nurture her child?
It's frowned upon because boobs have become overly sexualised in our culture. Dumb people think that they're sex organs and as a result even if they know that they're there to feed babies, which many people are too stupid to realise, they see it as kind of perverted and therefore something that should be done in private - just like sex. Pretty fucked up if you ask me.
I was watching a movie with my friend the other day and there was a scene when the lady was breastfeeding her child. He was like “omg, you didn’t tell me there’s nudity in this!” In a joking tone.
I just told him “she’s feeding her child, leave her be, it’s natural.” Because it is. It’s better to have a well fed baby than a screaming baby next to you in the train so suck it up people. Breast feeding is for the purpose of feeding offspring, not for a show.
Yeah according to me breastfeeding in public is absolutely fine there is nothing that sorts of crosses a line but it's the social stigma we have in our mind that whenever we see breasts all we can think about is sex we should have a control over our mind and we should understand that connecting everything with sex is a sign of sick mentality.
Being totally honest, I have seen many women breastfeeding, the majority of which it's so casual it just looks like they're holding their baby close to them. The only way you'll see nipples is if YOU look too close to where it is really none of your business.
Exaaactly.
I think a mother should feed her baby whenever and wherever she feels is appropriate! It's not our business. If she is comfortable having a stranger glance.. cuz that's the kind of world we live in. But I think its natural and doesn't bother me.
No they definitely shouldn't Haha but that's a completely different matter. You don't have to have sex. But the baby does have to eat.
"You don't have to have sex"
And you don't have to breastfeed either.
Apart from regular old cow milk, there's this great thing:
www.lansinoh.com/.../044677505208_3.jpg
Seriously, don't pretend like breastfeeding is the only viable option to feeding a baby. And I am not saying you shouldn't do it. But you shouldn't do it in public.
Except that you SHOULD breastfeed. Its healthy for the baby. Its how the mother passes on her own anitbiodies and immunity to the baby. Babies that dont breastfeed tend to get sick more often.
And breast pumps are inconvenient. Why have the middleman when your baby can just drink the freshest food?
I never said you shouldn't breastfeed, but don't do it in public. Because it is indecent.
"breast pumps are inconvenient."
Underwear is inconvenient. Pants are inconvenient. Just as shirts. Lots of inconveniences in life. Do you know why they exist? To stabilize the social structure by inducing as little tension as possible. That's why pulling out your tits in public shouldn't be allowed.
"Why have the middleman when your baby can just drink the freshest food?"
Why have a middleman (bed), when I can just fuck her right here, in a bus stop?
@Benedek38 Did your dumbass really compare feeding a baby to sex? Why are you sexualizing a baby you sick fuck?
@kaskas19
"Kids need to eat."
Breastfeeding is not the only way to feed a child.
I presented a couple of options.
"Some kids don't take a bottle and can't have baby formula."
Bullshit. The kid is malleable. It's the mother that lacks the will to separate the child, that are responsible. It is entirely up to her. Also, you can feed the baby at home.
"if the majority of men can not be pussies about it, so can you."
That sentence makes no sense. "Cannot" can't be followed up by "so can".
@kaskas19 Sorry I tagged the wrong person LOL D:
@Benedek38 Oh he knows exactly what I think of men, but not all men are the same. Men like you, though, get hurt when a woman does mention "all men" which I didn't say lol. Anyway.. get over it. My man is amazing.
Alright you guys. Can we stop this right now? I'm tired of getting notifications about a pointless argument.
If people struggle that much with diverting their eyes from an infant suckling on their mother's breast, then I think society has some serious problems.
Its part of life and someplace don't even have a private room. or will be too hot. They should let mum breastfeed. If people going be a pussy about it then add lactation room or club. if fucking ok to do it public. I don't like when a people fucking a child around.

Taking a shit is natural too, and nobody is arguing that we should do that publicly...
Having sex is natural, are we going to do that in public?
If you support it fine, but don't use the "It's natural" argument if you're going to be selective with it. Either "It's natural" is a valid argument which applies across the board, or it's an idiotic one that you need to stop using.
Sure, you should be able to feed in public places but cover the fuck up.
we said the same thing but i got female downvotes. interesting.
@COCOCHANEL Bunch of butthurts who can't whip out their boobies, lol
Amen -
BULL! Even I should be able to nurse and I do daily!##
IF it offends look away, if you can
@thomasans2 I'm just gonna quote @OlderAndWiser on that one: "No, everyone present must look away or one person can be more discreet."
Why would they need to "be more descreet" and what do you mean with it? Should they hide? There is no shame in breastfeeding a baby. It's natural. And no, sorry, but saying that "everyone present must look away" is total bullshit. Only those that are bothered need to, but I do hope that the majority of people are not as retarded as to be bothered by a mom caring for her baby.
@LearningSim What I mean by that is that they should cover up when feeding in public places. There are nursing covers specifically for that purpose. They are easily carry-able in a purse or diaper bag and easy to wear. You can also use a blanket, but those tend to slide off more. Asking someone to be discreet is not the same as telling them to remove themselves or telling them to stop. I see nursing mothers all the time. Most of them cover up just fine. It's the ones that don't seem to care that I have a problem with.
Whats there to cover when girls like the attention
@Kevin77777 I don't disagree with you that some women want attention, but not most. You're the example of someone who further sexualizes the act.
@kaskas19 Then you should find an establishment that provides secluded areas for nursing mothers.
For those who want to talk about covering up being difficult -- who of you have actually breastfed a baby? I'm waiting.
Obviously I have not breast fed, but my wife did with our two. The babies did not like the covers. Fought having their faces covered and tossed it off And babies often get used to a nipple, as in many breast fed babies will not nurse from a bottle nipple. And why should establishments pay for “secluded areas” and separate the mother and child from the rest of the family when the mothers can simply breastfeed where they are and most people not be offended. By the way, your wait is over. It was difficult with ours and I responded. 😀
@Red_Arrow "By the way, your wait is over. It was difficult with ours and I responded."
I have no idea what you're talking about.
"For those who want to talk about covering up being difficult -- who of you have actually breastfed a baby? I'm waiting." That was quoting what you said in this thread a bit ago. And I did talk about covering up and we actually had breastfed two babies. (Obviously she was the one)
@Red_Arrow It was difficult with my three as well, but it was doable. There is rarely a reason to whip your boob out in the middle of a crowd without taking some kind of precaution.
It's natural thing, baby need food whenever he is hungry,
Mothers need to feed baby she can't wait to reach home, she can't take hungry and crying baby too long
WWe should respect women, think like her and feel like her
Guys only have mouth to say bad only,
just only take women's responsibility of caring baby just for two days
YYou will never your mouth for anything after that
When a woman is breastfeeding, every man in the area has to be conscious of the fact that they can't look over in her direction. You have to keep your head pointed the other way, and sometimes that's not convenient depending on seating arrangements.
It's just annoying to force other people to enforce your own privacy for you, to force other people to protect your dignity for you.
Oh god forbid something is INCONVENIENT for you and other men!!
@winniethepoah I honestly don't give a shit, lady. Really, I don't.
I'm just answering the question. He wants to know what POSSIBLE reason anybody would have a problem, I gave one.
You're the one who can't handle it.
That video is so fake. They're literally saying the exact same thing and he's blurring their faces clearly so that people don't know its people in his family/friends group he's having say the exact same phrase over and over again. People aren't actually this verbal in real life. And even if they were there's be far more variation in word choice as oppose to everyone saying "disgusting."
It is a controversial topic. First of all: Yes, it is normal, but also a personal action, like going to the bathroom. I'm not agree about that thing saying "Its not acceptable". Cause it already is, the first months of child life they depends of breastfeeding, AND some situations can't be delayed. Conclusion, it's normal and shouldn't be frowned UP, but even though it should be considered like a mid-private action.
As long as it's socially acceptable to stare and no one is going to get shit for being a "creep" then I don't care. It's a twofold issue. Because you know people are going to have it both ways. "Why can't I just feed my child without guys staring at me?". Well, most people don't have to get naked before feeding their kids in public lol.
I think women should be allowed to show their breast in public the American sexualization of the female body is insane
Boobies are not scary people. The sight of them will not bring about the end of the world. They will not cause you to go blind. And if you can’t help but stare, then maybe you’re the one who should go to a special room so the breasts feeding mom doesn’t have to feel uncomfortable.
Or they could just use a blanket? You know. Like I use pants? A penis isn't scary and won't make you go blind either, you know. This argument is stupid.
@Sbgirl I know. I'm talking about her boob. I thought that was clear. Sorry.
Boob= body part.
Penis= body part.
Exposure of penis or nipple = indecent exposure.
So why does this not add up for breastfeeding?
@Prankster13 what I mean is, sorry if I didn't make clear, is that when a breastfeeding woman covers up, the bay will likely have to be covered at least partially too. It may not like it and not feed properly. And nipple won't be on show, or very briefly because the nipple will be in the babies mouth.
@Sbgirl Okay. I'm talking about the boob though. And if I wore pants and just whipped it out to pee on the street or something. It's just a few seconds. My hands should be coverinv it the whole time.
But it's STILL indecent exposure. So...
@Prankster13
I’m sorry that you cannot get past the fact that you find boobs sexually attractive, but the main function of the breast is to feed babies. I was always discreet when I had to feed my children, but feed them I did.
It’s also legal to go topless where I live, so a woman doesn’t even have to have a baby attach to be shirtless. If you find breasts indecent, I would recommend you stay away from places where tops for women are optional.
.. well okay.
I mean, we are allowed to do it.
Should we all go tribal, walk around shirtless and feed the baby at the restaurant, during working hours at our desk or whenever, wherever we please? I'm inclined to say no.
As for the argument which is made often enough "it is natural", I can only say "so is pooping".
I don't have a problem with breastfeeding in public.
Don't really understand shitty people who can't keep their nasty thoughts to themselves. What happened to if you have nothing nice to say, shut the fuck up?
You can also add your opinion below!
Most Helpful Opinions