If you are getting fired from your job , would you argue with them or just accept and leave?

Question

sage2021 · Accepted Answer

Last time I was getting fired, I told the lady to "Just save it" and I picked up my purse and wasled out. Went to the unemployment office a few days later with some notes she would leave on my desk for me about what a pleasure I am to work with, that I am such a good worker and collected unemployment money for a few months.

laly520 · Accepted Answer

would leave

DoggyDude · Answer

I would both accept it and leave AND debate the point legally.

Firstly, I wouldn't let them pull any crap, if what they where claiming is untrue I would make sure letters where written and emails sent proving how wrong they where.

Secondly, unless they became quite contrite, quite soon (meaning a level of reversal or appology) I would leave even if they later accepted they where wrong (as I would not wish to stay with such a company).

If though, they overturned their decision before it became official (e. g. brought me in to speak about a potential issue which might lead to my being let go) and they accepted my counter evidence and didn't persue it. I would be willing to be the bigger man and let it slide.

Hope that helps.

ps. It's way easier for me to do that in a civilised country where the law is a mediator than in say the USA where money is king. Since in the USA it's about who has the money to defend themselves, rather than whos right. If I was forced to work in the US, I'd just post a rebuttal to the claims with coworkers and HR. Make them give me a signed declaration of receipt of the proof, and then just quit myself. America may be great at some things, but fairness in employment ain't one of them.

electromagnetic · Answer

I wanna know why I’m getting fired because odds are, the only reason I would be id because I effed up somewhere and if that’s the case, I’d have quit on the spot before getting fired.
If I was being let go (shortage of work) I wouldn’t even bother wanting to know why. I’ll collect my EI happily and milk out the company as much money as I can considering I’ve devoted years. I’ll be sure to steal office supplies before my departure too and I’m not returning the company computer. Paper? Taking it, pens, toilet paper, if I can take it, I AM TAKING IT.

JoePro_ · Answer

By the time they're firing you, they've already filed all the paperwork to make it happen. They have no option but to fire you at that point. Arguing will often times change nothing. If, however, you feel like you were wrongfully terminated, unproven accusations of a criminal nature, then I would consult with a lawyer. But if you otherwise feel like "Well, I mean, some of the stuff they said is kind of true..." Then just move on. Even if the "main thing" wasn't true, and they have other back up stuff about how you negatively impacted the company which is true, they have the upper hand. Find a new job.

Anonymous · Answer

There's no point in arguing. The decision has been made. Nothing you say will change that.

In the US, people are often offered a severance package in exchange for signing a legal agreement that they won't take legal action against the company. When I was fired, I asked for time to read the agreement. I took it to a lawyer who had other ideas. He sued and I got 6x the cash plus health insurance for a year. The insurance alone was worth $20,000.

msmissydc · Answer

I would argue with myself what I did wrong and why I would fire me.
Jokes asside, even as a selfemployed worker, I still need places to publish. If one would stop publishing me, I would want to know why, but I would not argue and just look for a new place.

Mangospacho · Answer

It’s pointless to argue with them but make it as uncomfortable and awkward as possible. The firing manager is going to try to wrap things up as soon as possible to avoid being uncomfortable themselves. Keep them talking for as long as possible.

RoseySarah · Answer

Why argue they never care about you and companies are never loyal.

You worked 15 years for us... Fired ops your our best worker? Fired

It is all sucking up numbers and privilege in a company no one ever cares for you higher up.

sophiejo · Answer

I've never been fired but there's no point trying to make them change their mind just accept to and use it as an opportunity to do better

OlderAndWiser · Answer

What do you gain by arguing? Do you really think you will convince them to change their decision? And if they do, would you be comfortable staying on a job where the manegement already said they don't want you?

BigD214 · Answer

I've never been fired. By the time I decide to leave, I'm usually making the company so much money that they offer me a raise or bonus if I stay. What I usually do is tell them I'll take care of finding a suitable replacement so they are not left at a disadvantage.

Bricealan · Answer

Oh hell no, I'll do just like the rest of the brainless, losers and take my AK 47 in and shoot everybody!!! Isn't that what losers do these days?

Med_guy1978 · Answer

I'd walk out with a smile in style. If they don't appreciate you just walk away and find somewhere where they appreciate you.

loveslongnails · Answer

I wouldn't argue, since they probably have their minds made up anyway. I'd want to know the reasons and get documentation of whatever you could, in case you want to pursue a wrongful firing case.

exitseven · Answer

I would just leave. Arguing will not help anything. If I could file a wrongful termination suit I would. Otherwise I would go right down to the unemployment office and sign up.

BoopBoopBeep · Answer

Just leave. You aren't going to change their mind, and even if you did, they'd just find something else to fire you for.

Kykiono1 · Answer

Id want a reason and if i can't do anything just leave. I wouldn't shake their hand

devilish-cutie · Answer

accept and leave, no use in arguing, beneath me

Chevy1_kb · Answer

Just seen yaa wouldn't wanna be yaa enjoy your life

AviatorTom · Answer

When I was laid off after 20 years, I didn't argue, just got my personal things and left.

Surely · Answer

Guess it would depend upon why you were being fired or let go. If their reason was good. Put your tail between your legs and leave.

Yannae · Answer

Accept. No need to waste any more of each other's time.

Nifrayu · Answer

I honestly don't know how I would react. I've never been fired from a job before.

AmeerX · Answer

Accept and leave. No point in arguing. Never works

msc545 · Answer

Accept and leave. Arguing gets you nothing and just makes it worse.

TallAnon · Answer

I did argue with them, didn't help much; Job interview in a few days. (Couldn't agree on my salary)

Nice222 · Answer

Probably just leave they already made up their mind

NathanDavis · Answer

I would go on my way

JacobJordan · Answer

No point arguing. Just move on

XXblack88 · Answer

I would leave

FunkyMonkee · Answer

It depends on why.

eagle1951 · Answer

say fck you and by

Danny_dan92 · Answer

I been fired only once. I just showed I was upset.

clampfan101 · Answer

Depends on why.

Bklynbadboy12 · Answer

Nope I'd leave. I couldn't wait to walk out lol

Tim-loves-it · Answer

Just leave.. no point in arguing.

OtterMan68 · Answer

no point in arguing

LunarEclipse433 · Answer

Call my lawyer

If you are getting fired from your job , would you argue with them or just accept and leave?

Most Helpful Opinions

Most Helpful Opinions

What Girls & Guys Said

If you are getting fired from your job , would you argue with them or just accept and leave?

Most Helpful Opinions

Most Helpful Opinions

What Girls & Guys Said

We're glad to see you liked this post.