If Black people could have their own land and country do you think they would be better off there than in the USA?

Question

I know people will say black people have Africa.

Well to be honest the amount of black people leaving Africa in boats trying to get to Europe is a lot.
If you gave black people their own nation to run and build where no white people were allowed. As they typically state in BLM protest.
I wonder how their all black nation and country would end up as. A typical African country run by a dictator with black people separated into their ethnic tribes running into one another towns with machetes hacking people to death.
Then again I'm just going by what Africa does but that was the white people fault right?

ChubbyKing · Accepted Answer

It would run fine. Look up the 1921 Tulsa Race Massacre. Contrary to what many whites believe, post slavery blacks did try to build themselves up, they were shot (literally) down. Have you ever heard the phrase "Create the problem, sell the solution"? Well it wouldn't be too long after you'd see the Democratic party now making false promises to aid blacks. I think it started with FDR back in the 1930s. This trend of false promises to keep the black community voting Democrat has continued for decades. It took till Trump for someone in the fed to actually make strides toward police reform for example. I think a lot of whites have this ideology that everything was peachy after slavery was abolished, like there wasn't constant push to hold other races (not just blacks) back.

I digress, there are many prominent and capable African American leaders who would be able to run a black nation. In all honesty, I think it would put blacks in a better situation. One of the biggest plagues on the black community is things like crime and gang activity. These issues aee bred by poverty, poverty created by an old vicious cycle, of like I said, "create the problem, sell the solution" and systemic oppression. Those issues would most certainly be looked into with more detail under black leadership and dealt with swiftly. It's not a very hard problem to solve actually.

TyroneJones · Accepted Answer

I mean, we kinda do have Africa still. I think we would be better off in USA as we already have a large presence and influence here. Many artists are Black, most athletes are Black, many actors are Black, many celebrities are Black, many politicians are Black, etc. If we can maintain and control our power and influence in America, maybe one day we can have reverse racism on the whites and have a reverse Jim Crow on them and make them sit at the back of the bus instead of us, or even have them pick cotton for us. LOL!

Anonymous · Accepted Answer

If Black people could have their own land and country do you think they would be better off there than in the USA?

My cousin lent me his DVD of the uncut version of "Tears of the Sun."
The movie was about a group of Navy SEALS whose mission was to find and retrieve a a doctor who was part of the "Doctors Without Borders" organization.

She was working deep in the jungles of Nigeria to help people who were being hacked to death by Marxist rebels.

The SEALS orders were to extract her (against her will) and get her safely to the Cameroon border, where she would be airlifted to safety.

The SEALS orders were to NOT engage the rebels, unless fired upon. In one scene the SEALS just had to sit on the hilltop and look down as the rebels were murdering women and children with machetes. It was the hardest thing they ever had to watch.

In the uncut version of the movie... this guy says:

"Thank God for slavery." (He was referring to himself and how lucky he was to be an American) Of course that scene was cut from the final movie, but I'll never forget what a powerful statement that was. To me, he was saying: "Slavery sucked shit and never should have happened; but slicing up women and children with a machetes shouldn't happen, either.

Bee-Hatch · Accepted Answer

I'm assuming you're talking about carving up a country and making a part of it for separate groups. If we look at history. That doesn't solve the problem. Ireland, India and Israel all ended up that way through people just carving up the map.
Ireland resulted in a bloody civil war for decades that still continues
India the genocides on both sides are still not widely talked about.
Israel is still under regular attacks and war crimes.
What makes more sense is trying to work together.

Lazi-boi · Answer

There are awesome African nations like Botswana that are safer than a lot of cities in America and full of hard working diciplined people.

Most black people in America seem to be a lost causez raised by single moms.

I'd live in Botswana before I move to New York

KrakenAttackin · Answer

Within a week there would be tires burning at every intersection, SUV's turned into "technicals", and a war lord mentality would reign supreme.

There would be no use in the victim mentality and a brutal hirearchy would be instilled and enforced.

SmokinAces2000 · Answer

We did have our own land called “Black Wallstreet” which was extremely successful until white mobs “literally” burned it all down. The citizens in Black Wallstreet were thriving and arguably doing better than most white citizens outside the community so maybe if it hadn’t been destroyed black people would be better off.

ThatNoUVAtYourEyes · Answer

They would not be better off anywhere.
Most of them are tiny headed idiots - it isn't colour specific, look at Indians and what they are capable of producing as their living conditions.
Small headed Chinese are just the same (Africa and China have larger headed people too, even if few, India barely any)

DWornock · Answer

They would do worse because they have lower average IQs. Therefore, blacks are not capable of managing as well as whites and Asians in a world with high technology.

anylolone · Answer

Have you seen africa? They could if they did the right thing. They keep not doing it.

rcljr · Answer

Most African Americans have never been to Africa.

SamFromFL · Answer

Define a black person

888theGreat · Answer

No , and they do. Look at South Africa now

Anonymous · Answer

they have an entire continent.

ItsMeItsMe1989 · Answer

it's called africa

Anonymous · Answer

It's called Africa

If Black people could have their own land and country do you think they would be better off there than in the USA?

Most Helpful Opinions

What Girls & Guys Said

Should we give black people sovereign land like Native Americans?

If Black people could have their own land and country do you think they would be better off there than in the USA?

Most Helpful Opinions

What Girls & Guys Said

Should we give black people sovereign land like Native Americans?

We're glad to see you liked this post.