IS IT FAIR that transgender swimmer Lia Thomas competed in (& won) a Division I collegiate national championship against biological/cisgender females?

[Anonymous]

Reference articles:
https://www.msn.com/en-us/sports/more-sports/penn-swimmer-lia-thomas-is-a-national-champion-in-the-500-yard-freestyle/ar-AAVdfRX

https://www.inquirer.com/sports/lia-thomas-penn-swimmer-trans-athletes-rights-20220214.html

A - Yes — Because: “[Lia] has fulfilled all eligibility requirements [and] should be allowed to compete” against biological/cisgender females

B - Yes — Because of another reason

C - Yes — Because both answer options A & B are true

D - Other — I don’t have an opinion on this, or something else

E - No — Because: “Trans women who begin their medical transition after puberty will always retain some physical advantages” over biological/cisgender female competitors

F - No — Because of another reason

G - No — Because both answer options E & F are true

Updates

+1 y

For those who provide/have provided an opinion, please also cast a vote in the poll

[Anonymous]

I'm glad I'm not into sports. It would suck to work your ass off at something you are passionate about—and then actually win—just for your victory to be taken by people who don't even care about the sport and used as an example of why people like you are ruining it and shouldn't be allowed to compete. Damn.

[Anonymous]

"She" has a penis and testicles. How is that fair to compete as a woman?

[elizamichale1]

I think it is pretty fair tbh

[TheFlak38]

Totally fair. I support tranny men competing with women to destroy their sports. Women are always the first ones to push for degeneracy until they become victims of it. So no, let tranny men compete with women.

[notwoke]

the fact that this is even occurring tells you how fucked the world is. I'm glad I'm old

[Asker]

Are you the 1 G-vote that’s currently out there?
…if so, what’s the “other No reason”?

[notwoke]

because its just fucked the hell up and regular people shouldn't be forced to get in the same water (pool) or anything of the sort with these people. I mean come the fuck on