Because "All Lives Matter" is a reactionary statement made by people that only exist to counter statements regarding issues that affect Black people the most rather than people that genuinely care about "all lives." The truth is that certain issues affect different groups more than others, meaning that it could be a cause of concern for that community. "All Lives Matter" basically tries to convince people that the issue isn't just a cause of concern for that community, but for everybody equally. For example, even though anybody could be a victim of police misconduct, statistics prove that Black people are five-times more likely to be killed by police when they are unarmed. Thus, that is an issue that affects the Black community the most. If this wasn't the case, then the rates would be closer to equal for everybody.
Police officers are also more likely to get off scot-free when they kill Black people unjustly. The public is also more likely to support the cops if the victim is Black and attempt to demonize the victim rather than the cop. The judicial system is also likely to support the cop so he won't get convicted, assuming that he even goes to trial. As a result, people conclude that if you're more likely to kill a Black person when he or she is unarmed, get away with it, and have much of the public support the cop and sully the victim, the Black victim's life must not matter much. To say that "all lives matter" in response to this is simply untrue because, if they did, police wouldn't unjustly kill Black people at much higher rates than other races and the media, police departments, and the public wouldn't demonize the Black victim of police misconduct, something that rarely happens with non-Black victims of police misconduct.
Clearly, "all lives matter" is merely a reactionary statement made by people that are triggered about people claiming that Black people are affected by certain issues more. If "all lives mattered" to them truly, then it wouldn't be a statement that you only hear in response to people saying "Black lives matter." It would be its own political movement that addresses all instances of injustice to all people, not only as a counter to Black people trying to identify and solve the problems that affect them the most. It's not much different to trying to convince Asian people going through racism during COVID-19 that "all racism is bad" despite the fact COVID-19 racism is something that affected their community the most.
It's also not much different to going to a prostate cancer awareness program to tell the hosts that "all diseases matter," not just prostate cancer. Imagine that you're trying to raise awareness for prostate cancer, but some woman comes in and says, "what about breast cancer? All cancer matters!" Sure, both are issues, but one affects one group more than the other. Thus, it shouldn't be wrong to address this and raise awareness. It's not much different to telling LGBT people that "all HIV/AIDS victims matter" when they attempt to raise AIDS awareness in their community because it affects them the most. It's based on a false belief that you're "racist" or prejudiced in some form to say that different groups are more or less affected by different problems and that we all share every problem equally as a human race, but that's just simply untrue. All lives SHOULD matter, but based on statistics and double standards when certain things happen to certain people in certain groups, they clearly don't.
Most Helpful Opinions
Okay im going to be very open and honest right now. I have NO reason to discriminate against black people at all. They are equal to whites, mexicans, Asians, russians, like shit. I understand that what the police did to Geroge Floyd is HORRIBLE and there was NO reason or excuse for it. And im not standing up for that one police officer who did what he did. But to commit all of these crimes is doing nothing. I understand you want to prove a point to the government and citizens that black lives matter, because they do. But by destroying others lives, you really think your helping? Protesting is amazing. you're stabding up for what u believe in. But setting things on fire, robbing stores, killing people. Now what im about to say next may get me hate. Now im not saying i BELIEVE in thesr stereotypes but in a "stereotypical world" black people would always be stealing or ribbing or killing people. Right? Because thats what socuety has brought upon everyone. But by trying to prove your point that y'all are good people, setting things on fire and robbing aren't the way to do it.. I understand that what happened a long time ago was EXTREMELY wrong. But we can't change it. Most of history is bad. But without everything that has happened, look how we have developed. You can not blame all of us whites today for what happened between our ancestors.
Ok so there are a few problems here to unpack.
First the argument for BLM, it's been said by many supporters that of course all lives matter but for all lives to matter then black lives must matter too, in my view that's fair enough.
The problem comes when that argument is made and some are allowed to destroy homes, businesses in the name of the movement, when ridiculous ideas are out forward as a way of dealing with the past. When some who were killed are later shown to have been less than the Saint they were portrayed to be at the time.
Then there are a few other issues to unpack, yes blacks in the USA have it hard, truth is though so do whites.
Of course we can argue about privilege but frankly that's just bullshit, white people as a racial group are the worst performing of all racial groups, underperforming in all areas of society when you factor in numbers. Asians and Indians are the best performing groups.
White people are actually only slightly less likely to be killed by police officers or badly treated as black people. Again according to the figures.
Another problem is biased media, media that wants to stir up controversy, while I agree what the police did to that man is murder, I disagree that he was innocent, he was trying to pass off a forged note and high on meth at the time.
There is more than just this set of issues to deal with though which is that generally as a society American people have been sliding backwards in terms of critical thinking for years. Not five minutes before writing this opinion I watched a woman being interviewed quoting stats and saying that her figures came from the American statistical bureau, when the interviewer said a few other figures to her and said that his figures came from the same agency her best response was to say she didn't trust that agency anyway.
So here's where it all falls apart then, why is it ok to trust a body when they say something you like but sent them when they don't, and it's because of a lack of critical thinking ability.
That's why people get triggered, truthfully if critical thinking were better taught the. I doubt that BLM would even exist. If they did the last thing they would be doing is protesting and they'd be working with the police to take best practices of other police forces from around the world and helping to shape a national standard of training for all police. Then again murdering police and burning houses and businesses is far more the actual path, so you'll have to forgive me for not giving two shits because they don't get any support from me
It seems that being an influencer or receiving ratings often matters more to a person or group than the actual merits of an argument. This is not to say the BLM movement does not have its merits.
From my perspective as a poor "white" guy whos family was never part of slavery, other than possibly being one (history is fuzzy for my ancestry), this country has massive divisiveness issues, as well as an economy that absolutely keeps the working class nailed down, and sets them up to fail.
Offset programs are implemented to stop so-called racism (Melanism I call it as humans are all one race, but with minor skin and genetic differences). We have EEOC and affirmative action that guarantees some people with darker skin will receive jobs. Sometimes this prevents the business from getting the best candidate, and sometimes the "white guy" is about to become homeless without that job, and is very likely in the same boat as most other people.
What I've seen in this country is the rich getting richer, and poor getting poorer, and their education a travesty of whatnot should be. I see it as a wholly national sociopolitical issues, and that this "race war", while systemic due to how the system functions, affects everyone, including the so-called privileged, but as long as we fight amongst ourselves, we will not be free from the oppression that is the institution of the USA.
What Girls & Guys Said
Opinion
79Opinion
Because they know that it’s moronic to say “all lives matter” when not all lives were forced into slavery, beaten, tortured, and killed.
It's like being in an emergency room and the nurse tells you "Everyone is sick have a seat" BUT you are bleeding and about to die. You would definitely get upset that the nurse just totally disregard your situation and lumped you with the other patients who are not in a serious or critical condition.
True, "All Lives Matter" But, that's the point. If all lives matter there should be fair justice for all lives.
People are quick to judge and not empathize. If you walk in someone's shoes for a day or week, you would understand.
If you look at history of how people have been treated by law enforcement and the judiciary system, you would understand.
And, not all are criminals experiencing police brutality, injustice and incompetence. African Americans who follow the law and well educated experience such unfairness as well.
One can wrap their mind around it because you don't have to live the life that others are subject to the day they are born.Could just as much ask why 'all lives matter' activists get triggered when black lives matter is brought up.
We are at a dinner party, and everyone but you gets desert.
you say "Hey, where's my desert? My desert matters."
I turn to you and say, "All our deserts matter."
Black lives matter is not an attempt to elevate one group above the others, it is drawing attention to the fact that one group has been ignored, left out and oppressed while others have not had the same experience.
You may well not have owned a slave, or sent a black person to the back of the bus or to the other water fountain, or personally oppressed them. But you HAVE benefited from a society built on their blood. The society owes a debt, that begins by acknowledging it.For the past several years, we've been hammered by social groups that we should be inclusive of ALL people. OK, so now when we say something inclusive, like "All lives matter", somehow that's wrong?
The BLM group is an extremely selfish organization whose goals are to invoke Socialism on everything they touch. They CLAIM it's about systemic racism, but that's FAR from the truth. Why? Because so many of the people pushing BLM have made, and still do make, extremely racist comments.
The REAL truth is no matter how much you try, you will NEVER remove racism - ever! And... EVERY race on this planet harbors a group of people who ARE some of the most racist people you can imagine! What's worse though is that it seems EVERYTHING is pointed as racist. The sky is blue - you can't say that, its racist! That car is a Ford - you can't say that, it's racist!
Grow up and ditch the garbage of BLM, because ALL of our lives matter!“You sayin’ All Lives Matter is a protest to my protest, what kinda shit is that?”
-Joyner Lucas
The real question is: why are people so uncomfortable with just acknowledging that black lives matter (the overall sentiment, not necessarily the participants that comprise BLM) without having to counter it, or have to say it with some sort of add-on, or just make it about white people in some way? Literally all that’s being asked of you is to basically say that you give a shit about the treatment of black folks, and that you either understand the prejudicial treatment they face, or are willing to listen and accept what they tell you about THEIR experiences, and not just dismissing it and being like “nahhhh, that’s not your experience...” What is so difficult about that? I don’t think these are liberal sentiments I hold, I’m apolitical, it’s just about not being an asshole and having some fucking awareness.Cause idiots? And it should just be basic human rights matter cause we are all human no matter the race.
"Black lives matter" so only black lives have had racism towards and human rights taken away from "well no" okay so don't just call it black lives matter cause that makes it sound like only black have been treated bad. And no don't say "black lives matter stands for all" cause it legit just say's "black" don't exclude your own race into a statement to stand for something that means all races.
imagine if someone said "all white lives matter" but meant that as all races. Smh it don't work.
And no it don't distract from the main issue, cause the issue is peoples rights are stepped on for many reasons and it needs to be stopped. And it's not just black people who gets there's stepped on due to racism.It's not that hard to figure out. There are a lot of excuses (surprise, right?) but it means exactly what you think it means. They don't care about anyone else's lives.
Deeper than that, they don't even really care about black lives. They care about capitalizing on black deaths. And of course, they use shaming tactics constantly, so after pushing aside everyone else's importance, they shame others into helping them.
If only the Democrats we elected into power positions, who've been promising to help the black community for decades, had actually followed through with their empty words, we wouldn't be here now.
The irony of it all.They get triggered because saying "All Lives Matter" kind of disregards the situation at hand, as black lives are being the most effected by injustice, profiling, and oppression. Yes, all lives matter, but right now we should focus on the black lives that are suffering.
From pure logic "all lives matter" includes "black lives matter", however in the current situation it shifts the priority too far away from the problems.
Its like saying "sick people need hospitals" or "all people need hospitals", both statements are right but the sick poeple need hospitals NOW and not in general.
At least thats how i understand it.All lives do matter, but most of the people who say "All Lives Matter" say that only in response to "Black Lives Matter." When someone says "Blue Lives Matter" those people just nod in agreement. They basically dismiss the concerns of people of color. I'm a white guy whose best male friend is from Trinidad and Tobago. His family is wealthy and he REGULARLY get pulled over while driving the speed limit in his expensive cars. Why? It is clearly a case of DWB - driving while black. No other explanation. Whether you all want to admit it or not, there are problems out there and solutions are needed.
What I don’t get is why is the BLM Is cramming their beliefs down the entire American population’s throat when they should be working WITH the police. Like seriously, if you want change, you gotta grab that bull by the horns.
I’d be more inclined to support BLM but I don’t see them doing much to promote sustainable change.
Also, I don’t know if anyone noticed but a few policemen have been killed during the protests. Where is their justice?Because they know exactly why you're saying it...
Your type aren't brave enough to say what you want to say... but you're not clever enough to see the huge gap in your deception
Obviously brown lives don't matter since you were fine caging children.
Blue lives don't matter since you guys cried and raged about armor-piercing bullets being restricted... hmmmm why? Criminals don't wear armor... but police and the military do
considering your insecurity and disdain for women, looks like Women's lives don't matter either
don't pretend to care just because you're cstill too cowardly to say that only White Male lives matter to youCause not every life matters I mean there are murderers rapist looters. Let's get real people some lives matter more than others and some would be better if they were not exist
"Black lives matter" is not worthy of consideration. They operate under false pretenses and don't actually work to improve black lives in a realistic or pragmatic way because they'd rather protest white people and the silly notion that the police are the US gestapo.
Questions like these make it seem as if they're a legitimate organization making a positive difference in the world.We need more people like David Clark
https://www.youtube.com/embed/tCibKUTdrTQBLM is a racist black extremist group accusing cops of racism when there is actually no racism. There’s no evidence that racism led to the deaths of Eric garner , Trayvon martin , George flyod And many others
https://m.facebook.com/story.php?story_fbid=676224299590951&id=153657598048710All lives matter is used to counter BLM and what it stands for. I don't understand why people act like they don't know this. BLM doesn't imply that no one else matters. So why do people keep acting as if it does? And using the "You're racist if you don't support all lives matter" argument is just as stupid as the "You're a fascist if you dont support Antifa". Yeah bro, I do think everyone's life matters and I hate fascism, but I don't support your movement because I think it's fucking stupid.
Because you’re missing the point.
Saying Black Lives Matter does not imply that other lives don’t matter.
But we can’t really say “All lives matter” until black people are treated the same in society and we do something to fix systematic racism.
If you think all lives matter then you should be upset at the treatment of black people in this country.Yes all lives matter. But TODAY, black lives are the ones that matter. They are the ones that are currently being affected. The whole movement started to support black lives, to get them justice. (especially for george floyd.) Therefore, saying all lives matter right now, does not allow for the justice the world is trying to achieve right now to happen.
We don’t get “triggered”. It’s because everyone knows All lives matter. But when people only use that argument when we say black lives matter, it’s like they don’t want to focus on the big picture. If your house was on fire and you needed help with that, how would you feel if a neighbor who’s house was fine said “well all houses matter.”?
Learn more
We're glad to see you liked this post.
You can also add your opinion below!
Most Helpful Opinions