• Discover
    See what’s happening on Girls Ask Guys now!
  • AI Personas
    AI Influencers answer your questions!
  • Popular
    Check out the most interesting ones of the day.
  • Questions
    Share your opinions on the questions.
  • myTakes
    Discover myTakes that may interest you.
  • Polls
    Vote on the polls, set the agenda.
  • Top Members
    See top members and meet the community!
  • Contact
  • Terms of Use
  • Privacy Policy
  • Guidelines
  • Tags
  • All Questions
Google Play Apple Store
Topics (23) All
  • HolidaysHolidays
  • Girl's BehaviorGirl's Behavior
  • Guy's BehaviorGuy's Behavior
  • FlirtingFlirting
  • DatingDating
  • RelationshipsRelationships
  • Fashion & BeautyFashion & Beauty
  • Health & FitnessHealth & Fitness
  • Marriage & WeddingsMarriage & Weddings
  • Shopping & GiftsShopping & Gifts
  • Technology & InternetTechnology & Internet
  • Break Up & DivorceBreak Up & Divorce
  • Education & CareerEducation & Career
  • Entertainment & ArtsEntertainment & Arts
  • Family & FriendsFamily & Friends
  • Food & BeverageFood & Beverage
  • Hobbies & LeisureHobbies & Leisure
  • OtherOther
  • Religion & SpiritualityReligion & Spirituality
  • Society & PoliticsSociety & Politics
  • SportsSports
  • Travel Travel
  • Trending & NewsTrending & News
Discover
Community of trusted and anonymous friends where girls and guys help each other.
A good descriptive title will get more attention. Min 15, Max 150 characters.
Add Details You can add more details, ask anonymously and change the settings for your question below.
0 / 150
Log In / Sign Up
Topics(23)
All
  • Holidays Holidays
  • Girl's Behavior Girl's Behavior
  • Guy's Behavior Guy's Behavior
  • Flirting Flirting
  • Dating Dating
  • Relationships Relationships
  • Fashion & Beauty Fashion & Beauty
  • Health & Fitness Health & Fitness
  • Marriage & Weddings Marriage & Weddings
  • Shopping & Gifts Shopping & Gifts
  • Technology & Internet Technology & Internet
  • Break Up & Divorce Break Up & Divorce
  • Education & Career Education & Career
  • Entertainment & Arts Entertainment & Arts
  • Family & Friends Family & Friends
  • Food & Beverage Food & Beverage
  • Hobbies & Leisure Hobbies & Leisure
  • Other Other
  • Religion & Spirituality Religion & Spirituality
  • Society & Politics Society & Politics
  • Sports Sports
  • Travel Travel
  • Trending & News Trending & News
Fashion & Beauty Health & Fitness Marriage & Weddings Shopping & Gifts Technology & Internet +17
Society & Politics

Do you consider Napoleon a dictator?

Julie4
Julie4 Follow
Explorer Age: 28
Follow
Facebook
Twitter
WhatsApp
03
Tell me what preconceived ideas you have about him
Do you consider Napoleon a dictator?
Do you consider Napoleon a dictator?
Post Opinion
Like
Share
Follow
3 likes
What is your opinion?
What is your opinion?
Add Opinion
Superb Opinion
  • Lliam
    Lliam Follow
    Master Age: 71 , mho 52%
    1 y
    5.6K opinions shared on Society & Politics topic.

    I'm not an expert, but I don't think so. An emperor isn't necessarily a dictator.

    After the French Revolution which overthrew the monarchy, Robespierre essentially became a dictator and led the nearly year long "reign of terror". Napoleon and his allies overthrew the French Directory government and created the French Consulate. He brought political stability to a land torn by revolution and war. He created a civil code that advocated for many liberal policies, such as the abolition of feudalism, the freedom of religion, and the creation of a central bank.

    The French adored him and voted overwhelmingly for him as emperor.

    1
    0 Reply

Most Helpful Opinions

  • RavVid
    RavVid Follow
    Master Age: 32
    1 y
    2K opinions shared on Society & Politics topic.

    He was a dictator for a period. I can't rattle off the exact events but at about the overthrow of Robespierre without checking.

    But then he became Emperor and that is entirely different. I'm not sure why I think that but it is influenced by my view of the Australian Monarchy.

    0
    2 Reply
    • Julie4
      Julie4
      1 y

      It is safe to say that Napoleon was not a democrat, but as the historian explains, he was not a dictator either. Moreover, there were counter-powers, which were admittedly rather weak during Napoleon's reign of power, but it was these counter-powers that forced Napoleon to abdicate in 1815.

      Reply
    • RavVid
      RavVid
      1 y

      True.

      Reply
  • CupcakeTheDestroyer
    CupcakeTheDestroyer Follow
    Master Age: 32 , mho 62%
    1 y
    1.8K opinions shared on Society & Politics topic.

    Not a dictator, but certainly a wannabe conqueror warlord type. He would have been a dictator if he succeeded in permanently widening France’s borders before he died.

    0
    0 Reply
  • WhitneySnow
    WhitneySnow Follow
    Master Age: 19
    1 y
    998 opinions shared on Society & Politics topic.

    Yeah he was. He was good to the French people (mostly), but his word was law and he conquered a lot of other countries.

    0
    0 Reply
Ask to an AI Persona
All
Travel Buddy
Travel Buddy
I'm your go-to travel companion, passionate about exploring new destinations and experiencing...
Love Doctor Brad
Love Doctor Brad
Welcome to the heart of understanding and transformation. I am your guide on this journey to...
Athletic Chloe
Athletic Chloe
Whether you need tips on improving your game, insights on fitness and nutrition, or just want to...
Fashionista Amy
Fashionista Amy
I'm here to inspire and guide you with a touch of latest trends or advice on personal style.💅👒
Gamer Bella
Gamer Bella
With my passion and experience in hobbies and leisure activities, I'm here to offer personalized...
Cinematic Lily
Cinematic Lily
With my rich background and passion for the arts, I share insights on films, TV shows, and...
Advisor Smith
Advisor Smith
With years of experience guiding individuals in their education and career paths, I'm here to...
James The Foodie
James The Foodie
From savoring Italian classics to discovering the bold flavors of Japanese cuisine, I explore...

What Girls & Guys Said

3

Opinion

14

Opinion

  • RebelinSteel m
    RebelinSteel Follow
    Guru Age: 31 , mho 40%
    1 y

    A person who could have brought great change to France and entered into a peaceful internal rebuilding of the republic, however he took the aggressive route and as they say, met his waterloo.

    0
    6 Reply
    • Julie4
      Julie4
      1 y

      He changed France

      Reply
    • RebelinSteel m
      RebelinSteel
      1 y

      Yes agreed he changed it, however he got too ambitious and wanted the world. Things went down hill after that really.

      Reply
    • Julie4
      Julie4
      1 y

      No, he didn't want the whole world.

      Reply
    • Julie4
      Julie4
      1 y

      Did you know about these statements and Napoleon's geopolitical "forecasts" for Russia, the USA and the UK, and what do you think? ↗

      Reply
    • RebelinSteel m
      RebelinSteel
      1 y

      Yes I read it, a good question, some accurate some not so. One of the reasons around the unification of Germany was the Prussians needing the full might of Germany to balance against Poland and Russia. The Greater Poland uprising and the pretty much defeat of Prussia by the French and Poles, did not go down well in Prussia. The British have always viewed the Russians as an enemy, the great game was how most of it was played out. Both the French and British were very quick to get involved with the Crimean war.

      Reply
    • Julie4
      Julie4
      1 y

      No they haven't always considered the Russians as an enemy, that's not how geopolitics works, there are no eternal allies or enemies in geopolitics, only interests are.

      You can see from these statements that Napoleon didn't want the world. Which wouldn't even make sense.

      You seem to be mentioning things here that Napoleon doesn't mention in the texts I mentioned.

      Reply
  • loveslongnails
    loveslongnails Follow
    Master Age: 40
    1 y
    5.1K opinions shared on Society & Politics topic.

    He was a narcissistic little shit. Don't try and rewrite history.

    0
    9 Reply
    • Julie4
      Julie4
      1 y

      You're the one trying to rewrite history here.

      Reply
    • loveslongnails
      loveslongnails
      1 y

      Right... he wasn't a tyrant and a dictator. Uh huh. Whatever his "good qualities" were, I stand by my statement: "He was a narcissistic little shit". By little, I don't mean short. The myth that he was barely over 5 feet tall has been debunked for a long time. Historians now believe he was about 5'6 or 5'7", which was tall enough for his day. Next thing you're going to try and sell me is what - how great George Washington was?

      Reply
    • Julie4
      Julie4
      1 y

      How was he a dictator? Please be specific

      Reply
    • loveslongnails
      loveslongnails
      1 y

      I don't have time for this, girl.

      Reply
    • Julie4
      Julie4
      1 y

      Just say you don't have arguments

      Reply
    • loveslongnails
      loveslongnails
      1 y

      Do you know how read books? Go blow this snow at the DOZENS of historians who have written about him. I'm not wasting my time arguing about whether or not an authoritarian military regime was "technically" a dictatorship, nor do I care. Have a good night.

      Reply
    • Julie4
      Julie4
      1 y

      It's precisely because I've read historians, and even exchanged with some of them.

      The problem here is that you're unable to explain why Napoleon was a dictator.

      Reply
    • loveslongnails
      loveslongnails
      1 y

      No, the problem is that you want to argue over technicalities and I don't. Your exchanges with historians have not changed your mind, and your explanations will not change mine. Therefore, while I'm perfectly ABLE to explain my viewpoint, I don't care to debate with you! I answered your post's question. Yes, hell yes, I consider him a dictator and I already told you why. So again, have a good night.

      Reply
    • Julie4
      Julie4
      1 y

      Historians, and in particular the historian Thierry Lentz, with whom I had the opportunity to exchange views, have written

      "To speak of dictatorship, and military dictatorship, is to mock the meaning of words. The army was not in charge, and counter-powers remained.

      "At no point were you able to explain to me why Napoleon was a dictator. That's all I'll remember here.

      Oh yes, good night to you too

      Reply
  • RyanEC
    RyanEC Follow
    Guru Age: 35
    1 y
    465 opinions shared on Society & Politics topic.

    I would say yes but he provided better leadership than the tumultuous governments that proceeded him in France.

    0
    0 Reply
  • RedInnocent69
    RedInnocent69 Follow
    Guru Age: 49
    1 y
    1.5K opinions shared on Society & Politics topic.

    Yes. They’re not preconceived. Is this some sort of Trumpnapologist question?

    0
    3 Reply
    • Julie4
      Julie4
      1 y

      I care very little about Mr. Trump. And to speak of dictatorship is to mock the meaning of words, as historian Thierry Lentz wrote.

      Reply
    • RedInnocent69
      RedInnocent69
      1 y

      So, only a Napoleon apologist, then?

      Reply
    • Julie4
      Julie4
      1 y

      No, I've read the historians

      Reply
  • OtterMan68
    OtterMan68 Follow
    Yoda Age: 57
    1 y
    1.3K opinions shared on Society & Politics topic.

    yes, he could not be overruled by any legislative or judicial branch

    0
    0 Reply
  • Iron_Man s
    Iron_Man Follow
    Mentor Age: 46
    1 y
    10.1K opinions shared on Society & Politics topic.

    you’re the one that lives in France, you tell me

    0
    0 Reply
  • jack1924
    jack1924 Follow
    Xper 6 Age: 35
    1 y

    He has so many mental issues that what I know

    0
    0 Reply
  • Titus_of_Ultramar
    Titus_of_Ultramar Follow
    Xper 2 Age: 21
    1 y

    He was one for a while though he technically was an emperor

    0
    0 Reply
  • Mettbltt
    Mettbltt Follow
    Xper 6 Age: 20
    1 y

    Of course he is a dictator

    0
    2 Reply
    • Julie4
      Julie4
      1 y

      No lol

      Reply
    • Mettbltt
      Mettbltt
      1 y

      Although he was seen as an oppressive and violent dictator at the time, he also established some constitutional rights.
      but still dictator

      Reply
  • legalboxers
    legalboxers Follow
    Master Age: 49
    1 y

    Yes. Also makes a good ice cream

    0
    0 Reply
  • purplepoppy
    purplepoppy Follow
    Master Age: 25 , mho 53%
    1 y
    6.4K opinions shared on Society & Politics topic.

    Evil warmonger

    0
    0 Reply
  • Anonymous
    Anonymous
    (36-45)
    1 y

    No, he was an emperor.

    0
    0 Reply
  • bellissimoe
    bellissimoe Follow
    Xper 1 Age: 22
    1 y

    Yeaahh

    0
    3 Reply
    • Julie4
      Julie4
      1 y

      Why?

      Reply
    • bellissimoe
      bellissimoe
      1 y

      Because he arrested the Pope and took him away from Rome

      Reply
    • Julie4
      Julie4
      1 y

      The Pope has forgiven

      Reply
  • Walksbehindtherows
    Walksbehindtherows Follow
    Xper 6 Age: 22
    1 y

    Yes like that

    0
    0 Reply
  • msc545
    msc545 Follow
    Master Age: 38
    1 y
    10.2K opinions shared on Society & Politics topic.

    sort of yes,.

    0
    0 Reply
  • Timetraveleryy
    Timetraveleryy Follow
    Xper 1 Age: 31
    1 y

    Yes definitely

    0
    1 Reply
    • Julie4
      Julie4
      1 y

      Why?

      Reply
  • TheCaller
    TheCaller Follow
    Xper 4 Age: 20
    1 y

    Yeah

    0
    0 Reply
Show More(12)
Click "Show More" for your mentions
Home > Society & Politics > Questions > Do you consider Napoleon a dictator?
Add your reply For "{0}"
Most Helpful Opinion(mho) Rate.
Learn more

We're glad to see you liked this post.

You can also add your opinion below!

Related Questions

Is Napoleon comparable to Hitler? You know Napoleon, but have you heard of Napoleon III? Have you ever heard of Napoleon III? Do you see Vladimir Putin as a dictator? Do you consider Donald J. Trump to be a Dictator or the President of the United States?
Popular Questions
  • Girls, What are the Ways for Men to Say They Care About You?
  • My boyfriend follows random girls on Instagram, should I be worried?
  • Girls what does the 😌 emoji mean?
  • How do I ask for a girl's Instagram?
  • "How Do You Feel About Me?" Best Answers to This Situation!
  • Do guys really like girls with thick thighs?
  • Girls, What Makes a Man Fall Deeply in Love With a Woman?
  • What does the date under "Hey there I am using Whatsapp" Status mean?
  • What's a good comeback when someone jokingly calls you old?
  • When a girls says "I'll let you know" what does it mean?
Recent Questions
  • Where HAVE all the cowboys gone?
  • How would you describe 2025 for you in a few words?
  • What do you think will happen for you in 2026?
  • What’s the movie that you think is so bad, but you enjoy it anyway?
  • How safe is aircraft travel today?
  • A pastor I watched said God does not always reveal his method because limitation increases Faith. Thoughts?
  • Do you know this FAMILY?
  • What’s the strangest road sign you’ve seen?
  • What Christmas gifts have you gotten so far?
  • Is cheese the answer?
  • Help
  • Contact
  • Terms Of Use
  • Guidelines
  • Privacy Policy
  • Sitemap
  • Featured Questions
  • Topics
Popular Topics
Dating Education & Career Entertainment & Arts Flirting Food & Beverage Girl's Behavior Guy's Behavior Health & Fitness Relationships Technology & Internet
Girls Ask Guys
©2025 GirlsAskGuys ™
Apple Store Google Play
Join with {0}
Loading...