Girls: Do you prefer your men Muscular or Athletic?

Football player type for sure.

haha I think football lol but not like the chunky football players lol haha just nice muscular backs =]]]]]]]]]]]]]] hahah and arms and make sure you have nice v lines hahaha those are bomb, haha and legs.

I like both, but mainly muscular football players. I LOVE FOOTBALL PLAYERS, I'd date the whole team.

Interesting question. Well, I would prefer if a guy was slim, but not a bone. Lets just say, he can't be skinnier than me. lol. But as for muscles, it doesn't really matter to me. He can be tall, slim and "in shape" but not some huge macho man. I know this may sound weird, but I don't really like guys that are all muscle bound. Just normal is fine with me. lol. Maybe I am just weird, everyone else seems to like muscle. lol.

I prefer athletic and lean.

Athletic for me. My boyfriend is 5'11" and built like a tennis or soccer player and I absolutely love his body.

i like them both. football players have nice butts.

I would go for either but I'd prefer musclar. One problem is though were a girl has mentioned before is too much muscles. That is the bigest turn off to me ever.Better being toned up with some muscles nothing like a body builder or even close. I'd prefer to feel the muscles rather than see them if that makes sense

I'm definitely into athletic over super muscular. I guess I still have that stereotype of thicker "football guys" being not too interesting/intelligent (bad stereotype, I know!) and so it's actually kind of a turn-off for me. What attracts me is someone with strong (but not huge) arms and who is somewhat lean (but not lanky). Someone who keeps fit, but doesn't look like they spend two hrs at the gym every day.

athletic all the way but you def want some muscle and definition. and 5 11 is a good height

Hmmm. Personally, both sound great to me!
But if you're looking to attract chicks, I think the 'muscular' appearance will work more to your advantage. Girls like when those big, strong arms wrap around them and make them feel safe. Plus big muscles are excellent to look at. Just don't go overboard. There is such a thing as TOO muscular. Bleh. It sounds like you're aware of that though.