Should IS (Islamic State) get their own country?

[PrettyRegular]

This is a very random question that just came to my mind. It could be beneficial if the Islamic extremists would be in one country. Also maybe having to run their own country would make them less radical, because they'd have to be more responsible. Also it would be easier to have an eye on them that they don't do anything crazy, if they're in one place.

[Anonymous]

No absolutely not. There are many examples also that even after getting their own control over a land they are no good. They are that brainwashed creatures who wants to follow so called "Allah words" without using their own brain that this is wrong. They can't be responsible like normal people but they are just brainwashed to run like a robot as per Quranic verse where it is written that to spread Islam in whole world to fight with kaafir (non muslim) to keep slaves, to beat wives. How they can be so called responsible like this? Also their goal is to spread Islam in whole world so they are not going to stop themselves in their own land but they will be making themselves for opportunity using that land as base to attack on other countries to have control and implement shariya (islamic law) everywhere. And that means killing of kaafirs, beating of wives, normalising slavery again.

[Cheerfull009]

Read my comment, answer to your comment

[Opinion Owner]

No that's not the answer. You are seeing their world their mentality from their own perspective. Do you know the real reason behind why they are as they are now? Have you ever seen inside their brains? Once upon a time I also was very much curious about all this why this happens why they does so what they do etc. But now after lot of research and observations I know very well what goes inside their brain and when I knew I was surprised myself with my findings. So whatever I'm saying it's not just empty words but words because of a reason research and observations.

[Siri137]

Hell no. They don't deserve anything at all, except a kick in the nuts and a missile down their chimney.

[Cheerfull009]

Muslim Talban of Afghanistan have fucked and kicked out so called super power, America along its coward allies in August, 2021, search on Google, if you don't know

[Siri137]

@Cheerfull009 The Taliban, as awful as they are, are not ISIS though. And they've kicked out at least three superpowers - the British Empire, the USSR, and the United States.

[Cheerfull009]

@siri137, thank you, I am at neighbor, so I know all the history of Afghanistan and about brave people of Afghanistan

[Anonymous]

First off. Most middleeastern countries are predominantly Muslim. So they do have an Islamic state. If those gov'ts are not administering to that demographic then you need to take that up with them gov'ts. If You're referring to Palastine, then there is NO right or easy answer to this. Because Israel isn't really going to cede any land really to a Palestinian state. And the Palestinians will never be ok with even an inch of an Israeli state. So there's always going to be strife here.

[PrettyRegular]

IS are a very specific type of radical Muslims and they would just execute everybody else, including Muslims. I didn't mean Palestine, but they legally own Gaza, East Jerusalem and the West Bank. Also most of them have accepted Israel existing. If Israel keeps oppressing them and building more illegal settlements to West Bank, they just turn the world against them even further. I think one state solution with equal rights for everybody might be too optimistic, but two states is far better than Israel occupying also Palestinian territories and having an apartheid system against them.

[Opinion Owner]

I agree with you for the most part. But the radicals will not let that happen. If this was an insurgency that could be quelled as conditions improved for all I'd agree. But since this ideological I don't see that happening. But, I hope your right. And eye for an eye leaves everybody blind.

[deus_ex_sisyphus]

The thing about countries is that land is finite; for one to be gain, another must lose. So suggesting one would gain without another losing is speaking in platitudes. You are not going to find anyone who wants to give up their land / heritage in exchange for nothing, let alone enough to make up an entire country and the supplies needed to kickstart that effort.

[_piotr]

No. They will use the land as a base to gather forces and attack other countries. Their goal is to have sharia law all over the world. This will give them a sense of victory and radicalise them even further.

[Dargil]

Like Hamas-Palestinians, they have so national vision. All they want to do is commit murder and mayhem. Ditto Hezb' Allah and Islamic Jihad. The KURDS should have their own state.

[Drewtate]

If they had their own country it would be a base to conduct worldwide terror attacks

[Cheerfull009]

@Drewtate Muslims are second largest in the world do you know

[Cheerfull009]

It is possible, if USA and other non Muslim countries, stop occoping Muslim Oil and other resources, stop genocide and destroying their infrastructure, as did in Iraq, Libya Syria, Afghanistan and in Palestine

[Curmudgeon]

That's what Iran is, isn't it?

[Siri137]

No, it is not. Iran is Shia, not Sunni. ISIS are Sunni, and consider the Shia to be heretics worthy of extermination.

[Curmudgeon]

@Siri137 True, there are more factions of extremists, and Iran is the Shia one.

[PrettyRegular]

IS are radical terrorists who want to kill everybody else. Iran is a conservative muslim country, but not extremist. Biggest reason why they're seen on bad light in the West and why they're heavily sanctioned is that they're against USA interests.

[Siri137]

Exactly. And they oppose Israel as well, the country that controls the US government.

[strateguy632]

at the expense of others? no way!

[slatyb]

They already have several countries.

[OtterMan68]

where would it be?

[PrettyRegular]

I was thinking some relatively small unhabited desert area from middle-East. Other countries could even pay for the land to the country/countries currently having it.

[OtterMan68]

if Turkey, Iraq, & Syria haven't given land to the Kurds for the past 100 years, I don't see anyone giving land to IS

[ellefia]

Why should Türkiye give land to the Kurds?

[OtterMan68]

@ellefia same reason England gave up claims to Ireland

[Anonymous]

I agree good idea

[Opinion Owner]

@prettyregular message me. I want to discuss something