No taxes. Is this supposed to be a bad thing?

Question

Speaking as someone born in the UK where everything is taxed to the hilt and the government gets greedier every year.

contentious · Accepted Answer

Not exactly, but that's kind of the plan... At the federal level you raise revenue through tariffs and eliminate the federal income tax. This means people, but more specifically companies that do business internationally foot the bill for the federal government to maintain diplomatic relationships with other countries and to field an army that can manage disputes with foreign nations rather than normal average Americans who rarely interact with foreign powers. The responsibility to pay is put on those responsible for those foreign interactions. At the state level there is more variability. Local governments manage their own budgets and methods for funding those budgets. So for example in Florida, we already have no state income tax. Currently we are working toward no property tax for residents of Florida on their homestead. You still would have to pay taxes on commercial property, industrial property, and investment residential real estate like second homes, rentals, etc. The burden of taxation is shifted to people generating cash-flow from real estate, rather than placing that burden on people just trying to live. There is also obviously still consumption tax (sale tax). If you participate in commerce, then clearly products need to move through sea ports, on rails, over roads, etc. and all that infrastructure needs to be maintained. So if you buy shit, you are partially responsible for that infrastructure that makes it all possible. Of course there is more to the plan with state chartered credit unions issuing low interest loans to residents of their state to reduce cost of living and promote economic growth, a commodity back currency to act as a store of value which appreciates over time rather than depreciates, tracking of government spending to eliminate fraud and abuse of tax payer dollars, etc.

https://x.com/ReOpenChris/status/1972777499756249231

exitseven · Accepted Answer

President Trump delivered the biggest tax cut in American history. It is aimed to benefit mostly the middle class. Every tax cut that I ever saw always benefitted other groups besides the middle class that pay most of the taxes in America.

No taxes on tips, a big deduction for Social Security and raising the SALT deduction to $40,000 are things that will help the working class and not the rich.

I think that Trump would like to eliminate the IRS and fund the government just on tarriffs. I do not think it is possible but between the tarriffs and cutting government spending we will be in a much better position financially.

Anonymous · Accepted Answer

It's insane if they think Americans are going to pay for the shit that needs to be paid for out of the goodness of their hearts. They're the most vile, egoistic indivuals who walk this earth.

School are going to shut down, streets are going to be shittier than they are now, military is going on a strike.

I so wish they'll get this through so I can see the cesspool they call the United States go to even more shambles than it already is. Let them kick the most vulnerable a little more. Perhaps they'll go on murder spees out of desperation but that is fine, at least they've rights to own guns.

avery58 · Accepted Answer

There should be a balance, and appropriate taxation depending on income with the rich paying more. Where do you think most hospitals, parks, city maintenance and security comes from if not the taxpayer dollar?

What we should do is stop sending so much of American taxpayer money overseas.

AviatorTom · Answer

Doesn't sound bad to me.

Before federal income tax came into existence in 1913 with the 16th amendment to the US Constitution, there was no income tax or inheritance tax, and only limited regulations. Nothing wrong with less government in my book.

Surely · Answer

In a perfect world. No taxes would be a wonderful idea.
Putting the government on a strict diet from spending would be a great start.
Unfortunately. All those things that we need. Like hiways, military, and even parks. Need to be funded by some means.
Maybe Trump’s tariffs?

worldscolide · Answer

I personally see taxation as theft. Especially when we are taxed on money earned, money spent, property we own and so on. We are taxed to fucking death. So yeah less taxes is a good thing.

FreyaRed · Answer

Who pays police, school system and their beloved army that is needed to invade Greenland and Canada soon.

jshm2 · Answer

Of course it's a bad thing, you dolt.

Where the fuck do you think roads, hospitals and the police comes from? Your moms purse?

Taxes pay for every public service and infrastructure. A shutdown halts all new builds and maintenance

Grond21 · Answer

She thinks the government is there to solve all of our problems. Since she views taxation as the lifeblood of the government, this is pure insanity to her.

Med_guy1978 · Answer

Income tax is unconstitutional thus illegal in the US. It was introduced as a temporary war tax in 1916 if I'm not mistaken. Snuck in under the carpet by the same bankster gangsters who privatised the federal reserve in 1913.

DJB72 · Answer

It's a far left thing. They think we can't be trusted with what we earn so under leftist ideology government gets bigger and personal ownership - including accountability - gets stripped away.

Not sure how that's a bad thing.

Joshydavid25 · Answer

Yeah, I don't get what she's trying to say either.. Maybe she thinks her audience is silly enough to see this as a bad thing as it erodes our "dear government"..

strateguy632 · Answer

About update, no, you actually didn’t miss anything. you couldn't understand because she did not make any sense!  She opposed trump and is trying to make up silly reasons.

MannMitAntworten · Answer

Ending of income tax and property tax would make my Life.

Anonymous · Answer

it takes a special kind of idiot to really love taxes

Anonymous · Answer

Joy Reid is a bitter loser. That's not at all what WAGA people want. She's just fear mongering and hate mongering, which is the only thing the left is capable of doing anymore.

FunkyMonkee · Answer

No! It's SUPPOSED to be what the country was built on!! No taxation without representation!! Legally, you don't HAVE to pay taxes in America!! There's NO LAW that says you HAVE to pay taxes!!

Anonymous · Answer

I don’t think she’s doing a good job of making MAGA sound bad

Anonymous · Answer

We need to eliminate the income tax and property tax

Anonymous · Answer

She's trying to deceive people into believing that good conservative values are a bad thing. Not having an Income Tax would certainly be a proper constitutional thing

red-lipstick-girl · Answer

You're in England and you're complaining, pray girl. Everyone's unhappy in my country. My country is the worst country.

Sevenpointfive · Answer

it sounds like they want to go back to medieval times?

slatyb · Answer

It would be a bad thing because vital government services would be discontinued.

Anonymous · Answer

Because people want to be paid to exist Overpopulation requires culling

Sal_Monella · Answer

Joy Reid is full of bovine excrement of all "races" from Brahma to Angus. And that's her strong point.

beefcakebradybatson · Answer

That's called dystopian H**l for the 99.99999% and Heaven for the overlords, which Trump and his despicable lemmings desire.

Hispanic-Cool-Guy · Answer

How are things supposed to be funded?  Taxes are a need for a country.

Guanfei · Answer

Well, no taxes means no public services.

KostasKouvalis · Answer

Sounds great to me

shortster · Answer

Don't threaten me with a good time

seeyounexttuesday · Answer

She's the greatest advertisement for MAGA.

msc545 · Answer

No public services, no armed forces.

Bklynbadboy12 · Answer

That is a bad thing

IamRight · Answer

Sounds good

No taxes. Is this supposed to be a bad thing?

Most Helpful Opinions

What Girls & Guys Said

Should non resident people living in America stop paying income Tax?

No taxes. Is this supposed to be a bad thing?

Most Helpful Opinions

What Girls & Guys Said

Should non resident people living in America stop paying income Tax?

We're glad to see you liked this post.